I don't disagree about Gilbert potential the hard part is living up to that potential. He has the tools but as a player entering his 2nd year of college he has to step up and take over the team and produce.
Chris Simms had allot of the tools you speak of but never was able to get the players behind him like Applewhite did who had much less in terms of physical ability than Simms.
Believe me I'm 110% behind Gilbert but just as Colt had to overcome Vince Young, Gilbert will have to overcome both Young and Colt.
Texas fans have been use to watching the spread option with both Young and McCoy with their ability to pull the ball down and gain yards on the ground, now we will go back to more of a conventional style of offense and Gilbert will have allot of pressure on him and I'm looking forward to see how he handles that