If Available, Mike McCarthy An Intriguing OC Candidate, Ben Roethlisberger Says

[Sydla]

Only so much you can do when your QB can’t read a defense

McCarthy is cooked. He should be fired. Accept that.

 

[bigE79]

Yep and if Tomlin steps away I’m guessing MM would be a serious candidate for the HC job if available.

Why...his playoff record is worse than ours..5 straight one and done.. Steelers fans want him gone worse than we want mike gone.

 

[MikeT22]

McCarthy is cooked. He should be fired. Accept that.

Yeah he should be gone too. But Jerry will just hire another Wade, Garrett, MM, Campo.

 

[KingintheNorth]

I'd love to see your game plan, complete with call sheets, down and distance plays, and your adjustments.

Just an fyi it's not simply saying it was a poor game plan, it's the continued use of words like idiots. This lifts you above them, and thus means you should be able provide exactly why you are better than the coaches.

So, please, share your work

Does this logic apply to everything?


Are you not allowed to complain about your meal because you aren't a chef?

There should never be any medical malpractice lawsuits right? How does the patient dare criticize the trained surgeon?

How about politics? Are you only allowed to be critical if you served a couple of terms in Congress?


Ridiculous response.

 

[stilltheguru]

Oh he crapped the bed just like the rest of the team...he should have developed a different game plan and adjusted on the fly, he's just as guilty as all the other idiots

what mike did wrong was say he wanted to be a run oriented team but didn't install a great run scheme. That's his greatest failure. The young guns in the NFL have run games without 3 all pro lineman.

 

[fivetwos]

They will learn the way the Giants figured it out with Jason Garrett.

McCarthy has been exposed. He's outdated and too wishy washy. His play designs and concepts are from the 90s.

I know enough to know that I didn’t understand enough to know if this was true or not when I had my suspicions.

It really seems that the bottom line is that Jerry isn’t capable of finding and recognizing the better, younger minds in the game.

Seems as if those types routinely find and exploit our weaknesses. It’s NEVER the opposite. It’s always some dated scheme, and appears as if the defense knows what’s coming far too often.

Even Moores deal seemed like Garrett’s lame offense with some trick plays inserted.

Always outcoached, never outcoach anyone….and that certainly pre-dates McCarthy.

 

[Gambit]

Does this logic apply to everything?


Are you not allowed to complain about your meal because you aren't a chef?

There should never be any medical malpractice lawsuits right? How does the patient dare criticize the trained surgeon?

How about politics? Are you only allowed to be critical if you served a couple of terms in Congress?


Ridiculous response.

Sure you can complain, but if you're going to go on message boards calling the chef and idiot, you should be prepared to answer the question what would have done differently.

Medical malpractice is VASTLY different than a " bad game plan" in a football game, I hope you can see that, right? Not at all analogous. One can kill you one can merely cost you a game.

More analogous would be complaining about the flow of traffic in an er etc. which sure you can complain, but be prepared to answer questions about solutions.

It's almost like you're advocating for blanket complaints and name calling with no accountability for what's said....

 

[FVSTONE]

https://steelersdepot.com/2024/01/m...isberger-says-hed-be-awesome-but-i-dont-know/

It's a recipe for disaster when both the HC/OC & QB both get BIG GAME JITTERS at the same time.

 

[32BellyOption]

Why...his playoff record is worse than ours..5 straight one and done.. Steelers fans want him gone worse than we want mike gone.

You misread my post.

 

[bigE79]

You misread my post.

I sure did,I apologize

 

[pacy]

As if Jerry would let Dak get benched. Cooper is very limited and SF got rid of Lance for a reason.

Yes, the reason is Brock Purdy.

 

[cowboyfan4life2]

Great.

He also spit the bit in the playoffs three straight years too.

He's not getting snapped up in a second if Jerry fires him.

Yes and he needs to go. But there are plenty of franchises who would give their right arm for our past three years. Even 1 and 3 in the playoffs.