How would you Grade Reeves tonight?

[Bob Sacamano]

Plaxico owned his man ALL NIGHT LONG. Where am I speculating? Where am I speculating about a particular play? I was clearly refering to the player, Plaxico. Tonight, the play didnt matter. He was catching it and scoring.

guess you missed when the Giants were in our red-zone twice and only came away w/ 6 points (2 FGs) and Manning didn't look to PLax once

 

[DBoys]

Spencer had a sack (doesn't count in his stats because it came on a two-point coversion play, but it might have been our biggest defensive play of the game). He also knocked Manning out of the game with another knockdown. A sack and a hurry -- that's not bad for a rookie's first game.

I really like what I saw from Spencer.

 

[mmohican29]

Reeves gets a D-. He was atrocious, but managed to catch the ball thrown to him when Burress slipped. I've seen our other DB's drop those.

I thought Spencer played pretty good... got pressure a few times and made the play on the 2pt conversion and covered Shockey on the left sideline pretty well in the 4th Qtr.

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

guess you missed when the Giants were in our red-zone twice and only came away w/ 6 points (2 FGs) and Manning didn't look to PLax once

You just made my point. If Eli would have thrown to Plax they could very well have gotten 14 instead of 6.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

You just made my point. If Eli would have thrown to Plax they could very well have gotten 14 instead of 6.

no I didn't, Eli didn't look to Plax then because he probably wasn't open

 

[el_chevo]

You just made my point. If Eli would have thrown to Plax they could very well have gotten 14 instead of 6.

Didn't Eli throw to Plax at least once more and Reeves defended the play well where no catch occured?

 

[CanadianCowboysFan]

Didn't Eli throw to Plax at least once more and Reeves defended the play well where no catch occured?

Yeah there is one time I remember.

 

[DallasDomination]

He didnt play very well but they were throwing to his side like crazy...I give him a C- with potential to improve.