Here's how I view the 26th pick

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,840
Reaction score
103,587
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
And you think Hyatt can come in and immediately take snaps from him?
If the team is smart? Definitely. Hyatt can bring a home run threat when he’s on the field. What does Michael Gallup currently bring?
Not likely. And the contract is what the contract is. He's not going anywhere for at least two seasons.
And two wrongs don’t make a right. You don’t compound the contract error by forcing him on the field or passing on improving the position.
 

VACowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,007
Reaction score
3,899
NFL currently has him at 59 and the 11th best OL but they do give him a starting grade. They note that he should do well with bull rushers and is light on his feet but has trouble sustaining blocks in the run game.
This. NO MORE finesse guards, please! I'd MUCH rather have Bergeron or Mafi, guys who are already maulers in the run game.
 

cnuball21

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,938
Reaction score
9,853
If the team is smart? Definitely. Hyatt can bring a home run threat when he’s on the field. What does Michael Gallup currently bring?

And two wrongs don’t make a right. You don’t compound the contract error by forcing him on the field or passing on improving the position.
And this…
 

starman22

Well-Known Member
Messages
974
Reaction score
871
If the team is smart? Definitely. Hyatt can bring a home run threat when he’s on the field. What does Michael Gallup currently bring?

And two wrongs don’t make a right. You don’t compound the contract error by forcing him on the field or passing on improving the position.
Zeke?
 

morasp

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
6,851
Last year the Lions gave up a third round pick and swapped first and second round picks with the Vikings to move up to 12 to take Jameson Williams a WR similar to Hyatt but ranked a little lower (6.48) and coming off an ACL knee injury. It would be nice to draft a JaMar Chase but we aren't picking in the top 10 and there isn't anyone that good in this years draft or last years for that matter.
 
Last edited:

ghst187

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,722
Reaction score
11,572
Avilia in my opinion is a reach at 26, there will be better players available. At 58 or a small trade up from there, makes far more sense. We have to avoid reaching to fill a need, not one site has Avilia as a top 30 pick.
I agree…I think we either have to move down from 26 or way up in round 2 to get Avila. I’d be okay with a trade way down in round 1 if we picked up another 3rd or 4th doing it and then take Avila so we get that fifth year option. 26 is expensive to me
 

Carson

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,068
Reaction score
67,028
Last year the Lions gave up a third round pick and swapped first and second round picks with the Vikings to move up to 12 to take Jameson Williams a WR similar to Hyatt but ranked a little lower (6.48) and coming off an ACL knee injury. It would be nice to draft a JaMar Chase but we aren't picking in the top 10 and there isn't anyone that good in this years draft or last years for that matter.
IMO Jameson has potential to be a legit 1 in this league. Hyatt is going to be a solid 2
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,781
Reaction score
95,333
If the team is smart? Definitely. Hyatt can bring a home run threat when he’s on the field. What does Michael Gallup currently bring?

And two wrongs don’t make a right. You don’t compound the contract error by forcing him on the field or passing on improving the position.
Lots of fast guys do nothing in the NFL if they can't be rounded WRs. If Hyatt struggles at other routes initially and he struggles at understanding zones and he struggles at getting off the LOS in bump coverage, just running fast on go routes won't get him on the field, nor should it.

Too many of you are just enamored with his speed and ignoring the fact that he seemingly is really raw at a bunch of other things NFL WRs are required to do.

And let's be clear here, Gallup isn't some bum like a practice squad level player here. Too much hype on a raw rookie and a complete underselling of a veteran who was pretty darn good before he got hurt.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,840
Reaction score
103,587
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Lots of fast guys do nothing in the NFL if they can't be rounded WRs. If Hyatt struggles at other routes initially and he struggles at understanding zones and he struggles at getting off the LOS in bump coverage, just running fast on go routes won't get him on the field, nor should it.

Too many of you are just enamored with his speed and ignoring the fact that he seemingly is really raw at a bunch of other things NFL WRs are required to do.

And let's be clear here, Gallup isn't some bum like a practice squad level player here. Too much hype on a raw rookie and a complete underselling of a veteran who was pretty darn good before he got hurt.
“Pretty darn good before he got hurt”. There’s some faint praise right there.

The fact is that Gallup was hurt. And he’s looked outright bad since.

The last thing I would do is to base any decisions on Michael Gallup.

Don’t make a bad situation worse.
 

