Jaylon Smith's knee injury could prevent him from playing in 2016

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,523
Reaction score
29,868
The team that drafts Jaylon Smith is likely going to have to wait for a return on its investment.

The Notre Dame linebacker, who some believed was a top-five prospect prior to tearing up his knee in January, appears headed for a medical redshirt season in the NFL. NFL Network's Ian Rapoport says that there was very little difference between the condition of Smith's knee at the NFL scouting combine in February to how it looked in an examination on Friday back in Indianapolis for the NFL medical rechecks.

It's likely, then, that 2016 could be spent rehabbing for Smith and not on an NFL field. That's bad news for Smith, who boasted to Shutdown Corner on March 31 that he was leg-pressing 600 pounds and felt great in his rehab.

This almost certainly pushes Smith out of the first round of the draft starting April 28, although history reminds us that Willis McGahee was still the 22nd pick in the draft in 2003 NFL draft despite a devastating knee injury, and he did not play until the following season of 2004 but still had an occasionally brilliant career.

On the other end of the spectrum is Marcus Lattimore. He fell to Round 4 to the San Francisco 49ersand never was able to get back on the field after multiple torn ACLs.

Smith suffered a torn ACL and LCL and might have suffered some nerve damage in the injury that happened in Notre Dame's Fiesta Bowl loss to Ohio State. It is very possible and perhaps likely that Smith is drafted at some point the next day in either Rounds 2 or 3. Perhaps a team that is loaded with picks in that range could opt to take a flier on Smith as a long-term investment.

http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/nfl-s...event-him-from-playing-in-2016-174910152.html
 

tm1119

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,941
Reaction score
8,681
Pretty much a given once I saw the replay of his injury...Just a matter of what % of him comes back if/when he does. Doesn't seem like the nerve damage issue was resolved though? Obviously I'm no doctor so not sure how they go about finding that out or if it was even possible to do so yesterday.
 

skinsscalper

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,146
Reaction score
5,693
I wouldn't touch this kid before the 6th round. Some other team will and they can afford to but I'm not taking a redshirt guy that's on a short deal to begin with.
 

BoysfanfromCanada

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,997
Reaction score
6,474
I wouldn't touch this kid before the 6th round. Some other team will and they can afford to but I'm not taking a redshirt guy that's on a short deal to begin with.

But with McClain here on a one year contract, I feel like he'd be a perfect Rd 4ish pick for us
 

rockj7

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,468
Reaction score
2,197
I wouldn't touch this kid before the 6th round. Some other team will and they can afford to but I'm not taking a redshirt guy that's on a short deal to begin with.

Skin what about our second 4th we can't do any worse then what we have been doing in the 4th in the past. Here is a list of our past 4ths

2009 Victor Butler Stephen McGee Brandon Williams
2010 AOA
2011 David Arkin
2012 Kyle Wilber Matt Johnson
2013 BW Webb
2014 Anthony Hitch
2015 Damieon Wilson
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
I wouldn't touch this kid before the 6th round. Some other team will and they can afford to but I'm not taking a redshirt guy that's on a short deal to begin with.

I'm with you. Missing the whole year changes everything.

I would use one of the late 6ths. Not much there besides risk/reward guys anyway.
 

skinsscalper

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,146
Reaction score
5,693
Skin what about our second 4th we can't do any worse then what we have been doing in the 4th in the past. Here is a list of our past 4ths

2009 Victor Butler Stephen McGee Brandon Williams
2010 AOA
2011 David Arkin
2012 Kyle Wilber Matt Johnson
2013 BW Webb
2014 Anthony Hitch
2015 Damieon Wilson

I won't lie, rock. It is intriguing with our 2nd 4th rounder especially (as you've noted) since we haven't had the best of luck in the 4th lately, anyway. But I've got to be honest man, I don't think this kid is ever going to be even half of what he was before this injury.

I could be way off base and, for his sake, I hope I'm completely wrong but something about this injury, to me, says "never gonna happen". IDK.
 

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,523
Reaction score
29,868
Dr Cooper is the Cowboys team doctor and did the surgery. I am sure his prognosis will be carefully evaluated. If he says anything positive I'd definitely take him in the sixth. Couldnt be any worse than the late round trash we have seen lately.
 

skinsscalper

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,146
Reaction score
5,693
But with McClain here on a one year contract, I feel like he'd be a perfect Rd 4ish pick for us

Honestly, If I'm looking to cover my *** re: McClain, I draft the sure thing in Myles Jack and don't look back (sounds like song lyrics, huh?).

:laugh:
 

BoysfanfromCanada

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,997
Reaction score
6,474
Honestly, If I'm looking to cover my *** re: McClain, I draft the sure thing in Myles Jack and don't look back (sounds like song lyrics, huh?).

:laugh:

"the draft show" guys mentioned that some teams have more confidence in Jaylon Smith's knee than Jack..... I hate this draft!
 

rockj7

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,468
Reaction score
2,197
I won't lie, rock. It is intriguing with our 2nd 4th rounder especially (as you've noted) since we haven't had the best of luck in the 4th lately, anyway. But I've got to be honest man, I don't think this kid is ever going to be even half of what he was before this injury.

I could be way off base and, for his sake, I hope I'm completely wrong but something about this injury, to me, says "never gonna happen". IDK.

You got a point Bro
 

rockj7

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,468
Reaction score
2,197
Dr Cooper is the Cowboys team doctor and did the surgery. I am sure his prognosis will be carefully evaluated. If he says anything positive I'd definitely take him in the sixth. Couldnt be any worse than the late round trash we have seen lately.

RS12 I posted our 4th round whiffs since 2009
 

Rogerthat12

DWAREZ
Messages
14,605
Reaction score
9,989
Dr Cooper is the Cowboys team doctor and did the surgery. I am sure his prognosis will be carefully evaluated. If he says anything positive I'd definitely take him in the sixth. Couldnt be any worse than the late round trash we have seen lately.

Our team certainly has the inside scoop on this situation.
 

conner01

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,960
Reaction score
26,604
I think most teams expected he would miss this year. That's not really the issue, he is or was good enough to redshirt. The real question is about the next year. Will he ever be the same player? Any team that thinks he can be will take him well before the 4th, those that don't think he will be won't. Honestly if I thought there was anything better than a 50/50 chance he can be the same player I would use a 4th on him. It's a gamble but one worth taking a shot st if your docs think it's reasonably possible he can be the same player
 
Top