if u had to cut one

[david_jackson]

Wow - how many times do we have to go over who is or isn't PUP eligible. It is simple - you play in TC at all -- NO PUP.

I agree PUP is definately the way to go!

 

[silver]

Barber.

Potential yes, but he hasnt shown much other than the fact that he coughs up the ball every now and then. Thomas has a better resume. Barber seems like a ps candidate. if the guy can't play st, he'll be waived

 

[Mike 1967]

A-Train, less upside and brings nothing to special teams.

Tuna learned his lesson about Vet experience at RB last year, I hope.

What he said

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Barber. Thompson needs time but he may get there. A-Train understands the Pro game. He won't get your QB killed and he does play special teams. He will get you a couple of yards and he can play a 16 game season should it come down to that. Barber isn't healthy. He's turned the ball over. He hasn't shown he can get it done. You can't grade him on what he hasn't shown.

Now, the real answer is none of them. I would send one of them to developement.

Parcells said Barber might be ready for the game this Thursday, so right now hes as injured as Ferguson.

-Anthony Thomas really cant play ST.

Thompson and Barber have returned kicks and covered kicks.

 

[SmashFactorGolf]

lets see......based upon last year...how long did it take for BP to "trust" a rookie rb in Julius........

expeireince tells me he will keep a vet rb, hope all stay one way or another at expense of fb position which TE or a guard can cover but.......likley gonna use 2 TE sets alot to help cover up Pettie right side for awhile anyway

 

[blindzebra]

lets see......based upon last year...how long did it take for BP to "trust" a rookie rb in Julius........

expeireince tells me he will keep a vet rb, hope all stay one way or another at expense of fb position which TE or a guard can cover but.......likley gonna use 2 TE sets alot to help cover up Pettie right side for awhile anyway

The second he was healthy.