If the draft fell like this, and you couldn't trade back

[bleachedwheat]

1. Titans- QB Cam Ward, Miami
2. Browns- CB/WR Travis Hunter, Colorado
3. Giants- DE Abdul Carter, Penn State
4. Patriots- WR Tet McMillan, Arizona
5. Jaguars- DT Mason Graham, Michigan
6. Raiders- RB Ashton Jeanty, Boise State
7. Jets- RT Armand Membou, Missouri
8. Panthers- Edge/LB Jalon Walker, Georgia
9. Saints- CB Will Johnson, Michigan
10. Bears- DE Mykel Williams, Georgia
11. 49ers- T/G Will Campbell, LSU

If only 1 QB goes before the Cowboys pick, it really hurts.
Choices:
WR Matthew Golden, Texas
TE Tyler Warren, Penn State
T/G Kelvin Banks, Texas
G Tyler Booker, Alabama
Edge Mike Green, Marshall
DE Shemar Stewart, Texas A&M
DB Jahdae Barron, Texas

None of the picks are Ideal and trading down requires another team to want to move up for one of these guys. If you have to stay put and pick, who would it be.

For me I would go with
1. G Booker
2. Edge Green
3. DB Barron

Not having a player there that really jumps off the page, my thinking would be to just draft the safest player.
Booker is the least likely player to bust, from this list; in my opinion. The Interior line becomes a strength and the team has said they want to run the ball a lot this season.

I would also sign T Tyron Smith after the draft to play swing tackle for a year. If signed after the draft he doesn't affect the comp pick formula. It would be nice to have a failsafe for Guyton and Steele.

What would you do if it went like this. Everyone is just assuming that multiple QB's are taken before 12.

 

[Mikexike]

If this was to happen, I'd probably turn in Tyler Warren's card. Replacement for Fergy

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Between Mike green
Shemar
Mykielwwilliams

Someone is gonna be an all pro right ?

 

[Montanalo]

Kelvin Banks or Shemar Stewart... it's a no lose situation

 

[baltcowboy]

1. Titans- QB Cam Ward, Miami
2. Browns- CB/WR Travis Hunter, Colorado
3. Giants- DE Abdul Carter, Penn State
4. Patriots- WR Tet McMillan, Arizona
5. Jaguars- DT Mason Graham, Michigan
6. Raiders- RB Ashton Jeanty, Boise State
7. Jets- RT Armand Membou, Missouri
8. Panthers- Edge/LB Jalon Walker, Georgia
9. Saints- CB Will Johnson, Michigan
10. Bears- DE Mykel Williams, Georgia
11. 49ers- T/G Will Campbell, LSU

If only 1 QB goes before the Cowboys pick, it really hurts.
Choices:
WR Matthew Golden, Texas
TE Tyler Warren, Penn State
T/G Kelvin Banks, Texas
G Tyler Booker, Alabama
Edge Mike Green, Marshall
DE Shemar Stewart, Texas A&M
DB Jahdae Barron, Texas

None of the picks are Ideal and trading down requires another team to want to move up for one of these guys. If you have to stay put and pick, who would it be.

For me I would go with
1. G Booker
2. Edge Green
3. DB Barron

Not having a player there that really jumps off the page, my thinking would be to just draft the safest player.
Booker is the least likely player to bust, from this list; in my opinion. The Interior line becomes a strength and the team has said they want to run the ball a lot this season.

I would also sign T Tyron Smith after the draft to play swing tackle for a year. If signed after the draft he doesn't affect the comp pick formula. It would be nice to have a failsafe for Guyton and Steele.

What would you do if it went like this. Everyone is just assuming that multiple QB's are taken before 12.

Yuk… Good realistic scenario. I might take a quarterback but I would probably draft Hampton. Walk in starter at a position of need.

