ESPN: We were robbed!

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
22,114
Reaction score
23,483
ESPN reporters list 3 teams that felt like they were robbed by a bad call when playing the Cowboys.

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id...le-officiating-controversies-all-32-nfl-teams


Philadelphia Eagles
Dec. 9, 2018. That suggestion from safety Malcolm Jenkins came after a controversial call on the opening kickoff of the Eagles-Cowboys game that went in Dallas' favor and helped decide the division. Jenkins' hit on Jourdan Lewis caused a fumble that Kamu Grugier-Hill came out of the pile with. But the refs, citing "no clear recovery," gave possession to the Cowboys, denying the Eagles a huge momentum swing. "That was a pretty terrible call," Jenkins said. "So whoever's watching that in New York should stay off the bottle." -- Tim McManus

Detroit Lions
Jan. 4, 2015. There are many to choose from here over the past decade, from the Calvin Johnson catch rule to Calvin Johnson's batted ball out of the end zone to Trey Flowers' phantom hands-to-the-face against Green Bay. The call that still resonates, though, was the picked-up pass interference flag thrown on Dallas linebacker Anthony Hitchens in the Lions' wild-card game against Dallas.

The Lions were leading 20-17 and driving when the flag was thrown and then picked up on a third down. Instead of a first down putting Detroit in field goal range, the Lions punted, gave up a drive for a touchdown and lost 24-20, continuing the team's playoff losing streak. "That was trash," former Lions defensive lineman Darryl Tapp said at the time. The league then apologized for the missed call, but it mattered little with Detroit out of the playoffs. -- Michael Rothstein


Minnesota Vikings
The original Hail Mary, Dec. 28, 1975. Leading Dallas 14-10 with 24 seconds remaining in the divisional playoffs, the Vikings were the victims of a critical no-call after Cowboys quarterback Roger Staubach launched a prayer to Drew Pearson in the end zone. Pearson admitted years later that he used his "outside arm to get inside leverage on [Vikings cornerback] Nate Wright," which many thought was a deliberate push off that should have resulted in offensive pass interference.

Pearson caught the ball against his hip and ran into the end zone to give the Cowboys an eventual 17-14 edge over their NFC rival. The play ended Minnesota's run of two straight trips to the Super Bowl and caused such outrage inside Metropolitan Stadium that one fan launched a whiskey bottle at the head of official Armen Terzian, who was momentarily knocked unconscious. -- Courtney Cronin


 
The Lion one is so overblown. If you want to be honest, there were fouls by both players on that play so at best, it would have been off setting penalties and they try again. Not to mention I believe that call happened in the 3rd Q, hard to say that was the reason they lost the game when they couldn't score for over a quarter and it was their QB who fumbled the game away.
 
At some point you just have to put the trivial BS behind you. Especially for anyone in Minnesota who is still mad about the hail mary 45 years after it happened.

I do wonder, though, if Oilers fans are still mad about this blown call from 1980. This bad call prevented Houston from 'knocking the damn door down', as Bum Phillips used to say.

renfro2.PNG
 
Last edited:
1.Super bowl Cowboys / Colts Dave Manders clearly recovers the fumble.

2. Super bowl Cowboys / Steelers Benny Barnes did not interfere with John stallworth

3. NFC championship Cowboys / 49ers Deion Sanders clearly interferes with Michael Irvin.

That's three robberies right there now I get off my lawn:mad:
 
The Lions call was a bad call. That went in our favor but it shouldn't have.

Having said this, what's done is done.

All this does is make us mad. We can't change history otherwise, I'm eating my flag on the Benny Barnes bogus PI.

"Not going to go there. Not going to go there. Not going to go there."
 
The Lion one is so overblown. If you want to be honest, there were fouls by both players on that play so at best, it would have been off setting penalties and they try again. Not to mention I believe that call happened in the 3rd Q, hard to say that was the reason they lost the game when they couldn't score for over a quarter and it was their QB who fumbled the game away.

Right. The WR had his hand firmly placed on the linebackers facemask. That's why they picked up the flag IMO. How many times do you them call offsetting pass interference? They either call it on one, or not at all.

I have an issue with the Eagles one too. There has to be clear recovery after the whistle blows.

Vikings Hail Mary. Look closely at the play. Drew barely touched him. The field was horrible. All game players were slipping. The dude just slipped running that terrible defensive call.
 
ESPN reporters list 3 teams that felt like they were robbed by a bad call when playing the Cowboys.

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id...le-officiating-controversies-all-32-nfl-teams


Philadelphia Eagles
Dec. 9, 2018. That suggestion from safety Malcolm Jenkins came after a controversial call on the opening kickoff of the Eagles-Cowboys game that went in Dallas' favor and helped decide the division. Jenkins' hit on Jourdan Lewis caused a fumble that Kamu Grugier-Hill came out of the pile with. But the refs, citing "no clear recovery," gave possession to the Cowboys, denying the Eagles a huge momentum swing. "That was a pretty terrible call," Jenkins said. "So whoever's watching that in New York should stay off the bottle." -- Tim McManus

Detroit Lions
Jan. 4, 2015. There are many to choose from here over the past decade, from the Calvin Johnson catch rule to Calvin Johnson's batted ball out of the end zone to Trey Flowers' phantom hands-to-the-face against Green Bay. The call that still resonates, though, was the picked-up pass interference flag thrown on Dallas linebacker Anthony Hitchens in the Lions' wild-card game against Dallas.

The Lions were leading 20-17 and driving when the flag was thrown and then picked up on a third down. Instead of a first down putting Detroit in field goal range, the Lions punted, gave up a drive for a touchdown and lost 24-20, continuing the team's playoff losing streak. "That was trash," former Lions defensive lineman Darryl Tapp said at the time. The league then apologized for the missed call, but it mattered little with Detroit out of the playoffs. -- Michael Rothstein


Minnesota Vikings
The original Hail Mary, Dec. 28, 1975. Leading Dallas 14-10 with 24 seconds remaining in the divisional playoffs, the Vikings were the victims of a critical no-call after Cowboys quarterback Roger Staubach launched a prayer to Drew Pearson in the end zone. Pearson admitted years later that he used his "outside arm to get inside leverage on [Vikings cornerback] Nate Wright," which many thought was a deliberate push off that should have resulted in offensive pass interference.

Pearson caught the ball against his hip and ran into the end zone to give the Cowboys an eventual 17-14 edge over their NFC rival. The play ended Minnesota's run of two straight trips to the Super Bowl and caused such outrage inside Metropolitan Stadium that one fan launched a whiskey bottle at the head of official Armen Terzian, who was momentarily knocked unconscious. -- Courtney Cronin

What about Dez’ catch in GB?
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
474,012
Messages
14,506,558
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top