How is Dak a top QB?

BobbyFlame469

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,468
Reaction score
1,903
He can’t even have two good games in a row. I use to be a HUGE Dak supporter but I’ve seen him for what he is. He does not make a single difference in games. Cooper Rush made this VERY clear. He may not be better than Geno Smith.


Mahomes
Jackson
Hurts
Burrow
Herbert
Allen
Trevor Lawerence
Rodgers
Stafford

All demonstrably better quarterbacks than him that can win actual defenses in the playoffs.
 

john van brocklin

Captain Comeback
Messages
39,624
Reaction score
44,845
He can’t even have two good games in a row. I use to be a HUGE Dak supporter but I’ve seen him for what he is. He does not make a single difference in games. Cooper Rush made this VERY clear. He may not be better than Geno Smith.


Mahomes
Jackson
Hurts
Burrow
Herbert
Allen
Trevor Lawerence
Rodgers
Stafford

All demonstrably better quarterbacks than him that can win actual defenses in the playoffs.
Define "top"
I would say he is middle of the pack..
He has great games and stinkers so that would be average in my opinion.
 

doomsday9084

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,260
Reaction score
4,561
IMO, he is somewhere in the 10 to 15 range for starting QB's. Outside of a few extremist haters or fans, I'm not sure there is a lot of debate about that. The tough question is if you can win with a #10 to 15 QB being paid $40m per year.
 

glimmerman

Well-Known Member
Messages
30,561
Reaction score
30,276
He has the stats of a top QB. He can string games together with the rest of the teams help. We went through this with Romo. But he has had some stinkers. Let’s try a different OC and playcaller. Shorter passes to someone schemed open and not abandoning the run will help him. Pollard getting hurt effected the game. Should have used Malik. 15 runs in a game is forcing to many passes.
 

MWH1967

The Cook
Messages
7,114
Reaction score
9,465
I keep telling you folks he's a good QB with warts. He needs a supporting staff and Stephen is a cheap arse.
 

Coogiguy03

Well-Known Member
Messages
25,807
Reaction score
21,728
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
BECAUSE HE WOWS us for a few games and everyone falls in love only to see who he really is!!

Really all of our good plays comes from scramble drills!!
 

Ken

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,705
Reaction score
17,366
He can’t even have two good games in a row. I use to be a HUGE Dak supporter but I’ve seen him for what he is. He does not make a single difference in games. Cooper Rush made this VERY clear. He may not be better than Geno Smith.


Mahomes
Jackson
Hurts
Burrow
Herbert
Allen
Trevor Lawerence
Rodgers
Stafford

All demonstrably better quarterbacks than him that can win actual defenses in the playoffs.
This is a new and refreshing topic.

Nicely done.
 

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
42,115
Reaction score
28,677
He can’t even have two good games in a row. I use to be a HUGE Dak supporter but I’ve seen him for what he is. He does not make a single difference in games. Cooper Rush made this VERY clear. He may not be better than Geno Smith.


Mahomes
Jackson
Hurts
Burrow
Herbert
Allen
Trevor Lawerence
Rodgers
Stafford

All demonstrably better quarterbacks than him that can win actual defenses in the playoffs.
Hes top 10 still yes after even with soem late season mistakes,

cooper rush did absolutely nothing to make any type of statement. daks clearly better then rush and no debate form the peanut gallery can change this.

Rush if you break down each game was barely steering the bus let alone driving it with that supporting cast which BTW broke down after dak got back and no way shape or form could Rush have won most any of those games with NO RUN GAME, Shaky OL, skill players have passes bounce of their hands, sts fumbling, bobbling and broken-down ie Mahers ..

rush played with the team playing elite and still couldn't score point bottom 10 in 3rd down % and scoring and you think Rush made statement? yes any qb including Dak could have won those games and give n that Washington game rush threw 2 INts called back but still threw them, Rams game might as well took a vacay and still fumbled the ball twice lucky agin to get those back( we could have won that game playing wildcat with no QB), 3 Ints in the eagles game.. he had the best of the best stretch in team pay down that stretch and still looked like a backup..

that 100% Facts and rlaity. Dak comes back and immediately gets our offense back top 5 in total scoring, RZ scoring, and 3rd down %..

Rush could not have handled the position after the team broke down especially up front with no run game.

if yiou think so you need a new drug. Those shrooms are hitting you hard, FACT is Dak easily wins those games and by a larger margin given the exact same scenario that wen down in those games. on the flip side Rush would have got killed...

Daks still a top 10 QB hes not typically a INT thrower

His 166 tds 65 ints plus 26 Rushing tds for his career after 97 games and Pmanning had 167 tds 117 ints and only 10 rushing td, Daks number across the board are equal or better including the playoff record at 2-4 but dak had 11 tds and 5 int in the playoffs to Peytons 10td-6 INt

Ironic huh??

the hate for moir own payer who in fact wasn't the worse qb in the playoffs with Turnovers Allen and Trevor were the same or worse..

also a fact top 5 highest paid 2022 qbs didn't even make the playoffs, also Fact Daks being highly and over critisized for issues breaking down around him.

Ive never seen so many INT that came from a ball being tipped at the line, tipped off of receivers hands, having his arm hit or jersey grabbed as he was throwing , and receivers getting pushed off their routes or running bad routes all leading to that unusually high amount of INts and have the QB blamed for them all without actually breaking them down and realize HALF of them were just pain not his fault.

that all this pace does talk about the its we can clearly go back and break down each one and find 50% of them were OTHER issues involved and then not mention how the offense was top 5 in scoring, red zone scoring and 3rd down % most of the games Dak came back and played down the stretch.. all positive..
 
Top