is Deuce Mcallister good?

[locked&loaded]

he doestn seem to get touchdowns, but his yardage seems to be good. so what im trying to say is if reggie bush turns out to be amazingggggggggggg. and deuce is being traded would he fetch alot of takers?

 

[Bob Sacamano]

deuce is being traded would he fetch alot of takers?

I don't know, he'll be 28 next year I believe, so after next year, he'll be approaching that wall for RBs, and he would have to stay healthy

he would probably fetch a 2nd at most, most likely a 3rd

 

[cobra]

I'd take Deuce.

He is very good. Not great. But very good. I think he would probably fit better as an every down back in BP's offense than either one of our guys individually.

 

[BlueWave]

I think McAllister has to worry about getting back to his preinjury form before anything else.

That being said, I think Reggie Bush fill seats. Reggie Bush sells jerseys. Reggie Bush puts the Saints, and New Orleans, on the map. That's what the NFL wanted when they told the Texans not to draft him (my opinion only). He will eventually save the franchise and keep them in New Orleans, Deuce would not have.

 

[AbeBeta]

I'd think the Saints could get a 2nd for him. He's young. Still got some miles left. He doesn't score many TDs b/c the Saints suck

 

[Yakuza Rich]

Had nearly 1,700 yards rushing in 2004 at 4.7 ypc.

I actually created Reggie Bush in Madden '06. I gave Bush an 86 rating with 93 speed and 94 catching ability.

I absolutely killed teams with Bush in McCallister in the same backfield because Bush was so hard to defend. I could start him from the backfield and either have him catch passes out of there or motion him out wide like a WR and create massive mismatches. And if they guarded against Bush receiving, I could just run the ball.

Something tells me that Payton will screw this up.


Rich...........

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Something tells me that Payton will screw this up.


Rich...........

hehe, but he is pretty creative

 

[Yeagermeister]

Duece is good when healthy but he can't seem to stay that way.

 

[Yakuza Rich]

Duece is good when healthy but he can't seem to stay that way.

In his first 4 years he missed a total of 3 games.

Not really all that injury prone.


Rich...........

 

[Sarge]

A healthy Deuce is a very very underrated and under-appreciated RB in this league.

 

[Chocolate Lab]

A healthy Deuce is a very very underrated and under-appreciated RB in this league.

 

[Qwickdraw]

He's washed up by now. (ie: Stephen Davis, Jamal Lewis)

He was great once. Now he's an injury waiting to happen. He'll get overpaid somewhere.