Garrett ranked 17th?

waving monkey

waving monkey

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,540
Reaction score
14,930
Sydla said:
Again, he's won ONE PLAYOFF GAME in 6 years. So no, he's not exactly a "winning" coach as I would define it. He needs to start delivering in the postseason starting now. Coaches are defined in the playoffs, not what they do in the regular season.

Belicheck, McCarthy, Carroll, Payton, Tomlin are SB winning coaches who have performed in the playoffs. Reid is a better coach. Then you have guys like O'Brien, Rivera, Arians who might be better.
Click to expand...
Again he won 13 games in 2014/12 games in 16. Of course he has an incredible staff but all winning teams do.
Play off wins are coming. It really is a process
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,895
Reaction score
95,590
waving monkey said:
Again he won 13 games in 2014/12 games in 16. Of course he has an incredible staff but all winning teams do.
Play off wins are coming. It really is a process
Click to expand...

And single digits wins in 2015.

Process. 6 years in. LOL. When is the process over? Guys have turned around teams much faster than this.

It doesn't matter what you think is coming, judging coaches now is largely based off what they have done. And right now, what Garrett has accomplished doesn't make him a Top 10 coach most likely. Again, 6 years in and one freaking playoff win. There's little doubt if that was the resume of one of our rivals, you wouldn't be so bullish.
 
waving monkey

waving monkey

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,540
Reaction score
14,930
Sydla said:
And single digits wins in 2015.

Process. 6 years in. LOL. When is the process over? Guys have turned around teams much faster than this.

It doesn't matter what you think is coming, judging coaches now is largely based off what they have done. And right now, what Garrett has accomplished doesn't make him a Top 10 coach most likely. Again, 6 years in and one freaking playoff win. There's little doubt if that was the resume of one of our rivals, you wouldn't be so bullish.
Click to expand...
The process is never over grasshopper
 
ghst187

ghst187

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,722
Reaction score
11,572
To me 17 is quite high for him. He is terrible, one of the worst I've seen at managing his players and the flow of the game to the point it has cost us a lot of losses to include at least one playoff game. I think he's had more than a fair share of talent and still little to show for it. The fact he couldn't win a game when Romo went down two seasons ago I thought was telling while those same QBs went elsewhere and were passable for a few games. Frankly, there is nothing I can point to and say Garrett has done a good job with. I think the games we have won almost anyone coaching would have won and in a lot of cases we won despite of Garrett. Outside of the gutter coaches like Kelly, I can't think of very many coaches I'd rank Garrett ahead of. IMO he might be better than Campo, maybe although Campo never got this long at the helm and he never had any talent to work with.
 
CATCH17

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,718
Reaction score
86,322
Have we ever made the playoffs in back to back years with Garrett?
 
RS12

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,643
Reaction score
30,247
Sydla said:
He's won one playoff game in 6 seasons.

One.

Where would the author rank him? 17 might be a bit low but he's not Top Ten either.
Click to expand...
And that was on a very questionable non PI call. Only made the playoffs twice in six and a half years.
 
Idgit

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
This isn't a consensus ranking, this is 'what Pete Prisco thinks.' It's low, and it's still quite a bit higher than most of his detractors around here.
 

cowboyblue22

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,031
Reaction score
8,707
17 th is about right for a coach with his playoff success one win in 6 seasons
 
Zekeats

Zekeats

theranchsucks
Messages
13,181
Reaction score
15,751
Romo and now Dak win despite garret. The only real reason for the 2 successful season in the past 3 years is ripping the playbook out of Jason's hands and sticking to the running game....it's a process
 

Frosty

Bigdog24
Messages
3,960
Reaction score
2,257
stasheroo said:
It's funny, if you're not ranked number one, you feel slighted. There's no in between.
Click to expand...

Oh Yes there is...Jason Garrett has been .500 coach his entire career. About the middle of the pack as you can get...right up there with Jeff Fisher...oh wait..Fisher made it to a Superbowl...never mind My Bad...what was I thinking...1 playoff and done is the best Garret can do.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top