I don't think an athlete has a ever divided a fanbase quite like Tony Romo

Ring Leader

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,610
Reaction score
1,249
In that game Romo choked the game away early. He had 3 or 4 int's and a pick 6. He had us down like 23 to nothing early. We held Eli pretty good in that game and then the Giants played prevent defense..which ended up allowing us to come back. That was an early choke job by Romo.. not a late one like we are used to.

Glad to know we now have yet another "made up" category to trash Romo: The "early" choke job. So now all of your choke bases are well covered. In all seriousness, even for a jaded super hater, you have to have Tyron Smith length arms to reach this much.
 

LatinMind

iPhotoshop
Messages
17,457
Reaction score
11,571
In fairness to Danny at least his meltdowns were on the big stage, he had his moments of greatness (i.e Atlanta playoff game).....Romos meltdowns aren't even in the playoff games.

Thats what im saying. DW was crucified a million times worse that Romo is now. You just hear about it more because theres internet.
 

dupree89

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,410
Reaction score
2,623
Thats what im saying. DW was crucified a million times worse that Romo is now. You just hear about it more because theres internet.

you are right latin mind. No question about it. It drives me nuts when I hear people say.....Romo is another Danny White. Well, Romo has some things to accomplish before he can be considered as successful as Danny White was. And PLUS....Danny White had a lot more pressure in trying to replace Staubach. When Romo took over, the feeling was "it cant be any worse".
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
Glad to know we now have yet another "made up" category to trash Romo: The "early" choke job. So now all of your choke bases are well covered. In all seriousness, even for a jaded super hater, you have to have Tyron Smith length arms to reach this much.

Dude.. set your Romo pom pom's down. You telling me he didn't choke early in that game? I guess some fans can't handle the truth.
 

LatinMind

iPhotoshop
Messages
17,457
Reaction score
11,571
you are right latin mind. No question about it. It drives me nuts when I hear people say.....Romo is another Danny White. Well, Romo has some things to accomplish before he can be considered as successful as Danny White was. And PLUS....Danny White had a lot more pressure in trying to replace Staubach. When Romo took over, the feeling was "it cant be any worse".

Danny White was the QB in his final yrs when i started watching Dallas. Or should i say when i was old enough to comprehend what i was watching and the outcomes. DW replaced a legend, played for the legend played with Legends and came up short. Romo plays with a couple of very good players and a coaching staff thats average. No comparison
 

khiladi

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,912
Reaction score
37,412
I think where the divide comes from is it depend son your age. I'm mid 20's so my memory of this organization is the era after the triplets. I remember fondly the Anthony Wright's, Clint Stoerner's, Ryan Leaf's, Quincy Carter's, Drew Henson's, Chad Hutchinson's, etc. I remember Aikman at the end of his career. I think people in my age group can sort of appreciate how bad things can get and can appreciate what Romo does for this team. I think the older fanbases who grew up watching Staubach, Aikman and even White to an extent have a certain expectation for what a quarterback should be and don't get it from Romo.

Not true... If you saw Aikman and Staubach, you also saw Danny White as well as Hogeboom and others. You also remember the above. Being a witness to the 90s SBs, I appreciate Romo. It's Garrett, I don't. Contrary to perception, Romo also saved Parcells last season. He would have looked bad if it weren't for Romo. Remember, even Parcells players from NYGiants days had to come fly down and encourage him on the sidelines in the Panthers game in Romo's first start. No Romo, no playoffs for Parcells his last year.
 

Ring Leader

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,610
Reaction score
1,249
you are right latin mind. No question about it. It drives me nuts when I hear people say.....Romo is another Danny White. Well, Romo has some things to accomplish before he can be considered as successful as Danny White was. And PLUS....Danny White had a lot more pressure in trying to replace Staubach. When Romo took over, the feeling was "it cant be any worse".

Danny White had a playoff caliber team surrounding him for multiple years.
Dude.. set your Romo pom pom's down. You telling me he didn't choke early in that game? I guess some fans can't handle the truth.

