JJT: Jason Garrett deserves blame for Cowboys' horrendous offense

Dodger12

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,142
Reaction score
3,532
IRVING, Texas -- Jason Garrett, hired by the Dallas Cowboys as an innovative offensive mind and play-caller in 2007, coaches the NFL's most pathetic offense.

The San Francisco 49ers have scored fewer points and the Indianapolis Colts have totaled fewer yards, but neither of those bad offenses had three offensive linemen named to the Pro Bowl, tight end Jason Witten for 16 games and Dez Bryant for 10 games when the playoffs were still a possibility.

No offense in the league has done less with more than Garrett’s group. The numbers that matter most to Garrett are worse than pathetic.
The Cowboys have scored just 252 points, 31st in the NFL, and they rank last in the NFL in red zone touchdown percentage (41.4) and pass plays of 20 yards or more (32).

This is the worst offense since Jerry Jones brought in Garrett as offensive coordinator. Garrett had never been in charge of an offense that had scored fewer than 361 points before this season. The past two seasons, the Cowboys scored 439 and 467 points, respectively.

Sure, Scott Linehan calls the plays, but this is Garrett’s offense and he deserves the credit when it works and the blame when it doesn’t. Linehan isn’t doing anything with the offense or play selection that Garrett doesn’t want.

The obvious answer to the issues -- the easy one -- is that Tony Romo has started and finished just two games, and the Cowboys won both of those.

So what?

If Garrett’s offense can’t function without Romo under center, where he excels at consistently getting the offense into the best possible play, then it’s worthless.

Garrett loves to say the Cowboys’ offense is flexible, able to take advantage of any matchup created by a formation. But it’s a timing-based scheme that is based almost entirely on a receiver or running back winning a one-on-one matchup.

That’s great when Troy Aikman, Michael Irvin, Emmitt Smith and Jay Novacek are the epicenter of the offense. And it’s fine when Romo, Bryant, DeMarco Murray and Witten are the central figures in every game plan.

But we’ve seen what happens when the Cowboys don’t have a significant skill advantage at receiver, running back or quarterback: The offense becomes abject.

We’re talking about a unit that has failed to score more than one touchdown in each of the past seven games.

Kellen Moore is the fourth quarterback the Cowboys have used this season, and despite all of the hype surrounding the 6-foot, 200-pound lefty with a storage unit of intangibles, he has been the worst of the bunch through six quarters.

Optimists see glimmers of potential and hope, while realists see a dude with a pop-gun arm who can’t consistently throw the deep outs, which are fundamental to this offense’s success.

He’s probably good enough to be a solid No. 3 quarterback, but he’s probably not good enough to be the backup on a team on which you have to expect a starter such as Romo to miss a few games per season.

The Cowboys are 1-10 when someone other than Romo starts this season. It’s enough to make you wonder about the fate of the franchise when Romo eventually retires.

It’s not like Brandon Weeden, Matt Cassel or Moore have showed vast improvement under Garrett, Linehan and quarterbacks coach Wade Wilson.

Each regressed, though Weeden managed to end his 11-game losing streak as a starter Sunday, when he led the Houston Texans to win over the hapless Tennessee Titans. Dallas released Weeden in November and Houston picked him up.

For now, Garrett has no concrete answers for why the Cowboys' offense has been so bad. He blames inconsistent execution and the lack of big plays.

When he sits down with Jerry Jones after this wretched season ends, he needs to have a better answer. Jones has spent too much money and too many draft picks on the offense to have the league’s worst unit.

http://espn.go.com/blog/dallas/cowb...deserves-blame-for-cowboys-horrendous-offense
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I'm not a big fan of JJT, but I think that this is a good article with some undeniable, 'inconvenient truth' to it.

This offense is doing these players absolutely no favors, and if the team doesn't have a distinct matchup advantage, they're unable to compete.

I would expect the Joneses to force a change here, whether Garrett likes it or not.
 

Macnalty

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,639
Reaction score
2,162
No argument here with this article, what a waste of a great offensive line, these O lines do not happen often and have a limited shelf life.
 

phildadon86

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,552
Reaction score
32,318
I'm not a big fan of JJT, but I think that this is a good article with some undeniable, 'inconvenient truth' to it.

This offense is doing these players absolutely no favors, and if the team doesn't have a distinct matchup advantage, they're unable to compete.

I would expect the Joneses to force a change here, whether Garrett likes it or not.

What change could they force really? Make him throw out the playbook? Who creates the new one? Linehan? Only thing that would work would be Garrett being shown the door, and we all know that won't happen. What I don't understand is why they don't design plays based on Romo's quick release. He has one of the fastest releases in football but we never see a slant, like ever. I really just don't get it. Get dez into space and throw it too him in stride. I don't get why this is so hard to comprehend. Instead we make romo hold onto the ball far too long, and guess what, he gets hurt. I run better plays in madden. It's sickening
 

Dodger12

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,142
Reaction score
3,532
I'm not a big fan of JJT, but I think that this is a good article with some undeniable, 'inconvenient truth' to it.

This offense is doing these players absolutely no favors, and if the team doesn't have a distinct matchup advantage, they're unable to compete.

I would expect the Joneses to force a change here, whether Garrett likes it or not.

I agree but the bolded part is problematic. It's no secret I'm no fan of Garrett's but he's the HC and Jones should not be forcing the changes. The HC should be the one who controls his staff and makes changes accordingly. Garrett should make those changes because, ultimately, it's his job on the line even though the previous HC didn't have that same option....you have to marvel at the irony.
 

VThokie7

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,065
Reaction score
506
Nailed it. Our offensive system is so archaic. There is no innovation or even simple things like motioning Dez to create mismatches. Just line up and execute. Dez could be so much better if he was used like the weapon he is.

People will bring up last seasons production but I'm sure forget that prior to finding the ground game our offense despite the numbers went flat a few times a season. It's far too predictable
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,664
Reaction score
86,205
That’s great when Troy Aikman, Michael Irvin, Emmitt Smith and Jay Novacek are the epicenter of the offense. And it’s fine when Romo, Bryant, DeMarco Murray and Witten are the central figures in every game plan.

No it works when Romo is there.

The rest could be there and it will not work consistently and even with Romo i'm not sold on it ever working consistently against the leagues best teams for 3 or 4 weeks.


You don't walk into the playoffs and just think you're going to out athlete teams.
 

robjay04

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,240
Reaction score
14,068
I saw Denver run a play that just made me shake my head last night. It was a simple WR screen to Demaryius Thomas with a tackle that pulled out to lead the way. We have one of the most athletic left tackles in the game and a receiver who is considered one of the most physical after the catch in the league but maybe I am wrong...but I very rarely see a play like that. Maybe a basic screen but nothing remotely creative.
 

FiveTime

Well-Known Member
Messages
687
Reaction score
662
I saw Denver run a play that just made me shake my head last night. It was a simple WR screen to Demaryius Thomas with a tackle that pulled out to lead the way. We have one of the most athletic left tackles in the game and a receiver who is considered one of the most physical after the catch in the league but maybe I am wrong...but I very rarely see a play like that. Maybe a basic screen but nothing remotely creative.

Didn't Dez score on a similar play against the Jets?
 

Dodger12

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,142
Reaction score
3,532
No whining here. Just an observation.

You made a post earlier that you hope something gets done about the offensive play calling which is basically the same thing JJT and others are pointing out in terms of flaws in the system. You see the flaws too or you wouldn't want something to be done about the play calling. What would you suggest?
 
Top