Jason Witten Shouldn't Play

The Emperor

Marcus Aurelius Maximus
Messages
3,881
Reaction score
2
Even though it's the first game and it's important to have a fast start to the season, it's important to remember that a season is a marathon and not a sprint. The playoffs are a sprint. The regular season is a marathon.

The media, the fans, and the organizations have built this Week 1 matchup into sort of a playoff game. The fact is it's Week 1 of the regular season. There's no playoff positioning on the line. There's still 15 more games to atone for whatever loss we should accrue Wednesday night.

Our Wednesday night encounter with the New York Giants is really nothing more than a glorified urinating contest. When we look back on the 2012 season, it won't define it at all. Other important games will do so, not this Week 1 matchup with the Giants.

Do I want to beat the Giants? Indubitably. But I'm also thinking long term.

We need Jason Witten for more than one game this season, and I would sacrifice his services in this one game for the potential ten we'll need him later on down the road. I pick the number ten because that's what will get us into the playoffs.

Don't send him out there with a lacerated spleen and have him waste his season all because we want to stick it to the Giants in their house and spoil their season opening. Going back to the days of Landry, the Dallas Cowboys aren't about squabbles like that. They're not about Sicilian duels of honor. They're about focusing long term and achieving loftier goals at the end of the road. You can't get there when you're giving into road rage because someone cut you off.

Sit Jason Witten this week. Find another way to win. Don't risk his season over one game that we could easily atone later on in November and December when it counts.
 
Sorry but the NFL regular season is a sprint too..its not 162 like MLB, or the NBA.
 
You make good points, however....

If he is medically cleared to play, he is going to play regardless! That is just his nature.

Would I like to have him sit this game? Yes I would because that gives him what, 10, 11 more days of rest?

Witten is a thoroughbred...one of a kind of player. But, if he is medically cleared and Garrett is comfortable...he plays.
 
People are not giving John Phillips any credit either, Phillips is really good.
 
The Emperor;4701829 said:
Sit Jason Witten this week. Find another way to win. Don't risk his season over one game that we could easily atone later on in November and December when it counts.

Shouldn't the decision be made by doctors based on medical opinion, rather than uninformed fan opinion?
 
I'm thinking that if Witten does play, he could contribute vitally in a game the Cowboys badly need to win.........given that the Cowboys will be playing the comparatively inferior Seahawks and Buccaneers next......and also have an early bye week in the season.
 
Anyone else wondering about the effectiveness of Austin as well?
 
5Stars;4701849 said:
You make good points, however....

If he is medically cleared to play, he is going to play regardless! That is just his nature.

Would I like to have him sit this game? Yes I would because that gives him what, 10, 11 more days of rest?

Witten is a thoroughbred...one of a kind of player. But, if he is medically cleared and Garrett is comfortable...he plays.


Agree, this was in my line of thoughts also.
 
He cannot play unless cleared by medical staff; if they clear him to play, his butt should absolutely be out there playing...and he will.
 
if there is any risk at all that he could undue the healing he should not play

All too often players rush back and re injure themselves
 
fifaguy;4701873 said:
Anyone else wondering about the effectiveness of Austin as well?

Austin will play for awhile until his wet toilet paper hammys give up on him.

:laugh2:


(i read that in some article, so don't come cussing at me)
 
Chuck 54;4701876 said:
He cannot play unless cleared by medical staff; if they clear him to play, his butt should absolutely be out there playing...and he will.

He's a throwback player if I've ever seen one lately...

:starspin
 
burmafrd;4701883 said:
if there is any risk at all that he could undue the healing he should not play

All too often players rush back and re injure themselves

Mr. Obvious...is that you?


:confused:




(stupid cowboy fans)
 
Witten was injured August 14th. You can counts the days since then. I will be surprised to see him play.
 
burmafrd;4701942 said:
if you want to see one look in the mirror

Just got back from the mirror...and I'm one handsome man.

Thanks for the reminder.

;)
 
At the end of the day, it's going to be up to the doctors. This thing is pretty much cut and dry.

If Witten can safely play, the docs will tell him so. If he can't, he'll take a seat and come back in Seattle.
 
Primetime42;4701952 said:
At the end of the day, it's going to be up to the doctors. This thing is pretty much cut and dry.

If Witten can safely play, the docs will tell him so. If he can't, he'll take a seat and come back in Seattle.

The Cowboys can win this game without him...

;)
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,029
Messages
14,507,718
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top