Cowboyny

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,255
Reaction score
20,281
I agree…I think we either have to move down from 26 or way up in round 2 to get Avila. I’d be okay with a trade way down in round 1 if we picked up another 3rd or 4th doing it and then take Avila so we get that fifth year option. 26 is expensive to me
That's how I see it as well. Think there will be much better players available at 26 then him.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,781
Reaction score
95,333
“Pretty darn good before he got hurt”. There’s some faint praise right there.

The fact is that Gallup was hurt. And he’s looked outright bad since.

The last thing I would do is to base any decisions on Michael Gallup.

Don’t make a bad situation worse.
It's not unheard of for a guy coming off leg surgery to take time, even a season, to get his legs under him. ACL surgery isn't a death blow to a career and often times guys take awhile to get back to being themselves.

I'd be more OK with taking a WR as a replacement to Gallup if the guy being pimped was a more complete WR like Lamb coming out of college and not a raw guy who basically ran go routes in college. And certainly not taking that guy when there are likely going to be similar rated players available at 26 that would likely have a bigger impact than a 4th (or even 3rd) WR.
 

tunahelper

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,688
Reaction score
2,161
Smartest pick would be Avilia IMO. Getting a kid who can play LG or maybe even OC really solidifies the OL and your left side of the OL could be a foundation for years wiht Tyler Smith at LT (or eventually at LT). I like him more than Torrence.

Safest pick would be Mayer. Yes, he doesn't have the uber high ceiling of Washington but basically all the analyst say he also has the highest floor and less bust potential than the other TEs because Mayer does everything well whereas the other TEs might excel in one area but have struggles/questions in other areas.

Flashiest pick would be Robinson. He clearly has talent and looks like an explosive RB. Jerry could PR the crap out of him since he's a UT TB. But I just don't think the value is there in this draft taking a TB that high.

Dumbest pick would be Hyatt. That's not that I think he's a bad prospect or that he can't be a really good WR. He has great speed. But there are some questions with him about his route running, his understanding of defenses, etc. Plus, he'd be a 4th WR here. Given his rawness, to think he'd come in and replace Cooks or Gallup as one of the Top 3 WRs is a reach. You need your #1 pick to play and play immediately in Dallas given we don't use FA a ton. Seems like Hyatt is a guy who would languish for at least 2 years before he could even have a chance to make an impact.
I like OG or DT with 1st and second round picks. We need to solidify the middle.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,840
Reaction score
103,587
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
It's not unheard of for a guy coming off leg surgery to take time, even a season, to get his legs under him. ACL surgery isn't a death blow to a career and often times guys take awhile to get back to being themselves.

I agree. But it doesn’t explain to me where his hands went and why things were so bad with his catch numbers.

I like Gallup and hope he makes a great recovery and comeback. But I would not have those hopes affect my plans.
I'd be more OK with taking a WR as a replacement to Gallup if the guy being pimped was a more complete WR like Lamb coming out of college and not a raw guy who basically ran go routes in college. And certainly not taking that guy when there are likely going to be similar rated players available at 26 that would likely have a bigger impact than a 4th (or even 3rd) WR.
I can appreciate your concerns with Hyatt. There’s certainly a boom or bust potential. You might draft the next Ted Ginn.
 

morasp

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,440
Reaction score
6,851
IMO Jameson has potential to be a legit 1 in this league. Hyatt is going to be a solid 2
Maybe so, I'm not real big on arguing about which draft prospect is better, it just seems kind of silly, but he seems to have the same weaknesses as Hyatt and a few more.

