News: ESPN NFL QB Council: Ranking the top 10 quarterbacks in 12 different skills

[Reality]

 

[Rockport]

I think Dak should be much higher in the “Compete” category.

 

[Pantone282C]

Now, that was a comprehensive list of categories and top 10 QBs. Dak showed up on almost all the lists except for arm strength, where he came in as honorable mention as it were. He appears mostly about 6-8 out of ten. Reasonable listing, but I'm sure metrics gurus everywhere will argue the fine points of all the QBs.

 

[TwentyOne]

I think Dak should be much higher in the “Compete” category.

well they gave him the benefit of the doubt in all other categories.

seriously he shouldnt even be in that list, neither the conversation at all.

but i give you that: he has the it factor going for him. thats... and..... nothing else.

 

[Pantone282C]

I think Dak should be much higher in the “Compete” category.

I agree with your assessment.

 

[baltcowboy]

I did not see Carson Wentz name in any category. What is ESPN missing that Cowboys Zone sees?

 

[Rockport]

I did not see Carson Wentz name in any category. What is ESPN missing the Cowboys Zone sees?

No Andy Dalton either

 

[JoeKing]

This is just a peeing contest that doesn't mean anything. Dak is on most of the list but so what! I laugh hardily at those that take these lists seriously.

BSPN pushes this nonsense as if it matters.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

I did not see Carson Wentz name in any category. What is ESPN missing that Cowboys Zone sees?

Meanwhile, Wentz is already back and doing more in practice than Dak is currently doing.

Wentz should be ahead of Dak in that "toughness" category for sure.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Oh boy...the typical anti-Dak crowd is going to hate this. I'm sure they got excited when they saw he wasn't mentioned in "Compete" category....then they just kept scrolling and scrolling to find Dak omitted from everything else just for him to be added to everything.

Its a fair list.

Rarely you see people break down the QB position like that on these rankings...its usually just talking heads talking.

 

[jterrell]

Removing Dak from the equation the biggest thing I saw was a heinous overrating of Josh Allen.

Dude has literally had 1 season of quality football. He is the prototype physically but it feels like his bandwagon got awful full awful fast after some really poor seasons. He passed for under 200 ypg his first two NFL seasons both with a QBR below 50.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Removing Dak from the equation the biggest thing I saw was a heinous overrating of Josh Allen.

Dude has literally had 1 season of quality football. He is the prototype physically but it feels like his bandwagon got awful full awful fast after some really poor seasons. He passed for under 200 ypg his first two NFL seasons both with a QBR below 50.

Josh Allen is a top 6 QB right now.

 

[Rockport]

Meanwhile, Wentz is already back and doing more in practice than Dak is currently doing.

Wentz should be ahead of Dak in that "toughness" category for sure.

Here's a well known hater sticking up for another teams QB over our own. Can't make this stuff up.

 

[jterrell]

Josh Allen is a top 6 QB right now.

He's had 1 top 15 NFL QB season but A lot of folks agree w you.
He wasn't that good in college or high school and was pretty bad through 2 NFL season but he was definitely top 6 last season.

Guess we shall see.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Here's a well known hater sticking up for another teams QB over our own. Can't make this stuff up.

Being realistic = being hater in Rocky's mind.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

He's had 1 top 15 NFL QB season but A lot of folks agree w you.
He wasn't that good in college or high school and was pretty bad through 2 NFL season but he was definitely top 6 last season.

Guess we shall see.

Where do you think he should be ranked?

 

[jterrell]

Here's a well known hater sticking up for another teams QB over our own. Can't make this stuff up.

Mountaineer country is Steeler country.
Haters tend to hide their true allegiances here to troll.
Not sure if that's the case here but it certainly could be and it's easier to just place trolls on ignore if you catch an obvious pattern.

 

[MarcusRock]

So ESPN is now good again? Lol.

Funny that Watson has an asterisk next to his name everywhere.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Mountaineer country is Steeler country.
Haters tend to hide their true allegiances here to troll.
Not sure if that's the case here but it certainly could be and it's easier to just place trolls on ignore if you catch an obvious pattern.

If you're going to take Rocky's word on who a hater is then you might as well just consider the entire board haters.

Because anybody that doesn't agree with Rocky is a hater in his mind.

 

[CowboyFrog]

And the slobbers care more about Dak's stats and placement in meaningless lists than they do about winning. So tell me, where does Dak rank on the playoff win list?

Nick Foles is right behind Patrick Mahommes on your list and Jimmy G is on your list Cam newton...Tim Tebow....I could go on and on and on, BTW Big Ben is 2nd to Tom Brady on your list Blake Bortles...yes lets rank the active QB's on how they are going to do this year by playoff wins...Case Keenum..Marcus Mariota..Joe Flacco is well ahead of Patrick Mahommes and ahead of Wilson, Flacco is active. Its almost like playoff wins is about a team, like there is a full team that plays this sport....I know its crazy. Please let everyone know how your QB eye works by saying "I would take all of those over Dak" you already had it typed out just hit post.