Half this board thinks the players are bad, the coaches are bad; more think the QB is bad

FuzzyLumpkins

The Boognish
Messages
36,544
Reaction score
27,835
I pay attention when people are talking about football as it is played on the field. When people are looking to blame someone or something it is an emotional response as opposed to a reasoned one. I think of it as copium for people that struggle to process their feelings.
 

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
61,652
Reaction score
39,022
The problem I see with the Cowboys, it’s always a tale of two seasons. Earlier in the season they’ll find their stride and as the season wears on and we start approaching December they begin to fade. It’s been a troubling trend. Earlier in the season the defense was playing tremendous. Our pass rush was second to none. Once Dak returned our offense started to click and it appeared we might end up with a great team. Then all of a sudden we blew a 14 point lead to Green Bay and the defense started to crack. Our great pass rush disappeared and Parsons play fell off. Dak has become a very up-and-down QB who throws INT’s every week. He’s never returned to the player he was early last season.

He’s regressing and if it continues into next season then he may not be extended after his contract. The team we have right now is not the team we had early in the season that won four straight games under Cooper Rush. The defense is a shell of what it was earlier in the season. We would have gone 0-5 with the team we have now with Cooper Rush at QB. Dak has certainly been part of the problem but anyone who thinks we would be sailing along just fine with Cooper Rush is clueless! It’s puzzling as to why the Cowboys can’t maintain their level of play throughout a season. They always peak early and fade. The same thing has happened under different head coaches. It’s really hard to put your finger on exactly why this continues to happen but it’s extremely frustrating and disheartening.
 
Messages
10,075
Reaction score
7,296
CowboysZone DIEHARD Fan
The game was lost from Monday thru Saturday

From our coach of the year? Surely not! It was Jason Garrett holding this talented juggernaut back all those years so no excuses.
On a brighter note, the Detroit Lions may have delivered the high point of the season for us by giving Green Bay and Rodgers what they deserve... big fat season ending loss. Thank you Dan Campbell, you're my hero. :flagwave:
 

KMY_Amber

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,739
Reaction score
1,650
As for coaches, whatever. Fans purely assess plays in hindsight. Did it work, it was a good play. Did it not work, it was a bad play. That's pretty much worthless analysis in my view.
Nope, not me. I don't look at the stats, or the final score. They're often misleading. So even when the Cowboys have a "good day" and win, I still critique the obvious deficiencies.

And one of the obvious deficiencies is the lack of urgency in the 1st quarter, often lasting all half. And it's not just the offense's lack of urgency early, the defense's as well.

Moore's early game plans often don't produce early scores, because the plays are just too predictable. Everyone knows those stretch run plays are coming, and you can even predict which direction they're going to run by formation. It's just too vanilla.

And on defense, the Cowboys tend to almost play bend-but-don't-break early, with vanilla, easy-to-read formations. Very little creativity early in games with disguised pressure or even "threatening" pressure.

Moore and Quinn seemingly don't have any customized game plans or plays dependent upon the opponent. And if they think they can start slow in the playoffs and then "turn it on" later in the game, opening up the playbook as the game proceeds, well, that's a real risk, especially on the road, allowing the crowd to make its presence known.

So, no, this is not about the Cowboys' record, or their good stats overall...because on paper, they look formidable.

But in reality, with Moore and Quinn leading them, and McCarthy not making much of an imprint on most of these games, it's hard to feel confident that they could ever "outcoach" their opponent. So then it's ALL on the players to simply outperform the opponents, on every play. I don't like their odds if it just comes down to everyone having to play "above their heads". The fundamentals tend to count more in the playoffs, all the little stuff...and in many games, the Cowboys don't do the little things well, especially not early in games.

I complain when they win, even when they blow out opponents because of an avalanche of turnovers or some flashy plays by star players...because it's ultimately, it's about consistency.

Of course, the board doesn't like to read negative posts after wins, because those posts almost sound like "trolls". The claim is that many fans are just debbie-downers, only wanting to see the Cowboys lose. Nope, it's just that some fans aren't surprised by today's results....because they see the deficiencies in the Cowboys' tendencies and players even after wins, and know that they can and will be easily exploited, especially in the playoffs.

I just don't trust this coaching staff, and so then it's hard to count on Dak, Zeke/Pollard, Micah, D Law, and Diggs simply "outplaying" Tom and the Tampa Dee on Monday night.
 

Yoshimitsu

Lurch
Messages
4,375
Reaction score
4,317
I don't care about regular season success. This fanbase is starving for some playoff success as and this team continues to show us why no one believes.
 

