Fuzzy you are too smart of a poster and too in tuned with what's going on around the league to not see the train wreck that's incoming.
Regardless of what happens this season, I do not like how they have coddled Claiborne. I think he's naturally a passive person who lacks confidence in himself and his body and we have done nothing to help him break thru that mental hurdle. A tougher head coach would have demanded more out of him, and in turn would have made him a better player than what we've seen so far.
I get that there is quite the curve ahead and we don't have the best train I have ever seen but the train hasn't gone off the rails quite yet.
What I think is that trainers and doctors are having more influence on games than ever before. This is primarily due to the concussion issue. It's the same reason they are 'coddling' Okoye and Spencer or anyone else that has an injury. We have had at least a dozen people out for injury each preseason game to this point.
If Claibornes MRI shows the tear and inflammation from an AC sprain then it is what it is. You can try to tell a tale of past glory and how things used to be but the days of discounting the possibility of disability and long term health effects are over.
Generally sprains take a few weeks to recover. It is what it is.
I also am not convinced that ignoring medical advice would be a good thing. If anything, I think Claiborne's body is unable to handle the collisions in the NFL. I still think it makes more sense to actually wait for Claiborne's status for next Sunday before I become concerned.
There is the Bear Bryant school of thought where you grind every last bit as quick as you can. Then there are more modern takes like Walsh, Gibbs, and Vermeil where you are not that aggressive in your training.
To me it comes down to whether or not the guys particularly on the lines play hard, physical football.
What do you think of the Cowboys cutting Webb? He was one that I thought lacked courage. Wilson is another one who I though played scared of the OT. He was cut. Wilber has been weak taking on blocks and at the poa and he played in the romper room tonight for a half. Carter pouts and is benched
Claiborne himself is only starting because Scandrick us hurt and hasn't been the clearcut starter for over a season to this point. I think his soft coward routine vs the run is a big part of that.
Garrett marginalizes the weak and cowardly.