If you had to pick one of these quarterbacks to be your starter, who are you rolling with?

[mahoneybill]

Carr has better accuracy than Dak

A few years ago they had a passing contest , and Carr beat him very decisively

 

[garyv]

Dak Prescott
Derek Carr
Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady

Aaron Rodgers

 

[CWR]

Does it have to be from this list? If I had a choice outside of this list it would be Burrow.


Yep, Brady has reached the end. Dallas is lucky they got to face him in the playoffs over anyone else. The win against them was not the least bit impressive because of Brady's decline.

Yet half the board picked Tampa to win. I think more than anything his decline was hastened by the constant harassment we put on him. Although I will agree I'd rather not go with Brady at this point in his career. I'd probably pick Rodgers out of those choices, but I want to see Dak in a new offense.

 

[DasTex]

Rodgers and it's not close

 

[jgboys1]

In order:

Rodgers
Brady
Carr







Dak

I would just swap Brady and Carr. I think Brady's tank is on E but I would take him over Dak.

 

[BlueStar22]

Right now? Dak Prescott. Brady is old. Rodgers is a clown and thinks the world revolves around him. Derek Carr isn't a better QB than Dak.

 

[UncleRico]

Dak Prescott
Derek Carr
Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady

Rodgers
Brady
Dak
Carr

 

[gimmesix]

Dak Prescott
Derek Carr
Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady

A few years ago, it would have been Brady. But right now, it would probably be Rodgers. He's also not what he once was, but he may have a couple of good years left.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Dak Prescott
Derek Carr
Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady

Rodgers

 

[IceStar-D7]

Dak Prescott
Derek Carr
Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady

Dak Prescott.....or maybe Rodgers

 

[FloridaRob]

LOL


You rather a QB that is for a fact gonna fall short in the playoffs?


Give me geriatric Tom

Tom has only won because he had great defenses that supported him. the only time Rodgers had a top defense, they won the super bowl. If Dallas would have had Rodgers this year with the defense that Dallas had, Dallas would still be playing.

 

[beacamdim]

In order:

Rodgers
Brady
Carr



Daniel Jones



Dak

 

[shabazz]

Mahomes or Burrow

 

[G2]

Are wheelchairs allowed?

 

[catiii]

A few years ago they had a passing contest , and Carr beat him very decisively

Dakbois won't believe you without proof and these weren't even moving targets!!

 

[Captain-Crash]

Carr will be playing for Tampa Bay next year.

The original question, abd.

 

[HanD]

Rogers



Dak or Carr doesn't matter it's the same. Carr has no playoff wins though.



Brady with all due respect.

 

[blueblood70]

Brady. Give him an OL and he can still lead a championship offense.

How about this , GIVE Dak an OL the one Rush had with a Run game, rush had and defense all season that rush had , not the facts that actually went down the last 5 games of the season and reared back up in the 9er game.

seriously

the entire threads is fix the OL get a run game and X-QB can succeed. we saw rogers, brady, carr etc all struggle when there offense struggled around them,.. we beat brady on the road the rest didn't make the payoffs...neither did many top 10 highly pad QBS

laughable, thats all dak needs as well..

you all are in denial on why we fail in many of these playoff games, we were out physical led along the OL, run game shut down,. dirty pocket, WR not getting separation or allowing themselves to be knocked off their route and have a CB beat them to spot to Intercept the ball ie zero effort, and Schultz 2 mental gaffs on a 3min drive, and an OC play calls suspect once pollard goes down 16 runs and not even use Malik at all in the 2nd half to fight for some run yards. a one-dimensional offense with an OL that was not creating a cleaner consistent pocket is going to struggle against the best Defenses in the league.

right when Dak has an offense that even shows up and pays average around him lie some type of run game, oc sticking to run and an OL not being knocked back a yard at the snap and literally having Dak instantly having to decide to run or get rid of it before he was ready and before the routes developed.

how about that??

 

[blueblood70]

Dak Prescott
Derek Carr
Aaron Rodgers
Tom Brady

Dak hes under contract, and our qb for 2023 that easy...its 100% Dak

all those players failed without better team play...

How about this,

GIVE Dak an OL the one Rush had with a Run game, give Dak the Special teams not fumbling snaps, missing Xps, and muffing punts, a defense all season that rush had those 5 games , not the facts that actually went down the last 5 games of the season and reared back up in the 9er game. Dak didn't get those things.

seriously

the entire threads is fix the OL get a run game and X-QB can succeed. we saw rogers, brady, carr etc all struggle when there offense struggled around them,.. we beat brady on the road the rest didn't make the payoffs...neither did many top 10 highly pad QBS

laughable, thats all dak needs as well..

you all are in denial on why we fail in many of these playoff games, we were out physical led along the OL, run game shut down,. dirty pocket, WR not getting separation or allowing themselves to be knocked off their route and have a CB beat them to spot to Intercept the ball ie zero effort, and Schultz 2 mental gaffs on a 3min drive, and an OC play calls suspect once pollard goes down 16 runs and not even use Malik at all in the 2nd half to fight for some run yards. a one-dimensional offense with an OL that was not creating a cleaner consistent pocket is going to struggle against the best Defenses in the league.

right when Dak has an offense that even shows up and pays average around him lie some type of run game, oc sticking to run and an OL not being knocked back a yard at the snap and literally having Dak instantly having to decide to run or get rid of it before he was ready and before the routes developed.

how about that??

 

[blueblood70]

Right now? Dak Prescott. Brady is old. Rodgers is a clown and thinks the world revolves around him. Derek Carr isn't a better QB than Dak.