ESPN: LT is MVP

[peplaw06]

Except that i'm trying to say that VY doesn't deserve it just as much as Grossman shouldn't even be talked about for MVP. VY is good but not as good as some people/and the media have made him out to be. For this year that is. That's the whole point. I could've said Rivers, but LT is on the team so I went with the next best thing with comparable stats to VY. Don't forget GROSSMAN IS A WINNER!

First of all, we're talking about MVP and ROY... two completely different awards with two completely different pools of deserving candidates.

Like gbrittain said... apples and oranges. You can't logically twist this thread into a VY hate-fest.

 

[cjonesfan921]

First of all, we're talking about MVP and ROY... two completely different awards with two completely different pools of deserving candidates.

Like gbrittain said... apples and oranges. You can't logically twist this thread into a VY hate-fest.

OK, people. Calm down. It was meant to be a joke, which obviously didn't land. Moving on.

 

[gbrittain]

OK, people. Calm down. It was meant to be a joke, which obviously didn't land. Moving on.

Alright then...but I will say you and John Kerry and have the same knack for telling jokes.

 

[Dale]

First of all, we're talking about MVP and ROY... two completely different awards with two completely different pools of deserving candidates.

Like gbrittain said... apples and oranges. You can't logically twist this thread into a VY hate-fest.

Oh, but he can try.

I think the better comparison would be Vince Young to Roethlisberger. Roethlisberger won the ROY award because of his W-L record and the difference he made on that team winning games. His QB rating was good if memory serves, but his per-game statistics were not. He was a bus driver of epic proportions. Yet he helped that team win and won the ROY.

Notice, however, he's never been in any MVP discussions.

 

[smarta5150]

No kidding.

44 votes

Brees - 4

P Manning - 2

Oops. My bad. Reeeeeeepost.