OK, let me help you out a bit. As a card carrying Romo hater, the term "choke" is not necessarily appropriate for every mistake your Antichrist makes. You're losing hater credibility and worse, poignancy. Kind of like watching Ron Burgundy butcher the "when in Rome" quote. You'll thank me once this sinks in a little.
 

Section446

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,933
Reaction score
11,615
Once again, he proves that he just doesn't have the "it" factor.
 

hornitosmonster

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,963
Reaction score
5,312
I guess it is too much of us Romo supporters to ask the defense to not give up 50 freaking points. 500 yards, 5 tds, and 48 point should be enough. Haters going hate
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,889
Reaction score
48,677
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
When it comes clutch performances, there is no debate. Romo led the league in 4th-quarter comebacks last year, and has one of the highest late-and-close passer ratings of any QB for his career. That's the reality. Perception only contradicts this whenever Romo fails to perform well in a clutch situation. It doesn't happen often, but when it does, you hear "that's what Romo always does." Wrong, even as an exaggeration. But detractors are only too happy to chime in, then remain silent for the next few wins until it happens again, which it will.

This looks to be basically the same type of team that Romo has had most of his time here. The passing offense will carry the team as far as it can. Sure as the sun rising, Romo will be put in multiple situations this year where the game rests in his hands, and he will play well in most of those situations, and make mistakes in others. The mistakes will be magnified and loudly proclaimed as proof that the perception must be right. In between we'll win some games we have no business winning, because of Romo and the passing game.

Since 1960, teams are 142-2 when their QB passes for over 300 yards with a 140 rating.

Two losses in 53+ seasons, and it's the same QB both times.

I wish this was posted nationally, because it's so true and should require not even an average IQ to comprehend it. Yet some refuse to look at it that way.
.
The perception is so strong that he can defy that perception 10 times in a row, but once he makes one bad play a a key time (and stats and facts say that really does happen LESS for him than most) everyone piles on with the "see, I told you so's".

Dallas gets massacred without him today. Flat out slaughtered.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,889
Reaction score
48,677
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Isn't it? Guy just can't get it done when the game is on the line, never has been able to. The guy is great for fantasy football though.

Sure. He's done it many times...more than most even. yet "fans" like you only recall a few plays here or there that "define him".
 

Deep_South

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,030
Reaction score
3,653
Why don't we talk about one of the worst defensive efforts in the history of the NFL instead of the only QB who ever put up 48 points and lost?
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
Fair enough.

Danny White also happened to have TEAMS that were capable of making it to games that mattered in January. Romo doesn't.

I really don't think people understand how bad this defense is right now. They've allowed 2 400 yard passers in 5 games and allowed Peyton to absolutely torch them as well. 3 out of 5 games this defense has been nothing short of awful. Not surprisingly the Cowboys are 1-1 in games that this defense hasn't been trash. They're 1-2 in the ones where they have been trash.

If they don't get this defense playing a lot better then Dallas won't win 6 games this year because Romo isn't going to be perfect. No QB is perfect though so that's to be expected.

Danny White also had Tom Landry still in his peak. If Staubach does not retire, those teams win another SB or 2. People forget how good that team was around White.
 

WV Cowboy

Waitin' on the 6th
Messages
11,604
Reaction score
1,744
Why don't we talk about one of the worst defensive efforts in the history of the NFL instead of the only QB who ever put up 48 points and lost?

LOL, .. good point, .. I guess it does not fit their agenda.
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
I guess our defense is the only one who gave up a ton of points today. Peyton's played outstanding right? The truth is both defenses played bad and both QB's played outstanding. One of them just threw a crucial INT with time running out on our side of the field and made it easy for the other QB to close out the game.
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
Danny White had a playoff caliber team surrounding him for multiple years.


OK, let me help you out a bit. As a card carrying Romo hater, the term "choke" is not necessarily appropriate for every mistake your Antichrist makes. You're losing hater credibility and worse, poignancy. Kind of like watching Ron Burgundy butcher the "when in Rome" quote. You'll thank me once this sinks in a little.

Your telling me Romo didn't choke at the end of this game? Also, you are telling me he didn't choke against the Giants last year putting us in the hole early?
 
Top