I passed on the SB for the first time in 35 years.
I know Butler got the pick at the end of the game.
Did he account for 3 other TDs and/or stopped TDs?
Maybe he had 15 tackles and at least one more pick?
Maybe a punt return for a TD?
You guys are not saying that one play made him MVP for the entire game, I'm giving you credit for that...right?
Not all plays are equal. Normally, I'd agree with you, but that game was lost, and that play by the rookie DB was unbelievable. He really did gift-wrap a win for a team that had been beaten, despite a great game from Brady before that. In this rare case, I happen to think that one single play was more important than everything his teammates did that day, in total. It was as clutch as you can be at the time when you absolutely had to have it.
Plus, it's a lot more interesting than giving it to the franchise QB yet again. And a much better story for after the game to-boot. If you're not going to reward stuff like that, you might as well call the award Most Valuable Quarterback and admit it's the two-man race it actually ends up being most of the time.