I really hope McClay leaves

[zrinkill]

What a silly childish thread.

 

[T-RO]

His job is not needed here anymore. There is no way he put a board together and Shoemaker was even one of the top 5 remaining on it. His talents are being wasted here. That was a 100% McCarthy/TEs Coach make em happy REACH PICK. 100% REACH. They draft best TE available everyone. Unreal, I am done.

Let's review your draft knowledge:
1. You said no way Mazi was a top 100 player.
2. You said --no doubt -- Hyatt would go in the top 10 of the draft.

Now this nonsense thread...

I don't know what is more extreme with you:
-Your ignorance about how the draft works and what constitutes player value
-Your absolute certainty that you know better than everyone else after watching 3 and 4 minute highlight clips from YouTube

 

[raven55]

dumb and dumber always mess things up i know mazi was a need but they harp and harp on the 1st round being the bpa and there were two or three playser with first round grades and they passed so that is a buncn of bull. now what are they going to do if the corner that doesn't tackle says no to his contract offered and the defensive ends are aftert next year are another problem area and least of all the eagles have been drafting with great ease so jerry will see dallas in the super bowl from a cloud or a pitchfork in his hand

 

[Pass2Run]

McClay is on an extremely long leash with what he’s done here.
Not a fan of what we’ve done this draft but history has been on Will’s side.

It has, and looking at the players, he's selected, I think he's onto something. But that's just me. We've got some guys that match up well against the Eagles and 9ers.

That's what I looks like to me.

 

[Pass2Run]

This is a McCarthy trying to save his *** draft

It's foreshadowing about who the next coach is going to be.

 

[817Gill]

Yeah. I remember everyone hated the Trysten Hill pick and called it a reach. Dude was cut.

So many more productive day 1/2 picks in McClay’s era than not. Naming one of the misses doesn’t change the fact that his draft record is very good.

 

[gimmesix]

Yeah. I remember everyone hated the Trysten Hill pick and called it a reach. Dude was cut.

That's what makes it frustrating. It cuts both ways. We can dislike a pick like Tyler Smith and it turns out to be good one. And we can dislike a pick like Kelvin Joseph or Taco Charlton and it turns out to be a bad one.

I think there's a lot of overreaction, especially on the negative side, but the overreaction is based on picks like Hill, Joseph, Charlton, Wright, etc. But in the same breath fans think we can easily find a starting running back in the fourth round because we found one once in Tony Pollard. The draft is a strange animal.

 

[Acceptablename]

I remember everyone hated the Fredrick pick and called it a reach. Dude balled out. I hope this guy balls out also.

Yep and the smith pick

 

[cowboyec]

heck no.
he's the one thing about that side of the star that works.

 

[Kwyn]

His job is not needed here anymore. There is no way he put a board together and Shoemaker was even one of the top 5 remaining on it. His talents are being wasted here. That was a 100% McCarthy/TEs Coach make em happy REACH PICK. 100% REACH. They draft best TE available everyone. Unreal, I am done.

You should turn in your fan card.

McClay is elite and we are lucky to have him.

 

[3rdEyewarrior]

I remember everyone hated the Fredrick pick and called it a reach. Dude balled out. I hope this guy balls out also.

Yup. We miss Travis. If he was still here, zeke has 300 more yards a year:

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

His job is not needed here anymore. There is no way he put a board together and Shoemaker was even one of the top 5 remaining on it. His talents are being wasted here. That was a 100% McCarthy/TEs Coach make em happy REACH PICK. 100% REACH. They draft best TE available everyone. Unreal, I am done.

Looks like they panicked with the run on TEs and liked this kid and reached. Probably thinking he wasn't going to be there in the 3rd.

And torrence was right there to have.

 

[Hawkeye19]

What got me was they let the giants jump them and take John Michael Smitz

What do you mean the Giants jumped them? They pick in front of Dallas all draft long basically.

 

[Brooksey]

We drafted 3 players that will play this year and potentially start by year end, this is a playoff roster. Don't forget we signed Cooks & Gilmore who will also start.
Mazi will play, Schoon will split time with Ferguson and will be our best TE by year end IMO, he's a better blocker and a better athlete. Overshown allows Micah to play full time edge and gives Quinn tremendous flexibility in pass

Overshown & Damone Clark, Micah on the edge, Mazi in the middle.

 

[Zekeats]

So many more productive day 1/2 picks in McClay’s era than not. Naming one of the misses doesn’t change the fact that his draft record is very good.

His draft record is excellent when tweetle dee and tweetle dumb don't let the coaches make the picks

 

[Jipper]

We drafted 3 players that will play this year and potentially start by year end, this is a playoff roster. Don't forget we signed Cooks & Gilmore who will also start.
Mazi will play, Schoon will split time with Ferguson and will be our best TE by year end IMO, he's a better blocker and a better athlete. Overshown allows Micah to play full time edge and gives Quinn tremendous flexibility in pass

Overshown & Damone Clark, Micah on the edge, Mazi in the middle.

The TE pick is the one head scratcher for me...yes good blocker and yes sure hands but his stats remind me of Witten in his later years which drove us all mad.

Love the DT and LB as they really make the defense better instantly....guess I'll have to keep my negative ity at bay on the TE until we see...

While some are saying they hate this draft and it reminds them of 09, I feel very meh but kinda feel it could be like last year and surprise the crap out of me

 

[Pass2Run]

heck no.
he's the one thing about that side of the star that works.

Exactly. While Jerry takes the credit.

 

[LittleD]

His job is not needed here anymore. There is no way he put a board together and Shoemaker was even one of the top 5 remaining on it. His talents are being wasted here. That was a 100% McCarthy/TEs Coach make em happy REACH PICK. 100% REACH. They draft best TE available everyone. Unreal, I am done.

You could leave for the philly boards but, McClay isn't going anywhere else unless he wants to. Stephen has spoken.

 

[Zekeats]

You could leave for the philly boards but, McClay isn't going anywhere else unless he wants to. Stephen has spoken.

Ur littleD