I forgot who posted this here, or was it on Vela's site ... anyway ... the following from Bigblueinteractive Giants fan site FWIW. Some downpoints on Mendenhall to make everyone feel better. ....
-----
McFadden was named the top back in the draft by 16 of 17 scouts in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel poll asking them to rate their favorites on a 1-to-5basis, with a first-place vote worth five points and so on. He totaled 84 points.
Following, in order, were Oregon's Jonathan Stewart (one first) and Illinois' Rashard Mendenhall, 56; Arkansas' Felix Jones, 31; Texas' Jamaal Charles, 17; Rutgers' Ray Rice, 7; Central Florida's Kevin Smith, 2; and East Carolina's Chris Johnson and South Carolina's Cory Boyd, 1.
When the 17 scouts were asked which of the top 10 backs had the best chance to bust, the votes were: Johnson, 4; McFadden and Stewart, 2; Rice and Charles, 2; and Tulane's Matt Forte, Jones, Mendenhall and Smith, 1.
---
3. RASHARD MENDENHALL, Illinois (5-10, 225, 4.42, 1) - Third-year junior didn't start until '07, when he gained 1,681 yards and was Big Ten offensive player of the year. "He's going to be a really, really good back," Buffalo VP of college scouting Tom Modrak said. "He's big, you don't catch him, he makes people miss." Straight-line style somewhat reminiscent of Herschel Walker. "He can't break down, cut and change direction," one scout said. "I was surprised how stiff he was. He takes a beating because he can't avoid people." Graduated from Niles West in Skokie, Ill., and scored 23 on the Wonderlic. "I think when adversity strikes he may fold tent," another scout said. "I don't see grinder mentality with him. I see analytical." Said a third scout: "I just don't know how he's wired. I don't know how competitive he is. I don't know how much he wants to take the beatin' he's going to take."
4. FELIX JONES, Arkansas (5-10, 210, 4.45, 1-2) - Played behind McFadden for three years, getting 386 carries to McFadden's 785. "If Felix Jones played for West Virginia," said Polian, "you'd be talking about him in the same breath as Mendenhall and Stewart. He only suffers by comparison to the guy he's playing with." Averaged 7.7 yards per carry, second in NCAA history behind Army's Glenn Davis (8.3) from 1943-'46. Averaged 8.7 in '07, gaining 1,162 yards. "There's some similarities to Reggie (Bush)," said Rick Reiprish, New Orleans' director of college scouting. "Reggie is so quick but Jones might be a little faster." Happy-go-lucky personality. Excels on kickoff returns. "You can put him at wideout, the slot, running back," Brocato said. "He's tough. He runs inside. I think he can (carry the load)." Others see him as a change-of-pace back. "A very competitive runner who doesn't like to go down," said Eric DeCosta, Baltimore's director of college scouting. "He fights for yards all the time. If he was there in the second round he'd be excellent value." Wonderlic score of 22.