If Garrett has the play card Sunday how will it make you feel?

[dcstands4]

Simple question if on Sunday they shoot to the sideline and Ginger Jay had that laminate play-card what will your reaction be?

 

[big dog cowboy]

If that is what is best for business I'm all for it.

 

[Direwolf63]

I have no problem with it. It's his job on the line. He may as well control the playcalling.

 

[khiladi]

If I was Callahan, I'd commit sepaku, because that officially means I got demoted for this pathetic example of a coach...

 

[fifaguy]

whats the point of keeping callahan at all at this point then?

 

[Mr Cowboy]

it won't make a difference, its the same offense, and the reason Jason got stripped of play calling duties in the first place is because the offense was stagnant. Now two play callers with the same results should lead you to believe that there is a problem with the design of the offense................

 

[Direwolf63]

whats the point of keeping callahan at all at this point then?

He's the o-line coach.

 

[theebs]

season ended in new Orleans so it makes no difference.

if he takes the card now it shows even more how useless the jones family is and how garret has no backbone at all.

if he believed the team would play best with him calling plays than he should have demanded play calling or resign.

if the jones believe the team was better suited to garret not calling plays then who is to blame for him taking it back? why is he taking it back?

either way, the fans are the ones screwed. They will all sleep in their mansions and move on to their next 7 figure paycheck at their next job......

we will watch Brandon Jacobs dance in the end zone sunday and it will hurt us more than most of the quitters that take up space on this roster and on this staff.

 

[StarBoyz83]

Anytime garret and kiffen have something to do with this team its a fail. Period.

 

[Wheeltax]

I'd prefer it

 

[Chocolate Lab]

Jeez, theebs, are you trying the reverse jinx there or are you really that negative?

I mean, we may not be good but I don't think they are either. Granted, they have some momentum, but we're getting quite a few players back this week.

 

[TTexasTT]

Id be happy to see that.

 

[TrailBlazer]

I don't see it making a difference. It'll be the same snap the ball with one second left, chaotic, no rhythm offense we've seen for years now.

 

[theebs]

Jeez, theebs, are you trying the reverse jinx there or are you really that negative?

I mean, we may not be good but I don't think they are either. Granted, they have some momentum, but we're getting quite a few players back this week.

not reverse jinxing or being negative.

we are dead. This scenario is the ultimate scenario for the giants, they are going to beat us into submission and then embarrass us.

its all set up. Tom Coughlin is the master of this.

 

[KDM256]

I have no problem with it. It's his job on the line. He may as well control the playcalling.

Pretty much how I feel as well

 

[TTexasTT]

not reverse jinxing or being negative.

we are dead. This scenario is the ultimate scenario for the giants, they are going to beat us into submission and then embarrass us.

its all set up. Tom Coughlin is the master of this.

No. thats being negative... Or being a idiot.

The Giants suck far worse than the Cowboys. Dallas will beat NY and OAK and win the NFC E. Probably not much of a playoff run but the division is so poor that Dallas will win it. I have no clue what you find so impressive about the Giants or Eagles. After watching both of their games... They just suck.

 

[Blue Eyed Devil]

lipstick on a pig

 

[theebs]

No. thats being negative... Or being a idiot.

The Giants suck far worse than the Cowboys. Dallas will beat NY and OAK and win the NFC E. Probably not much of a playoff run but the division is so poor that Dallas will win it. I have no clue what you find so impressive about the Giants or Eagles. After watching both of their games... They just suck.

that's fine. Call me an idiot if you want.

The giants are at their best in a certain situation and they are in that situation this week. All this stuff about which qb's they have played means nothing. They have gotten healthier, gained confidence and now have a goal...to win the east and that is a reality now. They have Dallas and Washington in back to back weeks at home.

they have the best coaching staff in the division and the best defensive line. They will come out and play disciplined and push us around on both sides of the ball.

Tom Coughlin is a master motivator. Now that beason has stabilized their lb group and brown and Jacobs have stabilized the running game they can function.

They will have a week of coughlin motivating them, the press telling them how jerry said they fake injuries and old news stories of the media telling them they are toast.

its a perfect scenario for a coughlin led giants team.

In two weeks they will be 6-6. Then they can start movtivating themselves with the superbowl being in NY.

As I have said all year, the division started poor but one of these teams will pull it together and play well at the end....hoped it would be us but it seems it will be ny or philly.

 

[WestCoastQB]

Simple question if on Sunday they shoot to the sideline and Ginger Jay had that laminate play-card what will your reaction be?

Let him call plays in between the 20s and Callaghan once inside them...Seems to be the best of both worlds. (Unless you are a RB, then you hate them both.)

 

[WestCoastQB]

I have no problem with it. It's his job on the line. He may as well control the playcalling.

Do you really think the decision to stop calling plays was his? And that he truly can take it back whenever he wants?