Instant replay

yesfan

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,780
Reaction score
661
The booth will look over a play in the final two minutes of a game and
what i don't get is why have replay if an official can just throw the flag
and is wrong,and can't be reviewed.As long as they're trying to add new
rules then why not have that booth review on the officials for their errant
interference calls.More than anything else if not only just for the interference
those bad calls are game killers. Just venting i guess.
 

superonyx

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,478
Reaction score
15,836
I agree 100%. Now every penalty should not be reviewable. However any pass interference penalties that are call in the end zone should be able to be reviewed. A Pass interference call in the end zone isnt much different than a TD. When was the last time a team got stopped when they had 1st down from the 1 yard line?

I think the league needs to make an adjustment and stop giving away free touchdowns. A call like that can and will change a game completely.
Isnt getting it right the most important thing?
 

yesfan

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,780
Reaction score
661
Yes,i'm only addressing the interference calls and that their should
be an officiating review or something so that these bad calls that can
really change the outcome of a game, can be overturned.
 

TellerMorrow34

BraveHeartFan
Messages
28,358
Reaction score
5,076
I agree there should be some provision in there for them to have to replay a big penalty, like the PI they called on Henry which was CLEARLY PI on the Eagles WR.

That's one of those things where I don't think the defense played quite as bad (though they certainly weren't great) as everyone is so worried about. They gave up 1 TD in the second half, on a possession where the Eagles were allowed to start at our 45 yard line. They gave up a TD in the first half after the Romo INT that gave the ball to the Eagles on like our 35 or 40 yard line.

Then they got that TD after a HORRIBLE PI call gave them first and goal at the one.

I'm certainly not saying they don't deserve some tough love, cause they allowed the Eagles to make too many plays, but this idea that they some how suck badly, given some of these situations, is premature, IMO.
 
Top