Is play-calling stifling Phillips, Merriman?

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,281
Reaction score
45,639
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Only because I'm in the mood to start something. ;)

---------------

By Kevin Acee
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

October 5, 2007



K.C. ALFRED / Union-Tribune
Shaun Phillips sacks the Packers' Brett Favre two weeks ago, something the Chargers hope to see more of.

Denver RB in trouble again?


Ted Cottrell acknowledges that who he hasn't had and what he has been facing have influenced his play-calling.
But the Chargers defensive coordinator vehemently denies he is holding back the league's best pass rushing duo and, by extension, the league's most feared pass rushing front.

“It's aggressive,” Cottrell said of his scheme.

When evidence to the contrary was mentioned, Cottrell said, “Well, whatever. I'm not going to argue with you. But I'm not sitting back and playing frickin' coverage – don't tell me I'm not going after people.”

Well, something is going on (or not going on) – as evidenced by the simple fact the Chargers have just nine sacks through four games, ranking 14th in the league after leading the league last season with an average of almost four a game.

And an analysis of the Chargers game against the Kansas City Chiefs this past week and the one against the Chiefs last December reveals severe discrepancies in the way outside linebackers Shaun Phillips and, especially, Shawne Merriman were used.

In December's Chiefs game, as in pretty much every game last season, Merriman and Phillips were like kids in the backyard – rushing the quarterback without having to count to even “one alligator.” It was a track meet, stallions running wild. First down, second down, third down, whatever.

And their aggressiveness bled into the rest of the defense, as the Chargers flew around on seemingly every play.

This past week was most often more like watching a waltz.

In the December game, Merriman and Phillips blitzed on the same pass play 24 times. Both sat out a handful of plays, and while one or both were out, the outside linebackers blitzed together on five different plays. That's an all-out blitz on 62 percent of the Chiefs' 47 pass plays that day.


Last week, Merriman and Phillips blitzed together just nine times in 31 pass plays (29 percent).
Last December, Merriman dropped into coverage 10 times on 47 pass plays, Phillips four times and Carlos Polk twice. Never did the two outside linebackers drop back together.

Last week, Merriman was in coverage 14 times. Phillips was in coverage five times, including three times on the same play as Merriman.

The numbers would appear to be a reflection and a result of the attack.

In December, the Chargers sacked Trent Green six times, held the Chiefs to 241 yards and nine points – and won by 11.

Last week, the Chargers sacked Damon Huard twice, allowed the Chiefs 390 yards and 30 points – and lost by 14.

Phillips had just one sack in that December game and Merriman none. But their occupying blockers and disrupting the pocket resulted in other Chargers getting five sacks among them. Last Sunday, the Chargers had two sacks – one each by Merriman and Phillips.

Under former coordinator Wade Phillips, opponents often simply had too many pass rushers to properly block. That's rarely an issue this season.

Merriman led the league with 17 sacks in 2006, while Phillips' 11½ sacks were second only to Merriman among linebackers.

Cottrell bristled at the suggestion his scheme is to blame for a dropoff.

“Those two are good rushers,” he said. “I'm not sitting here talking about, 'Hey, I'm not going to use the tools I got.' But also, you have to be careful with the tools, be (aware) of how people are attacking you too.”

Cottrell points to the fact the Chargers' past three opponents have spread them out and gotten off quick passes, which often negates an effective pass rush. That is true. But Huard also had plenty of time to throw on too many plays Sunday, the pocket he had to work in sometimes looking as if it had been parted by Moses.

“It shouldn't have been,” Cottrell said of Huard's safe work zone. “We had called some things that just didn't – we're working on them.”

Cottrell has been somewhat hamstrung by the absence of inside linebacker Matt Wilhelm, whose athleticism is useful in coverage. Wilhelm has missed three games with a calf injury but will start Sunday in Denver.

“It's going to help tremendously,” Cottrell said. “That affects what you call and the volume of things you can call.”

As for the players' feelings about the defense as it is currently constructed, what they don't say is more damning than what they do say.

“I just run the plays that are called,” Merriman said.

And that is all he would say, sometimes a smile forming as he spoke, sometimes a shake of the head, sometimes a blank expression.

Phillips went after Huard more than Merriman, who was busy trying to disrupt the routes of tight end Tony Gonzalez. Phillips is loquacious in his support of Cottrell, but he sidesteps questions about any changes.

“I don't know,” Phillips said. “I'm not a coach. Me personally, I would want to rush every time. It can't work that way. It's not about me and Shawne. It's about this team and what this team can do better.

“It's still football. See ball, go get ball. I like what's going on. I believe in Teddy. I believe in his philosophy. We just need to make more impact plays.”

LINK
 

YosemiteSam

Unfriendly and Aloof!
Messages
45,858
Reaction score
22,189
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I have the answer. This season Merriman is not using steroids! :lmao2:
 

sago1

Active Member
Messages
7,791
Reaction score
0
I remember reading in San Diego newspaper when Cottrell was hired to replace Phillips that number of Charger players were concerned whether Cottrell would be as effective as Wade Phillips in making adjustments to his defense as the situation warrants.