InPhiltraitor

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,171
Reaction score
1,320
I don’t think the players are bad, but I do believe they’re overrated. We have a couple high profile players with the balance having average to slightly better that average abilities. When the Cowboys field a legit plus .500 team, the media pounces on “All that talent”. Just not realistic.

Can’t say that I’ve been blown away with the coaching staff, particularly game management situations, but I think they’re somewhat hand-cuffed with the product they work with. Perhaps the converse is true as well with the coaching staff inhibiting creativity.

Our QB, it’s easy to jump on him right now, and he definitely does deserve some flak for recent performances. However, I don’t believe he’s working with windows as large as many other QB’s and why are we such an inept screen team?

Ultimately, I point my finger at that front office. I defended it for years, but what other GM has had a 25 year stretch with so little playoff success. I guess no one close to Jerry has the nerve to clue him in on the definition of insanity. I don't know if it's ignorance or arrogance (little bit of both?) that keeps the Jones' from recognizing that they may be better served by inviting someone else to the dinner table.
 

john van brocklin

Captain Comeback
Messages
39,739
Reaction score
44,949
Nope, not me. I don't look at the stats, or the final score. They're often misleading. So even when the Cowboys have a "good day" and win, I still critique the obvious deficiencies.

And one of the obvious deficiencies is the lack of urgency in the 1st quarter, often lasting all half. And it's not just the offense's lack of urgency early, the defense's as well.

Moore's early game plans often don't produce early scores, because the plays are just too predictable. Everyone knows those stretch run plays are coming, and you can even predict which direction they're going to run by formation. It's just too vanilla.

And on defense, the Cowboys tend to almost play bend-but-don't-break early, with vanilla, easy-to-read formations. Very little creativity early in games with disguised pressure or even "threatening" pressure.

Moore and Quinn seemingly don't have any customized game plans or plays dependent upon the opponent. And if they think they can start slow in the playoffs and then "turn it on" later in the game, opening up the playbook as the game proceeds, well, that's a real risk, especially on the road, allowing the crowd to make its presence known.

So, no, this is not about the Cowboys' record, or their good stats overall...because on paper, they look formidable.

But in reality, with Moore and Quinn leading them, and McCarthy not making much of an imprint on most of these games, it's hard to feel confident that they could ever "outcoach" their opponent. So then it's ALL on the players to simply outperform the opponents, on every play. I don't like their odds if it just comes down to everyone having to play "above their heads". The fundamentals tend to count more in the playoffs, all the little stuff...and in many games, the Cowboys don't do the little things well, especially not early in games.

I complain when they win, even when they blow out opponents because of an avalanche of turnovers or some flashy plays by star players...because it's ultimately, it's about consistency.

Of course, the board doesn't like to read negative posts after wins, because those posts almost sound like "trolls". The claim is that many fans are just debbie-downers, only wanting to see the Cowboys lose. Nope, it's just that some fans aren't surprised by today's results....because they see the deficiencies in the Cowboys' tendencies and players even after wins, and know that they can and will be easily exploited, especially in the playoffs.

I just don't trust this coaching staff, and so then it's hard to count on Dak, Zeke/Pollard, Micah, D Law, and Diggs simply "outplaying" Tom and the Tampa Dee on Monday night.
Yep Garrett had that just beat your man mentality and has it rubbed off on Moore?
How bout we out scheme our opponents occasionally?
 

john van brocklin

Captain Comeback
Messages
39,739
Reaction score
44,949
I don’t think the players are bad, but I do believe they’re overrated. We have a couple high profile players with the balance having average to slightly better that average abilities. When the Cowboys field a legit plus .500 team, the media pounces on “All that talent”. Just not realistic.

Can’t say that I’ve been blown away with the coaching staff, particularly game management situations, but I think they’re somewhat hand-cuffed with the product they work with. Perhaps the converse is true as well with the coaching staff inhibiting creativity.

Our QB, it’s easy to jump on him right now, and he definitely does deserve some flak for recent performances. However, I don’t believe he’s working with windows as large as many other QB’s and why are we such an inept screen team?

Ultimately, I point my finger at that front office. I defended it for years, but what other GM has had a 25 year stretch with so little playoff success. I guess no one close to Jerry has the nerve to clue him in on the definition of insanity. I don't know if it's ignorance or arrogance (little bit of both?) that keeps the Jones' from recognizing that they may be better served by inviting someone else to the dinner table.
The major problem is Jerry and it all runs down hill from there.
He has created a culture of entitlement.
Players thank they have arrived just putting on Dallas uniform.
We need a no nonsense coach like Parcells or Jimmy, but Jerry will not have it
 

ICP

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,082
Reaction score
3,821
It's root rot, stems from the base of the franchise
 
Top