 

[RS12]

1. Titans- QB Cam Ward, Miami
2. Browns- CB/WR Travis Hunter, Colorado
3. Giants- DE Abdul Carter, Penn State
4. Patriots- WR Tet McMillan, Arizona
5. Jaguars- DT Mason Graham, Michigan
6. Raiders- RB Ashton Jeanty, Boise State
7. Jets- RT Armand Membou, Missouri
8. Panthers- Edge/LB Jalon Walker, Georgia
9. Saints- CB Will Johnson, Michigan
10. Bears- DE Mykel Williams, Georgia
11. 49ers- T/G Will Campbell, LSU

If only 1 QB goes before the Cowboys pick, it really hurts.
Choices:
WR Matthew Golden, Texas
TE Tyler Warren, Penn State
T/G Kelvin Banks, Texas
G Tyler Booker, Alabama
Edge Mike Green, Marshall
DE Shemar Stewart, Texas A&M
DB Jahdae Barron, Texas

None of the picks are Ideal and trading down requires another team to want to move up for one of these guys. If you have to stay put and pick, who would it be.

For me I would go with
1. G Booker
2. Edge Green
3. DB Barron

Not having a player there that really jumps off the page, my thinking would be to just draft the safest player.
Booker is the least likely player to bust, from this list; in my opinion. The Interior line becomes a strength and the team has said they want to run the ball a lot this season.

I would also sign T Tyron Smith after the draft to play swing tackle for a year. If signed after the draft he doesn't affect the comp pick formula. It would be nice to have a failsafe for Guyton and Steele.

What would you do if it went like this. Everyone is just assuming that multiple QB's are taken before 12.

I think Sanders goes top 10 but to answer your question 1) Banks 2) Green 3) Barron

 

[America's Cowboy]

Hard Pass on G Tyler Booker. His times at the combine were very slow, plus he only benched 220 lbs 21 times. All very poor results for an interior olineman who plays guard and will be expected to pull and push.

Out of all the players listed and if no one was willing to trade up for the Cowboys 12th pick, I would take WR Matthew Golden first because he would immediately help at a position of need. If not him, possibly Edge Mike Green.

 

[sbark]

If this was to happen, I'd probably turn in Tyler Warren's card. Replacement for Fergy

Agree, does so many things well
Virtually gives a team a #2 reciever

Yuk… Good realistic scenario. I might take a quarterback but I would probably draft Hampton. Walk in starter at a position of need.

It is a realistic scenario that could play out.

But at 12, with the 2Qb available, trade down becomes more & more possible...at 12, they have value

 

[cowboyec]

for me:
•de shemar stewart,texas a&m.
•de james pearce,tennessee(not listed).
•og tyler booker,alabama.
•ot josh simmons,ohio st(not listed).

i'd be happy with any of those four.
right now...i'd lean stewart.

 

[baltcowboy]

Agree, does so many things well
Virtually gives a team a #2 reciever


It is a realistic scenario that could play out.

But at 12, with the 2Qb available, trade down becomes more & more possible...at 12, they have value

I think he said you couldn’t trade.

 

[bleachedwheat]

From the responses, it looks like a consensus pick would be hard to deliberate.
Everyone is all over the place with whom they would take in this scenario.

I guess we can just hope 2 or 3 QB's go before 12. That should make things easier.

 

[BotchedLobotomy]

Giants will draft Sanders, that puts two QB in the top 11. Take it to the bank.

 

[BrAinPaiNt]

Mike Green

Mike and Micah would be a formidable pass rushing duo

 

[bleachedwheat]

Hard Pass on G Tyler Booker. His times at the combine were very slow, plus he only benched 220 lbs 21 times. All very poor results for an interior olineman who plays guard and will be expected to pull and push.

Out of all the players listed and if no one was willing to trade up for the Cowboys 12th pick, I would take WR Matthew Golden first because he would immediately help at a position of need. If not him, possibly Edge Mike Green.

I'm not to worried about Booker's RAS(Relative Athletic Score), in this system he won't be asked to get out on the edge a bunch. It should be a bunch of Gap Scheme and Duo Blocks. His RAS score does eliminate him from teams who run Outside Zone like the Dolphins and 49ers.

21 on the bench was a bit surprising because he is a people mover. On tape he throws people around with ease. He has 34.5 inch arms; long for a Guard. I'll just make an excuse for him and say he had further to go each rep than the others did.

Golden at 12 is a bit rich for my blood but Green at 12, I could get behind that pick.