I do know that our defense is steadily improving even if we not playing quality teams. Hopefully the defense with the addition of Ellis & Newman continue to improve. Sure would like to have a healthy Anthony Henry in there against the Patriots.
 

YosemiteSam

Unfriendly and Aloof!
Messages
45,858
Reaction score
22,189
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
sago1;1688067 said:
I remember reading in San Diego newspaper when Cottrell was hired to replace Phillips that number of Charger players were concerned whether Cottrell would be as effective as Wade Phillips in making adjustments to his defense as the situation warrants.

I do know that our defense is steadily improving even if we not playing quality teams. Hopefully the defense with the addition of Ellis & Newman continue to improve. Sure would like to have a healthy Anthony Henry in there against the Patriots.

I would like to hold the Patriots to 187 yards like we did the Rams. Two forced fumbles and three INTs would be nice too. Seven sacks of Brady to boot! As for Moss. One catch for seven yards. ;) :p:
 

Wood

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,447
Reaction score
5,697
Nice to see Merriman dropping into coverage like Ware had been. Is it no suprise his numbers a down. Now just watch what Ware can do now that Ellis is back in there.
 

burmafrd

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,820
Reaction score
3,379
He no longer has the strength of roids. That also is a factor.
 

Echo9

Erik_H
Messages
3,773
Reaction score
1,814
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
WoodysGirl;1688021 said:
Only because I'm in the mood to start something. ;)

---------------

By Kevin Acee
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

October 5, 2007



K.C. ALFRED / Union-Tribune
Shaun Phillips sacks the Packers' Brett Favre two weeks ago, something the Chargers hope to see more of.

Denver RB in trouble again?


Ted Cottrell acknowledges that who he hasn't had and what he has been facing have influenced his play-calling.

LINK

Stirrin the pot again eh?:lmao2:
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,107
Reaction score
11,449
It's simple: Cottrell is no Wade. Just because he uses Wade's system doesn't mean he can coach or call it as effectively.
 

superpunk

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,330
Reaction score
75
WoodysGirl;1688021 said:
In the December game, Merriman and Phillips blitzed on the same pass play 24 times. Both sat out a handful of plays, and while one or both were out, the outside linebackers blitzed together on five different plays. That's an all-out blitz on 62 percent of the Chiefs' 47 pass plays that day.


Last week, Merriman and Phillips blitzed together just nine times in 31 pass plays (29 percent).
Last December, Merriman dropped into coverage 10 times on 47 pass plays, Phillips four times and Carlos Polk twice. Never did the two outside linebackers drop back together.

It's not a matter of where he grips it, it's a simple matter of weight ratios.

Listen, a guy who blitzes half as much as another guy is not going to produce as much. Which makes Ware's 11 sacks last year awful impressive. Merriman's blitzing less now, he's going to get less sacks unless that changes, held under the dorsal guiding feathers or not.

The Chargers defense is not really the unit that is disappointing, to be honest.
 

theebs

Believe!!!!
Messages
27,462
Reaction score
9,207
ted cottrell is and always has been one of the worst coaches in the league, If you put a gun to my head I would blame him more for their troubles than turner.

If norv had been hired here and he brought along cottrell, I would have been physically ill. Norv told jerry " I have a guy in mind" when he was interviewed when talking about the defense, everyone assumed he meant Ron Rivera, I bet he meant cottrell...

Thank goodness that is not the duo here.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,107
Reaction score
11,449
I dunno, Theebs... I got the idea Cottrell was more an A.J. Smith call so they could keep exactly the same defense they'd run before.

Man... We dodged a bullet when Jerry didn't pick Norv. :pray:
 

superpunk

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,330
Reaction score
75
Chocolate Lab;1688305 said:
I dunno, Theebs... I got the idea Cottrell was more an A.J. Smith call so they could keep exactly the same defense they'd run before.

Man... We dodged a bullet when Jerry didn't pick Norv.

Word, ninja.

The worst part of that team is that they have no identity, or direction. Another problem may be that Rivers is not a franchise QB who can handle the load and the pressure if LT is being keyed on.

I don't know what those coaches are teaching them during the week, but you could make a lowlights reel of this year of the same play - it goes a little something like this;

Rivers drops back, Tomlinson steps up, chips a guy, and then rolls to the left flat - Rivers throws it and hits an unaware Tomlinson in the side of the helmet.

Rinse and repeat.

Maybe he should have played in the preseason...
 

YosemiteSam

Unfriendly and Aloof!
Messages
45,858
Reaction score
22,189
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
superpunk;1688333 said:
Another problem may be that Rivers is not a franchise QB who can handle the load and the pressure if LT is being keyed on.

I saw Rivers as a weakness last season and thought it was crazy to give up on Brees so quickly and go to an unproven QB. After that debacle and then the bout with Schottenheimer followed by his firing, they should just can A.J. Smith now. He is making Matt Millen look good.
 

dmq

If I'm so pretty, why am I available?
Messages
7,436
Reaction score
941
Maybe we can pick Merriman or Phillips off the waiver wire after this season.;)
 
Top