Surtain is the better player.
But I have to admit. Football is entertainment, and a part of me wants to pick Horn because the physicality and how entertaining that is. It's not something that can be tied to wins and losses through analytics, but it's something I enjoy to see while watching the game. It's stupid, completely irrelevant in a data-driven league, but it's omething I can't shake.
I want to enjoy the game, and I think a guy like Colombo is more exciting to watch than a guy like Byron. Even just for the occassional **** disturbance.