 

[cnuball21]

1. Titans- QB Cam Ward, Miami
2. Browns- CB/WR Travis Hunter, Colorado
3. Giants- DE Abdul Carter, Penn State
4. Patriots- WR Tet McMillan, Arizona
5. Jaguars- DT Mason Graham, Michigan
6. Raiders- RB Ashton Jeanty, Boise State
7. Jets- RT Armand Membou, Missouri
8. Panthers- Edge/LB Jalon Walker, Georgia
9. Saints- CB Will Johnson, Michigan
10. Bears- DE Mykel Williams, Georgia
11. 49ers- T/G Will Campbell, LSU

If only 1 QB goes before the Cowboys pick, it really hurts.
Choices:
WR Matthew Golden, Texas
TE Tyler Warren, Penn State
T/G Kelvin Banks, Texas
G Tyler Booker, Alabama
Edge Mike Green, Marshall
DE Shemar Stewart, Texas A&M
DB Jahdae Barron, Texas

None of the picks are Ideal and trading down requires another team to want to move up for one of these guys. If you have to stay put and pick, who would it be.

For me I would go with
1. G Booker
2. Edge Green
3. DB Barron

Not having a player there that really jumps off the page, my thinking would be to just draft the safest player.
Booker is the least likely player to bust, from this list; in my opinion. The Interior line becomes a strength and the team has said they want to run the ball a lot this season.

I would also sign T Tyron Smith after the draft to play swing tackle for a year. If signed after the draft he doesn't affect the comp pick formula. It would be nice to have a failsafe for Guyton and Steele.

What would you do if it went like this. Everyone is just assuming that multiple QB's are taken before 12.

If the off the field concerns with Pearce / Green are legit I’d go Burden or Simmons (if meds are clear).

 

[cnuball21]

If Pearce / Green concerns aren’t legit:

- Pearce
- Burden
- Green
- Simmons

Would be my big board.

 

[Acceptablename]

1. Titans- QB Cam Ward, Miami
2. Browns- CB/WR Travis Hunter, Colorado
3. Giants- DE Abdul Carter, Penn State
4. Patriots- WR Tet McMillan, Arizona
5. Jaguars- DT Mason Graham, Michigan
6. Raiders- RB Ashton Jeanty, Boise State
7. Jets- RT Armand Membou, Missouri
8. Panthers- Edge/LB Jalon Walker, Georgia
9. Saints- CB Will Johnson, Michigan
10. Bears- DE Mykel Williams, Georgia
11. 49ers- T/G Will Campbell, LSU

If only 1 QB goes before the Cowboys pick, it really hurts.
Choices:
WR Matthew Golden, Texas
TE Tyler Warren, Penn State
T/G Kelvin Banks, Texas
G Tyler Booker, Alabama
Edge Mike Green, Marshall
DE Shemar Stewart, Texas A&M
DB Jahdae Barron, Texas

None of the picks are Ideal and trading down requires another team to want to move up for one of these guys. If you have to stay put and pick, who would it be.

For me I would go with
1. G Booker
2. Edge Green
3. DB Barron

Not having a player there that really jumps off the page, my thinking would be to just draft the safest player.
Booker is the least likely player to bust, from this list; in my opinion. The Interior line becomes a strength and the team has said they want to run the ball a lot this season.

I would also sign T Tyron Smith after the draft to play swing tackle for a year. If signed after the draft he doesn't affect the comp pick formula. It would be nice to have a failsafe for Guyton and Steele.

What would you do if it went like this. Everyone is just assuming that multiple QB's are taken before 12.

Booker I know it is really reaching But this is an odd draft if that's a reason. But you have to take aBut this is an odd draft if that's a reason. But you have to take a running back in the second or third round

 

[Mikexike]

Agree, does so many things well
Virtually gives a team a #2 reciever


It is a realistic scenario that could play out.

But at 12, with the 2Qb available, trade down becomes more & more possible...at 12, they have value

Even though Warren is not talented as brock bowers, he would make the biggest impact for our offense and Dak. Security blanket!

 

[DoctorChicken]

I’m probably just taking Warren there.

He’s going to be a really good TE and could potentially be an awesome TE. High floor and high ceiling player.

It’d be Green if not for the fact that he might be a horrible person.

 

[sbark]

I think he said you couldn’t trade.

Ya I know
Thing is...as 2QB’s drop to 12.....
Trade cost vrs potential become too tempting...
Odds are Cowboys get offers