For or Against signing Vinny if we end up adding a 4th QB?

[Qwickdraw]

If BP decided that we needed to add a 4th QB to the roster based on Romo and Henson not being ready, would you be for or against adding Testaverde?

I probably don't even need to ask this question.
I'm also probably in the grand minority of people who think VT would be a viable backup in the event that Romo and Henson aren't ready.
Anyone else you bring in might ultimately cause a real QB contraversy.

 

[Doomsday101]

If BP decided that we needed to add a 4th QB to the roster based on Romo and Henson not being ready, would you be for or against adding Testaverde?

I probably don't even need to ask this question.
I'm also probably in the grand minority of people who think VT would be a viable backup in the event that Romo and Henson aren't ready.
Anyone else you bring in might ultimately cause a real QB contraversy.

I agree with you about Vinny's ability as a backup but no I don't think Dallas adds a 4th QB. If Vinny is brought in someone will be released.

 

[CactusCowboy]

If we just had to, I would be for it.

 

[Rack]

We aren't gonna add a 4th QB.


I'm against bringing Vinny in cuz that would mean we're cutting a promising young QB (Romo or Henson).

 

[jksmith269]

Nope I'd rather have Tim Couch than VT

 

[Qwickdraw]

Okay, assume that we cut one of the youngins and there's no getting around it.
How bout now?

At least VT would be returning to an offense, team, etc. that he is familiar with.

 

[LaTunaNostra]

If Bledsoe goes down the season is over anyway.

Love Vin the man, but haven't loved Vin the player since 98.

No. No. A million times no. He'd look better with a healthy T and JJ, but he sure couldn't compensate for a D that gave up over 400 points, OR for one that will be implementing a new scheme and integrating rookies.

The QB this year has to CARRY the team. VT cannot.

And why Testaverde would want to suffer the indignity again is beyond me.

 

[baj1dallas]

The ONLY circumstances I want to see Testaverde brought back in is if:

1 Bledsoe gets hit by a bus
2 Romo comes down with the plague
3 In a gravity defying move, Ray Lucas actually falls off the face of the earth.

 

[Sportsbabe]

Against, as any #. I saw enough interceptions from Vinny last year. I'm convinced.

 

[Doomsdayblitz]

We've got to get a veteran in here, & I feel Vinnie did an admiral job, for what he had to work with. He did have two receivers right at the 1,000 yd. mark, & a RB that would have easily surpassed it, if not for injury. That pretty much sums up 2004..."If not for the injuries".

 

[LaTunaNostra]

3 In a gravity defying move, Ray Lucas actually falls off the face of the earth.

LOL

Ray's in broadcasting now....did a few NFLE games and was GREAT at it, so if anyone's been harboring THAT particular Tuna reunion fear, rest easy.

 

[Arch Stanton]

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooo way!

Not again! Lets try and find a future QB from what we have.

 

[laythewood28]

I'd rather see woody dantzler running the option.

 

[LaTunaNostra]

I'd rather see woody dantzler running the option.

Or Patrick Crayton.

(and I say that only half joking)

 

[calico]

You know you want it.

 

[ABQCOWBOY]

I would bring Vinnie back as a back up.

 

[Crown Royal]

You know you want it.

Ugliest man in football. Ever.

 

[SupermanXx]

I would rather see Willie Blade at QB running bootlegs in 14.3 seconds and lobbing 15 yard bombs than seeing the 60 year old Vinterception anywhere near the state of Texas

 

[joseephuss]

My personal opinion is that Vinny the QB sucks and always has.

Setting aside my personal view. Vinny's play last season was'nt inspiring and he got all the reps. As a back up, he would probably receive little to any reps in practice. I don't think that bodes well if Bledsoe were injured. I understand that the young kids would probably face the same thing. I just think that this year isn't only about this year. Dallas is playing for the now and the for the future. Bringing in Vinny really slows the progress of the future.

Keeping four QBs on the roster would also be a detriment to the growth of the team at another position. There already may be some hard choices as to how many RBs, O-lineman, d-lineman and defensive backs to keep. That 4th QB would mean losing a young promising player for a guy that hasn't been called by other teams.

 

[speedemn]

I'm all for vinny coming in....