FWST: Just Chill: Crayton's downfall, Choice's rise and Ratliff's great play... more

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,281
Reaction score
45,652
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Just Chill: Crayton's downfall, Choice's rise and Ratliff's great play, among other observations


* Three years after the crucial dropped pass in the playoff game against the Giants that may have changed the course of history, receiver Patrick Crayton is firmly on the hot seat.

Crayton will lose his starting job opposite Roy Williams to breakout performer Miles Austin. Austin needs to be on the field because he is a big-play threat. Crayton will become the third receiver.

Remember, also, Crayton had what should have been a fumble on the first series of the game, but the official wrongly ruled that his forward progress had been stopped.

Coach Wade Phillips has been defending Crayton's performance as the punt returner for at least that long as well.

After his muffed punt against the Chiefs, the Cowboys have found a replacement there. Dallas native Allen Rossum is a free agent and he has history with special teams coach Joe DeCamillis. He will be signed on Wednesday.

* Rossum's return is a nice homecoming for the Dallas Skyline product. But let's not get too carried away about him being a game-breaking returner.

He averaged only 21.7 yards on kickoff returns in three games this season, although he did have touchdown returns on kickoffs in 2007 and 2008. As far as punts go, Rossum has averaged less than nine yards a return in five of the last six years and was averaging just seven yards a return in three games this season with the 49ers.

His last touchdown on a punt return was in 2004.

* But yes, Rossum still has more juice in his legs than Crayton and might make something happen at times when Crayton couldn't. Crayton has never taken a return to the house. But Rossum's value will be his experience.

He will not muff punts. He will not misjudge punts. He will not let balls bounce and give away field position. On kickoff returns, he will give the Cowboys an option other than Austin and Felix Jones.

Austin will be a starter at receiver, so he needs the rest. Jones has had problems staying healthy. Seeing how much they need him on offense, the Cowboys don't need to take any more chances with him on returns when he comes back from the sprained knee.

* What shouldn't be lost in Miles Austin's big day was his horrible start to the game. Never has someone gone from getting cursed out to being celebrated so quickly.

Austin dropped two touchdown passes in the first half before the glorious run to history at the finish. He had a 59-yard catch-and-run in the fourth quarter and then the 60-yard sprint to the end zone in overtime. He is too big of a threat not to have on the field.

But his start to the game is proof that he is still a work in progress and prone to inconsistency. As Bill Parcells used to say, let's not put him in Canton just yet.

Still, there are legitimate reasons to be excited about his performance. The catch-and-runs for touchdowns were great plays, but he had a catch over the middle where he had to go high for a ball and absorb contact to convert a third down that was pretty sweet.

Also, don't forget the deep ball down the right sideline that he simply took away from the defender who was in better position.

* Dropped passes were a huge problem against the Chiefs. Austin had two passes he should have come up with in the end zone.

Crayton had a drop and a near fumble. Sam Hurd had a drop in the end zone. And Jason Witten let quarterback Tony Romo down by not coming up with a deep pass in the second half.

It would have been a tough catch. But it was one a Pro Bowler like Witten should come up with.

* Let's just be real here. The Cowboys are too nice. That's the only explanation for Wade Phillips not coming out and saying that Austin was replacing Crayton in the starting lineup. What is this, Little League?

It was no different last year when he let Greg Ellis run on the field with the starting lineup, only to replace him with Anthony Spencer when the game started. They are too nice. Too worried about hurting someone's feelings.

Their nice ways are hurting the team. There is no question that Marion Barber is the team's best back when healthy. But he is not healthy right now. And the stubborn decision to continue to start him in front of Tashard Choice hurt the Cowboys the last two weeks.

Barber left yards on the field because he is still bothered by a strained quad. Choice should have gotten more carries against the Chiefs, as proved by his 36-yard touchdown and 92 yards on eight carries.

Barber broke through the line several times and couldn't finish the play. Maybe if it would have been Choice, we might be talking about him a having a record-setting performance on Sunday instead of Austin. Yes, the Chiefs were that bad on defense.

* I talked last week about linebacker Keith Brooking already becoming a leader on this team. Well, he is also quite a player, even at his advanced age. He was all over the field against the Chiefs with 18 tackles and a sack. Look for him to take it up another notch after the bye when the Cowboys face his old team, the Atlanta Falcons, who thought he was too old to still play.

* Now that the dam has broke for linebacker DeMarcus Ware, with two sacks against the Chiefs after going sackless for the last five games dating back to last year, look for him to start racking up some sack numbers.

Ware has been close all season with pressures and hits on the quarterback. He just hasn't gotten there. So its not like hasn't been playing well.

