I’m just not a big fan of older backs.
Unless your last name is Gore...running back js a young man’s sport. I would prefer to have a high upside mid round draft pick with some breakaway speed behind Zeke than a couple backs that would have a hard time finding another team if we cut them.
In my resrarch I discovered a general trend
You can find a productive back in any round. However, 1st Round picks typically have much longer careers with productuve seasons.
Of the ten seasons in which a RB, 32 years or older had a thousand yard season, 8 of them were 1st rounders. Five were top ten overall....like McFadden.
Beaides, they didn't put him on ice becauae Rod Smith was better, folks. He is still bihgwt, faster, and a far more accomplished reciever..
Just like they do sometimes in baaketball, the "dumb" coach kept the old veteran McFadden fresh just to make sure his age disn't become a stamina issue at the end of the season.
McFadden'a season will be 11 games. Elliot will not be in playoff shape and may not be ready to carry the load.
It could be that the real MVP of the season was the guy all the other NFL fans forgot.