Feeling better about defense than offense

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
48,135
Reaction score
46,129
At the beginning of this year, I felt our defense was going to be far behind our offense and ultimately be what held us back from playoff success (as in previous years). However, as we go into this final game, I feel like we've seen some things we can build on with the defense while some needs on offense have materialized.

The defensive line was a primary concern heading into the season. DeMarcus Lawrence proved himself to be the defensive end I felt he could be while David Irving provided a punch at 3-tech when he either wasn't suspended or concussed. Taco Charlton also has come on to show that we might have a bookend to Lawrence, leaving getting a monster 1-tech as the primary need.

At linebacker, we were overreliant on Sean Lee, both because of how good he is and how bad the other linebackers were, but there were good reasons for this. Our other primary linebacker, Anthony Hitchens, missed the first part of the season, which forced Jaylen Smith into the starting lineup before he was ready after a year away from the game. The good new is, like Charlton, Smith has started to look like he could be a player. Dallas has to start planning for Lee's career ending, though, and needs to improve the depth of this unit, whether or not it brings Hitchens back.

In the secondary, we also had our struggles adjusting to letting three-fourths of last year's starters go. Orlando Scandrick seemed to be our only reliable starter at the beginning of the season but went downhill quickly because of injuries. Nolan Carroll was a bust, Brown regressed and Jeff Heath and Byron Jones were hit and miss as the starting safeties (with both of them mainly being misses in run support). However, hope arrived in the form of three rookies who have stepped into leading roles. Both Chidobe Awusie and Jourdan Lewis look like they belong as starters and Xavier Woods has handled any role he's been given well. This allowed Brown to be a spot player and has made playing an injured Scandrick unnecessary. It also appears that we learned that neither Heath nor Jones is suited to be a run-support safety. Heath plays his best as a center fielder and Jones plays his best when given a specific coverage assignment, Kavon Frazier has taken on a role more like Church's had been in situational defense, but we need to bring in a starting strong safety who can handle that and not be a liability in pass coverage.

So our needs on defense are monster NT, starting strong safety and linebacker depth. I think we can get this by drafting a space-eater in either the first or second round, bring in a top FA at safety (which would give us an experienced starter to pair with the youth in the secondary), and spending several back-end picks on linebackers. If we do that, then we use a couple of our earlier picks to address holes on offense.

So here's a list of our needs and how I think we should address them:

WR: First- or second-round pick on player with downfield speed

NT: First- or second-round pick on space eater, plus veteran

SS: Top FA

LB: Multiple picks after second round (re-sign Hitchens if fairly cheap)

TE: Give Gathers chance to take some of Witten's snaps (if he fails, then TE becomes the priority in 2019)

OL: Re-sign Cooper or bring in FA starter, draft for depth after second round

(This is assuming, of course, that we re-sign or tag Lawrence and first-round tender David Irving.)

I'd also like to see us do something with the fullback position. I like Keith Smith, but if we could find an H-back or fullback who blocks as well but is more of a receiving threat, it would put more stress on the defense.
 
My opinion on needs in order

1. Coverage Linebacker

2. Offensive Tackle (I know we have Quality starters but you saw what happened when Smith was out and I doubt we ever see 16 games from him again)

3. Pressure players on the DL

4. Safety

5. TE

6. WR ( Our WRs are fine but our coaches need to step their game up. Dez is right about them all falling off at the same time not being a coincedence).

I do agree about the run stuffer in the middle. It would help our linebackers out a lot.
 
3. Pressure players on the DL.

I do think we should look for a pass-rushing specialist. One of those smaller, quicker players we can use in clear passing situations. It would be nice if Gregory could be that player, but it appears that ship has sailed. Mayowa was brought in as that kind of player, but hasn't given us near the pass rush we need from that role.

I think Lawrence and Charlton could be the starters at DE, with the pass rushing specialist subbing in and Crawford/Irving getting some snaps there. Then Irving/Collins could rotate at 3-tech, with Crawford getting some snaps there and the veteran/draft pick rotating at 1-tech. We could also keep a player or two from Mayowa, Ash, Tapper and Neal for depth, but I don't think any of them would be a big loss.
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,671
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top