As he showed last year, when the sacks start coming, they come in bunches. Look for him to start piling up the numbers and ringing the cash register as talks continue with the Cowboys for a contract extension.

* Jay Ratliff's blocked field goal was a thing of beauty. He sized the Chiefs up earlier in the game. His leap over the deep snapper was timed perfectly. It showed his instincts and outstanding athleticism.

There is not a more athletic nose tackle in the game. Albert Haynesworth, Casey Hampton or Vince Woolfork couldn't do it. But Ratliff did have help from his teammates. Igor Olshansky and Jason Hatcher both pushed their respective blockers down to help Ratliff have a lane to jump over.

-- Clarence E. Hill Jr.


Posted at 04:17 AM | Permalink | Comments (5) | TrackBack (0)
 

stilltheguru

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,457
Reaction score
14,361
Brooking, Austin, Ratliff and Choice. Cowboys that demand your respect. Period
 

ROUSH8692

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,581
Reaction score
368
I dont know why we kept using Barber. It was obvious their run D was vulnerable and Choice exploited it more and more with every opportunity. Let Barber get better. Were gonna need him later.

If we would have allowed him to rest up he may have already been 100% for Atlanta. Instead we will have to deal with a Barber that breaks out into the open for a measly 5 yard gain, when just 3 weeks ago that wouldve been a TD.....

Way to put your foot down Wade. Who cares how much he wants to play, look at the big picture. Look at the interest of the franchise. Cant argue his heart is there though. I love MBIII
 

Gaede

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,165
Reaction score
14,127
ROUSH8692;3017381 said:
I dont know why we kept using Barber. It was obvious their run D was vulnerable and Choice exploited it more and more with every opportunity. Let Barber get better. Were gonna need him later.

If we would have allowed him to rest up he may have already been 100% for Atlanta. Instead we will have to deal with a Barber that breaks out into the open for a measly 5 yard gain, when just 3 weeks ago that wouldve been a TD.....

Way to put your foot down Wade. Who cares how much he wants to play, look at the big picture. Look at the interest of the franchise. Cant argue his heart is there though. I love MBIII

Just another one of those decisions that indicts the coaching staff...So unwilling to make a change to their grandmaster plan that they'll play an injured, limited and relatively ineffective player at the expense of a) the game b) the player's season.

Just like the team, the coaches make really dumb decisions that are hard to justify.
 

RealCowboyfan

Championship
Messages
4,587
Reaction score
1
ROUSH8692;3017381 said:
I dont know why we kept using Barber. It was obvious their run D was vulnerable and Choice exploited it more and more with every opportunity. Let Barber get better. Were gonna need him later.

If we would have allowed him to rest up he may have already been 100% for Atlanta. Instead we will have to deal with a Barber that breaks out into the open for a measly 5 yard gain, when just 3 weeks ago that wouldve been a TD.....

Way to put your foot down Wade. Who cares how much he wants to play, look at the big picture. Look at the interest of the franchise. Cant argue his heart is there though. I love MBIII


True talk. But at the same time I believe Barber should allow himself time but I believe being that he has that big contract and he's consider hurt he wants to show Jerry Jones he's worth the money and he don't need to be traded to another because of Tashard Choice...
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
84,022
Reaction score
76,730
Yea that's what's mind boggling about all of these guys who are clamoring to Miles Austin like he's Mike Irvin in his prime. Yes he should start but let's not get carried away. He dropped TWO TD'S. TWO. Had he caught both or hell even one that game is ours without going to OT. He's still a work in progress and he's going to struggle and when he does don't write him off as fast as you guys are anointing him.


Gaede;3017394 said:
Just another one of those decisions that indicts the coaching staff...So unwilling to make a change to their grandmaster plan that they'll play an injured, limited and relatively ineffective player at the expense of a) the game b) the player's season.

Just like the team, the coaches make really dumb decisions that are hard to justify.

I Didn't have a problem with it. Having Barber in there had two change of pace backs. I think having Barber in there is how Choice had so much success. The defense wasn't ready for him and Choice wasn't fatigued since he hadn't played. My only complaint was not giving Choice more carries.
 

NoLuv4Jerry

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,698
Reaction score
4,911
now THIS is how you write an article...complete with facts, opinoin (soaked in REAL football IQ), some positive, some negative.
 

theebs

Believe!!!!
Messages
27,462
Reaction score
9,207
CATCH17;3017571 said:
I could've swore he had one against the Dolphins.


no he didnt score on that play, it was a big one, but I think he got hit out of bounds at like the 20 or the 18.
 

Iago33

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,541
Reaction score
1,380
Good article.

