ESPN: Two years after passing on a DT, could Cowboys go that route in first round?

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Two years after passing on a DT, could Cowboys go that route in first round?
March, 31, 2015
By Todd Archer | ESPNDallas.com

ncf_u_goldman01jr_576x324.jpg
Kim Klement/USA TODAY Sports

The Cowboys could stand to have a longer-term solution as a run-stuffing defensive tackle like Eddie Goldman.

IRVING, Texas -- In 2013, the Dallas Cowboys appeared ready to get a steal when defensive tackle Sharrif Floyd was available with the 18th pick in the first round.

Floyd, a defensive tackle, was the fifth-rated player on the Cowboys’ draft board. By sitting still, the Cowboys were going to get a player to fill a need at a great value.

But then the Cowboys made a trade with the San Francisco 49ers, holders of the 31st pick, leading to one of the more confusing moments in recent memory in their draft room. The easy explanation: The Cowboys didn’t view Floyd as a pass-rushing threat, and No. 18 would have been too early to take a run-stopping defensive tackle.

With the Cowboys moving to the 4-3 after an eight-year run in the 3-4 and a switch in defensive coaches, there was a lapse in communication between the scouting and coaching staffs that led Floyd to be the fifth-rated player on their board.

At least that’s the explanation the Cowboys gave. And as they get ready for the 2015 draft, the one-technique defensive tackle debate will continue again.

In his most recent mock draft, ESPN Insider Todd McShay had the Cowboys take Florida State defensive tackle Eddie Goldman with the 27th pick. Goldman had six sacks in his last two years at Florida State, and the scouting reports generally call him a terrific run stopper with only average pass-rushing skills.

Fellow ESPN Insider Mel Kiper has had the Cowboys take Jordan Phillips and Carl Davis in two of his first three mock drafts. Texas' Malcolm Brown might be more of a three-technique, but some view him as a run stopper as well.

So if No. 18 was too high for a player like Floyd two years ago, is No. 27 just right for a run-stopping defensive tackle in 2015?

Maybe not. Remember, most teams have 16-18 players with first-round grades. That’s the general number the Cowboys have had in recent years, so there would be a very real possibility their first-round pick would actually have a second-round grade. Travis Frederick, whom the Cowboys took with the 31st pick in the 2013 draft, had a second-round grade on their board.

In free agency, the Cowboys have added a high-profile defensive end in Greg Hardy, which could push them away from the spot at No. 27 this year. At defensive tackle, they have re-signed Nick Hayden, who has started every game the last two years.

By adding Hayden, the Cowboys have covered themselves at defensive tackle but could stand to have a longer-term younger solution as a run-stuffing defensive tackle like Goldman.


Todd Archer
ESPN Dallas Cowboys reporter

http://espn.go.com/blog/dallas/cowb...d-dallas-cowboys-go-that-route-in-first-round
 

Zekeats

theranchsucks
Messages
13,157
Reaction score
15,711
I hope not.......I don't want run stuffing anything in a pass happy league.
 

Cover 2

Pessimists Unite!!!
Messages
3,496
Reaction score
452
I like Eddie Goldman a lot, but I have to wonder how much they would value him. I'm not sure how many snaps he would get.

With a lot of teams going 3 wide would he play in the nickle, or would they slide Mincey or Hardy inside?

I'd still be fine if we took him though.
 

JoeyBoy718

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,715
Reaction score
12,709
Malcolm Brown has that position flexibility that Marinelli likes. He's a big boy (320, as big as Brent) with pass rush skills. I think he could beat out Hayden during training camp with ease.
 

Kaiser

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,628
Reaction score
28,430
I think this will be a smaller version of the Sherrif Floyd draft. Dallas will pass on drafting any DT and the fans will go nuts, but the young players already on the roster will do fine next year. Having Greg Hardy on the roster will make our DTs much better next year, plus you will get the normal development for second year players with Bishop, Coleman, Whaley, etc. Josh Brent will be much better with a full year of conditioning also.
 

JoeyBoy718

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,715
Reaction score
12,709
I think this will be a smaller version of the Sherrif Floyd draft. Dallas will pass on drafting any DT and the fans will go nuts, but the young players already on the roster will do fine next year. Having Greg Hardy on the roster will make our DTs much better next year, plus you will get the normal development for second year players with Bishop, Coleman, Whaley, etc. Josh Brent will be much better with a full year of conditioning also.

Bishop was my pet cat going into last year's draft. I was happy when we got him in the 7th. He didn't play much early on but he did in the playoffs. I'm thinking he might be given a chance to beat out Hayden for the 1-tech. I just don't want to see Hayden handed the job yet again. I'd rather see Hayden, Bishop and Brent compete for the job.
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,482
Reaction score
67,294
Malcolm Brown has that position flexibility that Marinelli likes. He's a big boy (320, as big as Brent) with pass rush skills. I think he could beat out Hayden during training camp with ease.

He is a far superior prospect to Goldman IMO.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,711
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I think this will be a smaller version of the Sherrif Floyd draft. Dallas will pass on drafting any DT and the fans will go nuts, but the young players already on the roster will do fine next year. Having Greg Hardy on the roster will make our DTs much better next year, plus you will get the normal development for second year players with Bishop, Coleman, Whaley, etc. Josh Brent will be much better with a full year of conditioning also.

I can see that happen. If they don't draft an immediate starter at DT then they don't have a big need for more mid/late developmental types.
 

reddyuta

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,514
Reaction score
17,236
right now it look like we are going to ignore the DT position completely unless a proper 3tech guy falls into our lap .
 

Manwiththeplan

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,268
Reaction score
7,763
while at the time I thought we made the right decision and hindsight has proved Dallas correct, I have to wonder if we went into that draft determined to take an o-lineman first or if we felt the need to once we saw a run of lineman. what ever the circumstances, I like what we ended up with, but typically when the #5 player on your board falls to #18, you make the pick. and while I don't watch the Vikings a bunch, just a look at his stats makes me think Floyd would have been a great pick. as well.
 
Top