Interesting piece on play calling

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
39,793
Reaction score
23,853
I saw an ESPN piece on McVay and his uncanny photo graphic memory...read this piece on play calling. it was pretty good. basically most plays on teams are similar, personnel and creating mismatches is the key. and doing that during the game is the real key. not every play call is necessarily made to succeed, although all plays are designed to succeed, but they are called sometimes to explore how the other side reacts to what you are trying to do.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nf...ut-smart-opponents/ar-BBNTjQ3?ocid=spartandhp
 
Doesn't seem like we ever try to exploit a weakness. We seem to roll out the same game plan week in and week out. Been like that for many years. Even during the game, cornerback would get injured, new cornerback enters the game...do we throw at them? Nope, don't even look to their side.
 
I saw an ESPN piece on McVay and his uncanny photo graphic memory...read this piece on play calling. it was pretty good. basically most plays on teams are similar, personnel and creating mismatches is the key. and doing that during the game is the real key. not every play call is necessarily made to succeed, although all plays are designed to succeed, but they are called sometimes to explore how the other side reacts to what you are trying to do.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nf...ut-smart-opponents/ar-BBNTjQ3?ocid=spartandhp

GREAT article!!!!!! That is EXACTLY what anyone who truly knows the game should see about McVay (and they best play callers) - they keep adjusting on the fly to exploit simple deficiencies in the D. Literally showing the same looks, yet changing 1route or player positioning can mean the world in a game of inches. And, what it showed is that Linehan/Garrett are stubborn as hell and will keep banging their heads against the wall.
 
Doesn't seem like we ever try to exploit a weakness. We seem to roll out the same game plan week in and week out. Been like that for many years. Even during the game, cornerback would get injured, new cornerback enters the game...do we throw at them? Nope, don't even look to their side.
How do you know. Aplaybwasnt called to that side, and dink and dak decides to play it safe and dump it off to someone five yards down field?
 
How do you know. Aplaybwasnt called to that side, and dink and dak decides to play it safe and dump it off to someone five yards down field?
I was thinking with Romo we didn't do it. And how do I know, because I would wonder why we don't try to attack the back up corner that just entered the game.

You know, a lot of complaints people have now were complaints when Romo was QB too? Like the not throwing deep, check down to Witten on 3rd down, and stalling in the red zone?

I know Dak has turned you into a Cowboys hater but these problems existed when you were being blind.
 
GREAT article!!!!!! That is EXACTLY what anyone who truly knows the game should see about McVay (and they best play callers) - they keep adjusting on the fly to exploit simple deficiencies in the D. Literally showing the same looks, yet changing 1route or player positioning can mean the world in a game of inches. And, what it showed is that Linehan/Garrett are stubborn as hell and will keep banging their heads against the wall.
Our pats per game is the most important stat, on offense.

Since 2010, and not in correctborder, here is what we have avg. per game.
27.4
22.1
26.6
17.2
23.5
24.6
16.8
28.4
23.1

This year is included in those numbers. Any cowboys fan can easily pick out this year and 2015.
So did our coaches just forget how to coach in those years?
What about th eyears we were in top 5 in pats scored? Were they eating their spinach and staying extra late studying film?


Stop blaming coaching for everything. The common denominator in those two crappy seasons above is no crappy coaching, but crappy qb play.
 
I was thinking with Romo we didn't do it. And how do I know, because I would wonder why we don't try to attack the back up corner that just entered the game.

You know, a lot of complaints people have now were complaints when Romo was QB too? Like the not throwing deep, check down to Witten on 3rd down, and stalling in the red zone?

I know Dak has turned you into a Cowboys hater but these problems existed when you were being blind.
Except our offense was still scoring points at a high clip. I don’t care how dak does it, if we scored 23 a game, and he threw three passes a game, I’d be ok with that. 16 pats. Agame won’t cut it.

And I know you bash the coaches all day... and I bash dak and I am a “cowboy hater.” So since you bash our coaches, does that also make you a cowboys hater?
 
Doesn't seem like we ever try to exploit a weakness. We seem to roll out the same game plan week in and week out. Been like that for many years. Even during the game, cornerback would get injured, new cornerback enters the game...do we throw at them? Nope, don't even look to their side.
I agree. You heard Dez. Lining up the same spot for years. Lol. Same with the whole team. Makes it easy to defend when you know the routes.
 
McVay largely uses the same personnel grouping, 3WR 1TE 1RB. And he still creates mismatches, all the time.

The NFL is about mismatches. It really is like a chess match. I'll never understand people that watch it for decades and still have no desire to learn the strategy, it's the best part.

To really play the game, you have to study tendencies, like the Vikings in the article. Once you can see what the tendencies are, if you want to succeed in the NFL in 2018, you have to attack the weaknesses in the tendencies. This is straight up personnel alignment, route design, using motion, whatever you can use to take advantage.

McVay also uses play action a lot. Which is another factor that comes into play in the NFL, hesitation. Anytime you can do anything to keep defenders off balance, you're at an advantage, this is a game of inches after all.

What makes this interesting nowadays, is lack of practice for NFL defenses and constantly changing personnel. This leads to more hesitation, more mistakes.

This is why these new offenses we're seeing tend to use a lot of motion, play action, west coast spread type principles. They have good coaches that are great at seeing tendencies and know how to exploit them. They also do just about everything they can to keep a defense off balance and force mistakes.

McVay runs less RPO but pretty sure they're near the top of the league in play action. Primarily same personnel every play. Other teams are running RPO stuff (not read option), and college kids are picking it up quick and its changing the game.

Some people don't like it, but it's not going anywhere. It's not some sort of "trick", as you can see in the article or really watching most of these attacks. The principles are sound, at the core defenses are simply getting outschemed. That route he noticed Barr on Woods was straight up football.

I think it's pretty revolutionary. Fun to watch.
 
I agree. You heard Dez. Lining up the same spot for years. Lol. Same with the whole team. Makes it easy to defend when you know the routes.
Was Dez lining up in the same place as he was when he was leading the nfl in td receptions over a five or six year period?
 
Last edited:
The core philosophy of the "Sling It Around Offense" is based on the notion that opposing DC's take the week off before playing Dallas and all defenses are exactly the same. Success is predicated on every starter being available and the Offensive Line being able to Mack Truck the defense every snap. When these conditions exist the "Sling It Around Offense" can be effective. When these conditions do not exist - chaos abounds.
 
Really interesting article.

No way the Cowboys offensive coaches have this kind of sophistication.

Coaching has never been more important than it is in 2018. And Dallas is in the bottom quarter of the league in this area.
 
so the defensive play callers are going to have to start changing things up every game like the offenses and change coverages zimmer got out coached because he called the same defenses every time
 
Except our offense was still scoring points at a high clip. I don’t care how dak does it, if we scored 23 a game, and he threw three passes a game, I’d be ok with that. 16 pats. Agame won’t cut it.

And I know you bash the coaches all day... and I bash dak and I am a “cowboy hater.” So since you bash our coaches, does that also make you a cowboys hater?

Agree
 
Really interesting article.

No way the Cowboys offensive coaches have this kind of sophistication.

Coaching has never been more important than it is in 2018. And Dallas is in the bottom quarter of the league in this area.

Lol... you know this how? Or is the coach limited by the qb
 
so the defensive play callers are going to have to start changing things up every game like the offenses and change coverages zimmer got out coached because he called the same defenses every time
The Patriots destroyed the Dolphins last week.

But the one pick Brady threw, he said it was because he had not seen the Dolphins play that particular defense in 10 years.

That's how coaching works in 2018.
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,658
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top