Why can't you just let the guy show what he can do before you disregard him and kick him to the curb?
He just might surprise all of us. Do you really think the coaches that know about him would still have him on the team?
I'd be fine with letting him. When exactly does that happen. It's been 'next week' since they signed him!
If he can't stay on the field now - running against air! - why would I expect that he'll be available when the team truly needs him?
The guy hasn't played football for 6 months and he still manages to be injured. The adage is simple but true. You can't help the club in the tub. And the most important ability is AVAILability.
I view this team as a championship contender. But a contender that needs to find some answers for a key departure at running back. Thus far, McFadden has brought only more questions.
McFadden's situation since he's arrived has been both frustrating and concerning.