Overview
Linear route-runner with electric long speed to impact a game as a home-run hitter or decoy drawing defenders away from other elements of the offense. Williams ruins man coverage but faces some limitations. He has issues getting off press cleanly and might require some scheming to help get off the mark cleanly against certain corners. Catch toughness can be inconsistent when contested or in heavily trafficked areas. He has all the juice to find consistent separation on vertical, over and post/corner routes and could see monstrous production if paired with a high-end talent at quarterback. The ACL tear could play a role in determining his ultimate draft destination, but it's unlikely to change his game.
Strengths
  • Record-breaking high school hurdler.
  • Smooth route take-off with instant gas.
  • Able to eviscerate the cushion and blow by corners.
  • Extra burst before route break forces coverage to bail out.
  • Separation feels inevitable on long-form patterns.
  • Posted FBS-best 11 touchdowns of 30-plus yards in 2021.
  • Long-limbed with expansive catch radius.
  • Plays with sudden hands to stab and secure high throws.
  • Opens hip to extend and grab back-shoulder/hip ball.
  • Good YAC stack when catching on the move.
  • Returned two kickoffs for touchdowns in 2021.
  • Long but lean and lanky.
  • Suffered ACL tear in the national title game.
  • Press release is narrow and indecisive.
  • Strider requiring extra time getting in and out of breaks.
  • Competitiveness diminishes near the noise.
  • Instances where he failed to finish routes.
  • Below-average play strength when battling for catch space.
  • Inconsistent tracking and working back to underthrows.
Overview
Long, slender wideout with deep speed that could force defensive coordinators to alter coverage considerations. Hyatt’s gliding gait disguises explosive acceleration that can lead to easy separation on deep throws. However, he does display inconsistency on contested catches comes. Hyatt is ordinary getting in and out of intermediate breaks and might be best with a limited route tree full of slants, crossers and a series of field-stretching patterns. Hyatt is an instantly credible WR2 with the ability to make a huge impact, but production could be erratic due to the limitations of his game.
Strengths
  • Top-end speed creates tension for defensive coordinators.
  • Run game will see lighter boxes out of defense’s respect for his explosiveness.
  • Tears into cushions and rockets past off-man coverage.
  • Maintains spacing from physical coverage getting into the route.
  • Runs focused vertical routes at crisp angles.
  • Glides into acceleration mode at route stems to separate.
  • Gets pitch-and-catch opportunities underneath against off-man.
  • Finished second in FBS with 15 receiving touchdowns.
  • Willing and effective as a perimeter blocker.
Weaknesses
  • Scheme created a variety of free releases for him.
  • Route tree somewhat limited.
  • Lean frame, lacking in play strength.
  • Knocked off course when press punch finds him.
  • Lacks deception in his short and intermediate routes.
  • Unsuccessful holding ground when catch is contested.
Sources Tell Us

“When you have someone who can run like Hyatt you get explosive catches but it also really benefits your running game because safeties can’t get involved as much. He reminds me a lot of watching Will Fuller when he was healthy.” -- Director of scouting for NFC team
Weaknesses
 
Last edited:

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,781
Reaction score
95,333
I agree. But it doesn’t explain to me where his hands went and why things were so bad with his catch numbers.

I like Gallup and hope he makes a great recovery and comeback. But I would not have those hopes affect my plans.

I can appreciate your concerns with Hyatt. There’s certainly a boom or bust potential. You might draft the next Ted Ginn.
LOL.

Damn blast from the past with Ginn.
 

CowboyoWales

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,665
Reaction score
4,863
I agree…I think we either have to move down from 26 or way up in round 2 to get Avila. I’d be okay with a trade way down in round 1 if we picked up another 3rd or 4th doing it and then take Avila so we get that fifth year option. 26 is expensive to me
If we were adamant about one of the Guards I would imagine there may be interest in a trade from the Saints (29th) for their 4th of Chiefs (31) for their 3rd who may be willing to trade to get a WR in front of the Bills. Luckily there doesnt appear anyone in the bottom end of the draft that needs interior O-Line.
 

ghst187

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,722
Reaction score
11,572
If we were adamant about one of the Guards I would imagine there may be interest in a trade from the Saints (29th) for their 4th of Chiefs (31) for their 3rd who may be willing to trade to get a WR in front of the Bills. Luckily there doesnt appear anyone in the bottom end of the draft that needs interior O-Line.
I’d be okay with that. Love to pick up one of the RBs from either auburn or Pitt, WR Mims or Mingo, a db, and probably a TE. Don’t see a lot of talent at DT honestly.
 

BoyzBlaster

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,981
Reaction score
3,825
Every time I see someone claim an interior OL is a low impact position it astounds me.

Is the QB a low impact position? The only thing standing in the way between him and the defensive line are those "low impact" blockers.

All it really means when you see someone make this claim is they don't know the game well enough to see their impact. A WR makes a catch. They understand this. A CB makes an interception. They can see this. But the most important player on the field having a big day because he enjoyed a run game, a clean pocket and was able to step into all of his throws? That takes a deeper understanding of the game.

They all belch out the old mantra that games are won or lost in the trenches then claim that the players in those trenches are low impact.

It never ceases to amaze me.
OUR qb is a low impact position.
 

BoyzBlaster

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,981
Reaction score
3,825
Last year the Lions gave up a third round pick and swapped first and second round picks with the Vikings to move up to 12 to take Jameson Williams a WR similar to Hyatt but ranked a little lower (6.48) and coming off an ACL knee injury. It would be nice to draft a JaMar Chase but we aren't picking in the top 10 and there isn't anyone that good in this years draft or last years for that matter.
I find it hard to believe anyone had WIlliams and Hyatt on equal footing unless you are saying Williams was severely downgraded because of the ACL?
 
Top