How desperate are the Cowboys, really?

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,709
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
http://espn.go.com/blog/dallas/cowboys/post/_/id/4706560/how-desperate-are-the-cowboys-really

So I've been trying to find something to write about the Dallas Cowboys even though they have no cap room and aren't signing anyone, because this is an NFC East blog and should hit on all four of the teams as much as possible. And I found this from Bryan Broaddus on the team's website about defensive tackle Jay Ratliff and the way he'll fit into Monte Kiffin's 4-3 defensive alignment. Bryan's excited because he thinks Ratliff is the kind of player who will flourish in the 4-3, and that he can play either of its defensive tackle positions well:
In this scheme, the defensive coaches want their guys to play with more speed and quickness, which is right down the alley for Ratliff. There is a reason that Jerry Jones and Jason Garrett never wavered about Ratliff coming back for this 2013 [season] despite the legal problem he faces in the coming months. He was built to play in this scheme.

This got me thinking. Sure, Ratliff's a knucklehead for blowing up at Jerry Jones in the locker room. Worse yet, he was arrested and charged with DUI a month and a half after teammate Jerry Brown was killed in a drunk driving accident for which teammate Josh Brent was charged. And sure, he had no more sacks last year than you or I did. But when healthy and on the field, Ratliff is still an excellent player, capable of disrupting an offense from an interior line position.

Then that got me thinking that Ratliff isn't exactly alone on the roster. On the defensive side of the ball, DeMarcus Ware is an excellent player. Cornerbacks Brandon Carr and Morris Claiborne are very good. Linebacker Sean Lee is outstanding, and fellow linebacker Bruce Carter sure looked headed that way last season before his injury. Jason Hatcher was excellent last season, and so was Anthony Spencer, whether he's worth his $10.6 million franchise tender or not.

On offense, the Cowboys have excellent players at quarterback, tight end and both starting wide receiver spots. They have a very good running back and left tackle. Can you find fault with any or all of these players? Sure. But on balance, I just gave you 14 starting positions at which the Cowboys are at least above average, and in several cases much better.

The point? Well, as Cowboys fans bemoan the lack of cap space and resultant lack of activity in this first week of free agency, it might be worth remembering that there are some really good players on this team, and that it might not be the kind of team that needed to have a big first week of free agency.

Now, of course they need work. I'm not naive. I know they've been 8-8 each of the past two seasons. I know the offensive line is a wreck, that they have question marks at safety, and that depth is an issue in spots. I know they need to find another starting linebacker to go with Lee and Carter. And yes, of course I know about Tony Romo's reputation for playing small in big spots. All of that stuff is true. I just think it's too easy too often for Cowboys fans to get negative about the way they perceive their team, and I don't think it's all doom and gloom there in Dallas.

Each of the past two seasons, they made it to the final game with a chance to win the division. By definition, that's a contending team, and as close to being a playoff team as one can get. They must improve in spots, most notably the offensive line, or it's going to be hard to believe they can make any big leap forward. But I don't agree with the perception that they're in big trouble because they were hamstrung this week in free agency. I think there are a lot of very good players on the Cowboys' roster who, if properly supported by a good draft and some smart free-agent bargain hunting, can make this a competitive team in 2013, just as it was in 2011 and 2012.

I think that's worth keeping in mind, is all.
 

Wood

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,447
Reaction score
5,697
I wonder if Higgs Boson can predict when Cowboys will have legitimate GM
 

burmafrd

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,820
Reaction score
3,379
the problem is that where the team is the weakest is where you need MULTIPLE new and better players- the O line.

AND the backend of the D- safety play.

You have one who has NO record in the NFL and another that is coming off a very serious injury and really only shined in a couple of games.


So you could potentially have about 5 big holes concentrated in 2 areas.


Virtually impossible to cover up or compensate when your holes are that big.

We DESPERATELY need to have a great draft this year.
 