I still haven't figured out why the coaching staff is so concerned about hurting people's feelings by not starting them or sitting them down. There's being nice and there's being stupid. This falls into the latter category.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,666
Reaction score
86,212
theebs;3017574 said:
no he didnt score on that play, it was a big one, but I think he got hit out of bounds at like the 20 or the 18.

Ok maybe I remember it because it was the only big return he ever had lol.
 

GimmeTheBall!

Junior College Transfer
Messages
37,696
Reaction score
18,043
Why is Crayfish the fall guy all of the sudden.

Why does ever one feel that RW deserves a starting job as he comes off an injury? What has RW done to deserve a starting role. Crayfish has been working hard while RW was pouting and injured.
Head to head, I pick Crayfish as my receiver over RW. Any day.

We need to come to the realization that just because we gave the ranch away in draft picks for the very average RW doesn't mean we are married to him forever. Or that he deserves a starting job by default.

Get real, people.
 

burmafrd

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,820
Reaction score
3,379
Never seizes to amaze me how coaches will still play someone who needs rest to fully heal when they DO NOT NEED TO. Choice has already proven he can carry the load by himself. Yet still the staff keeps playing Barber who clearly needed more time to heal. JUST PLAIN DUMB.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,666
Reaction score
86,212
burmafrd;3017612 said:
Never seizes to amaze me how coaches will still play someone who needs rest to fully heal when they DO NOT NEED TO. Choice has already proven he can carry the load by himself. Yet still the staff keeps playing Barber who clearly needed more time to heal. JUST PLAIN DUMB.

Because Choice still has mental mistakes in pass blocking.

Barbers blocking was a big factor last Sunday in the game.
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,920
Reaction score
112,968
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Wow great article. The best one I've read all season. Solid points and solid arguments to back them up. Just a gread read.
 

slick325

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,516
Reaction score
9,346
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I disagree that Felix shouldn't be returning kickoffs. Yes, he has been injured (each time during routine offensive plays) however, he NEEDS as many touches as possible because he is an impact player. Kickoffs is just another way to get the ball in our playmaker's hands.
 

wileedog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,356
Reaction score
2,393
CATCH17;3017616 said:
Because Choice still has mental mistakes in pass blocking..

Are you sure you guys are not confusing him with Felix? I don't remember Choice making many blocking mistakes at all when he started last season, or any big one's this year either.
 

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,529
Reaction score
29,875
stilltheguru;3017370 said:
Brooking, Austin, Ratliff and Choice. Cowboys that demand your respect. Period

You need to add Ware and Witten to your list.
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,335
Reaction score
64,035
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
GimmeTheBall!;3017607 said:
Why is Crayfish the fall guy all of the sudden.

Why does ever one feel that RW deserves a starting job as he comes off an injury? What has RW done to deserve a starting role. Crayfish has been working hard while RW was pouting and injured.
Head to head, I pick Crayfish as my receiver over RW. Any day.

We need to come to the realization that just because we gave the ranch away in draft picks for the very average RW doesn't mean we are married to him forever. Or that he deserves a starting job by default.

Get real, people.
This is either: a) comedic genius or b) some of the best fantasy football-based fiction ever written.
 

kramskoi

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,387
Reaction score
1,765
GimmeTheBall!;3017607 said:
Why is Crayfish the fall guy all of the sudden.

Why does ever one feel that RW deserves a starting job as he comes off an injury? What has RW done to deserve a starting role. Crayfish has been working hard while RW was pouting and injured.
Head to head, I pick Crayfish as my receiver over RW. Any day.

We need to come to the realization that just because we gave the ranch away in draft picks for the very average RW doesn't mean we are married to him forever. Or that he deserves a starting job by default.

Get real, people.

...it's what the guy costs...for better or worse, the Cowboys are going to have to live with Williams, considering the release of Owens...

...Austin is an undrafted talent, while Williams is a top draft choice with much more experience...

...Roy is the guy that'll get taken away and if defenses want to limit your number of catches there are certainly ways to do it...Owens had games where he went off and games where he finished with a whisper...

...curiously, i don't hear anything about Jason Witten, who did'nt have a stellar day either last sunday...he's gone a little MIA the past few games...

...this clamoring for Austin has reached a rather histrionic pitch...how soon some forget the Bailey INT, where he went in when he should've gone out, costing the Cowboys a chance of actually winning that game, had they scored a TD on that drive...

...i like Miles, but one game is a small sample size and he said himself that he's only "half-built"...

...with his inexperience i can say for certain that if Austin is the best receiver on the Cowboys roster then they are in more trouble than once thought...
 
Top