i don't think manny johnson stepped out of bounds

lane

The Chairman
Messages
13,221
Reaction score
5,630
just watched the replay of the game.

mcgee and johnson were robbed.


oh and by the way...lee is going to be a great one.
 
lane;3534618 said:
just watched the replay of the game.

mcgee and johnson were robbed.


oh and by the way...lee is going to be a great one.

hard to overturn that...nothing seemed indisputable
 
It was hard to tell from the angle they showed. The call could've gone either way.
 
If it were a regular season game, there would have been more cameras, thus more angles. Would have given a more conclusive look.

BTW, I thought he stayed in bounds as well.
 
He didn't but the side judge blew the play dead when he thuoght (WRONGLY) that the foot touched out of bounds. The whistle blew, and although the play went to a booth review, noting could be overturned because of that whistle. Hey, it's pre-season for the refs too.
 
AMERICAS_FAN;3534692 said:
He didn't but the side judge blew the play dead when he thuoght (WRONGLY) that the foot touched out of bounds. The whistle blew, and although the play went to a booth review, noting could be overturned because of that whistle. Hey, it's pre-season for the refs too.

Can't wait for all the blown calls and brain dead explanations for those calls during the regular season. :(
 
links18;3534694 said:
Can't wait for all the blown calls and brain dead explanations for those calls during the regular season. :(

It happens to every team. If you want to win a Super Bowl in this legue, I always say, "You've got to beat the refs!" what that means is beating your opponent so soundly that no matter how badly the refs screw you it won't change the victory outcome of your game.
 
Couldn't tell if he was in or not, though it looked like he went out to me. Either way the spot was wrong. If he went out it was either 2 yards back (most likely), or 3 yards forward of where they spotted it.
 
ChldsPlay;3534703 said:
Couldn't tell if he was in or not, though it looked like he went out to me. Either way the spot was wrong. If he went out it was either 2 yards back (most likely), or 3 yards forward of where they spotted it.

He was in, but the Cowboys beat he refs anayways, and that's the significance of that game. The Cowboys were down when the bad call happened, robing them of a TD, yet they still kept their composure and made the FG to win the game.
 
Good, now they owe us one in the regular season.
 
Not that it matters one tiny bit, but I thought I saw him step on the sideline 2 or 3 times...
 
AMERICAS_FAN;3534702 said:
It happens to every team. If you want to win a Super Bowl in this legue, I always say, "You've got to beat the refs!" what that means is beating your opponent so soundly that no matter how badly the refs screw you it won't change the victory outcome of your game.
This is the truth, I coach debate and we say the same thing -- gotta beat your opponents so bad that no matter what the judges predispositions they know you won. If you leave it close, its your fault for giving the referees the opportunity to ruin your game. When you start blaming refs, you stop blaming yourself and you start that slide back into mediocrity.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
474,592
Messages
14,547,017
Members
24,212
Latest member
JerryJonesSupporter
Back
Top