TwoCentPlain

Numbnuts
Messages
15,171
Reaction score
11,084
Wood;5024962 said:
I wonder if Higgs Boson can predict when Cowboys will have legitimate GM

Or, how about wondering if Higgs Boson can predict when Cowboys will have a legitimate head coach? You know, a head coach who knows how to manage a game, call timeouts, make adjustments and put players in a position to succeed. Present data and trends suggest sometime early next year, if not sooner. And, no, it isn't some red-headed coach who is presently trying to learn on-the-job.
 

whynot

Well-Known Member
Messages
330
Reaction score
475
So to answer the question:

Q. How desperate are the Cowboys?


A. No where near as desperate as their forum dwelling fans.
 

tecolote

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,038
Reaction score
1,196
I think he is spot on. Safety does not concern me much, there will be a veteran who is at least the same and very possibly better than Sensy that will be willing to sign a one year cheap contract if it comes to that.

Now, on the O line, they have to replace at least 2 of the scrubs we have there right now. They have to fix that.
 

Frosty

Bigdog24
Messages
3,960
Reaction score
2,257
have to disagree with you on Ratliff....they guy is getting older, slow and cant stay healthy. He would of been perfect in Monte Kiffens schemes when he was younger....at this point Jay Ratliff is just taking the Cowboys money. But then again, so is Miles Austin and most of the offensive players that got extended just to keep Spencer around...Lets hope Jerry Jones and this Jason Garrett guy have a master plan...

No Cap money and extending over paid aging players just to keep a 11mil dollar average to good DE (Spencer) really shows why the Franchise has sucked for the last 16 years...

As the the good NFC teams are getting stronger the Jason Garrett Cowboys look awfully lost and confused.
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
40,028
Reaction score
37,178
xwalker;5024952 said:
And I found this from Bryan Broaddus on the team's website about defensive tackle Jay Ratliff and the way he'll fit into Monte Kiffin's 4-3 defensive alignment. Bryan's excited because he thinks Ratliff is the kind of player who will flourish in the 4-3, and that he can play either of its defensive tackle positions well.

I'm excited about that, too. I think Ratliff will play mostly at the NT spot because Jason Hatcher's more suited for the other spot. But I also think we'll see Ratliff at the 3 some, with players like Lissemore slipping into the 1 spot.
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
40,028
Reaction score
37,178
Bigdog24;5025002 said:
have to disagree with you on Ratliff.

Age and health are a concern. I didn't really see any evidence of Ratliff playing slower when he was in the game. He had different responsibilities in Ryan's scheme than he did in Phillips', but that doesn't mean he slowed.
 

sonnyboy

Benched
Messages
7,357
Reaction score
0
Ahhh a voice of reason. 8-8 is 8-8 and most teams at this spot can just as easily head in either direction.

I'll always bank on the 8-8 team with an elite QB loaded with injuries the prior season to improve the following season.
 

Frosty

Bigdog24
Messages
3,960
Reaction score
2,257
gimmesix;5025005 said:
Age and health are a concern. I didn't really see any evidence of Ratliff playing slower when he was in the game. He had different responsibilities in Ryan's scheme than he did in Phillips', but that doesn't mean he slowed.

That was the big question with Ratliff "when he was in the game" No doubt a young Ratliff would of have been a monster in Kiffen's scheme...Jay Ratliff is not the Jay Ratliff of 2 years ago...Jerry Jones paid for past performance and not for future results.

IMO Ratliff beat Jerry Jones at his own game.... took Jerry to the Bank and loaded up... Ratliff is a MESS...on and off the field.
 

TwoDeep3

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,506
Reaction score
17,339
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
burmafrd;5024969 said:
the problem is that where the team is the weakest is where you need MULTIPLE new and better players- the O line.

AND the backend of the D- safety play.

You have one who has NO record in the NFL and another that is coming off a very serious injury and really only shined in a couple of games.


So you could potentially have about 5 big holes concentrated in 2 areas.


Virtually impossible to cover up or compensate when your holes are that big.

We DESPERATELY need to have a great draft this year.

This...said it last year, and saying it again.
 
Top