Is Dak elite?

[gtb1943]

Definitely and interesting example. I think the thing that separates him from most other QBs is he makes those couple plays like WTH? the extend drives and scores TDs. I wonder if there is some metric about that.

The WTH metric. Or maybe the Hail Mary metric?

 

[SteveTheCowboy]

Eli had a consistent running game and a defense that played great in the playoffs. He also made some huge plays in critical moments. He definitely wouldn’t have won those Super Bowls with the Cowboys. QB wasn’t our problem then and it isn’t now.

Eli had big bruising RBs and WRs that would flat out chase the ball. Eli heaved it up they went and got there were very few tight windows.

Luckiest QB ever.

 

[SteveTheCowboy]

The WTH metric. Or maybe the Hail Mary metric?

Side arm metric?

 

[Chasing6]

Definitely and interesting example. I think the thing that separates him from most other QBs is he makes those couple plays like WTH? the extend drives and scores TDs. I wonder if there is some metric about that.

It has absolutely nothing to do with their Defense. Nothing at all.

 

[doomsday808]

I will start with Dan Marino.

Ahhh, I though you were going to say Jim Kelly. Now make a list of Elite QB's with SB wins. Which list is longer?

 

[gtb1943]

Eli had big bruising RBs and WRs that would flat out chase the ball. Eli heaved it up they went and got there were very few tight windows.

Luckiest QB ever.

that helmet play; and so many eli fans like to forget samuels dropping a sure pick the previous play

 

[Qcard]

Then what is it about?

Great question....

Let me know when you are having the next Dak Hate Convention

 

[gtb1943]

Ahhh, I though you were going to say Jim Kelly. Now make a list of Elite QB's with SB wins. Which list is longer?

Well how about a list of QBs with rings who are not:
All three that GIbbs won with
Dilfer and Johnson
Flacco and Stafford
Eli and Foles
go way back and talk about Jim Plunkett getting two rings

 

[gtb1943]

Hostetler and Simms were not elite as well
Was Kurt Warner? Arguable

 

[SteveTheCowboy]

It has absolutely nothing to do with their Defense. Nothing at all.

huge defense! imho.

 

[Chasing6]

huge defense! imho.

1000%

 

[SuspectCorner]

Dak is on the edges of top ten - just in or just out.

 

[gtb1943]

huge defense! imho.

That last SB win the KC D stood up when their offense was DOA

 

[Havic]

IF i had to chose i would pick Dak

I'm taking Cousins, very similair Qb's, I think Cousins is a little bit better passer but Kirk would free up an extra 20M in cap space roughly.

 

[Ranching]

No it's actually not.

Yes it is....had yours made a difference? All your energy that you have used pointing out negatives day after day after day....what difference has that made? No more than my or anyone else's input. Jerry's team and money....he's the only one that matters in this issue.

 

[gtb1943]

Yes it is....had yours made a difference? All your energy that you have used pointing out negatives day after day after day....what difference has that made? No more than my or anyone else's input. Jerry's team and money....he's the only one that matters in this issue.

so you are now a board Mod telling other people to leave?

 

[BoysForLife]

Great question....

Let me know when you are having the next Dak Hate Convention

We usually end up meeting right after the opening playoff game. Could be earlier this year though. We'll keep you posted

 

[DStar22]

He can't even spell Elite.

 

[Ranching]

so you are now a board Mod telling other people to leave?

Where did you pull that out of? Make sure you wash your hands after handling it.

 

[Ranching]

We usually end up meeting right after the opening playoff game. Could be earlier this year though. We'll keep you posted

Lol! You must have not been invited to the daily poking the Dak voodoo dolls meetings...