Joe Brady out Panthers OC

[RonWashington]

Yep sitting at 5-7 with Sam Darnold and Cam as alleged QB’s he’s stuck with along with McCaffery hurt all yr it’s Joe Brady’s fault ?

 

[joseephuss]

He probably isn't the only issue. He had it very easy in his previous job. LSU was absolutely loaded with talent and experience when he was their OC. The Panthers are average in talent right now. I doubt they see an increase in production the rest of the season, but I didn't think Brady was some wonderkind, either.

 

[RonWashington]

He probably isn't the only issue. He had it very easy in his previous job. LSU was absolutely loaded with talent and experience when he was their OC. The Panthers are average in talent right now. I doubt they see an increase in production the rest of the season, but I didn't think Brady was some wonderkind, either.

I can agree to an extent but your not going to the playoffs five games left you throw him overboard ?
It’s like the Garret firing , the Giants managed 9 points against Miami . Glennon or Jones things look the same.

 

[joseephuss]

I can agree to an extent but your not going to the playoffs five games left you throw him overboard ?
It’s like the Garret firing , the Giants managed 9 points against Miami . Glennon of Jones things look the same.

Maybe a case of Rhule just looking to keep his job. Blame the oc. Plus we don't know how daily discussions go. There could be differences in offensive philosophy between the two.

 

[RonWashington]

Maybe a case of Rhule just looking to keep his job. Blame the oc. Plus we don't know how daily discussions go. There could be differences in offensive philosophy between the two.

Your right they must have decided this isn’t working out why wait. I think Brady was mentioned in HC positions in the NFL , believe the Jets were poking around. Before they hired Salah

 

[khiladi]

I can agree to an extent but your not going to the playoffs five games left you throw him overboard ?
It’s like the Garret firing , the Giants managed 9 points against Miami . Glennon or Jones things look the same.

Why not? When you fire an OC that is this bad, you aren’t expecting to go to the play-offs. You are getting rid of dead weight.

Joe Brady is 32 years old and has ZERO NFL coaching experience outside, his two years as OC of the Panthers.

 

[khiladi]

He probably isn't the only issue. He had it very easy in his previous job. LSU was absolutely loaded with talent and experience when he was their OC. The Panthers are average in talent right now. I doubt they see an increase in production the rest of the season, but I didn't think Brady was some wonderkind, either.

He wasn’t an OC in LSU, Steve Ensminger, a coach with multiple years of experience, was. Joe was the passing game coordinator and WR coach, and that for 1 year. He probably got the job based on affiliation to the Burrow-led team. Apparently, Brady got interest for HC jobs after his first year with the Panthers which says a lot about the NFL franchises these days, just looking to make a splash with a young face as HC. How can you become a HC with only one real year coaching in the NFL and the numbers and body of work don’t even support the hire?

The guy replacing Brady was the OC and play-caller for Rhule at Baylor and is a Senior Offensive Assistant with the Panthers.

 

[RonWashington]

He wasn’t an OC in LSU, Steve Ensminger, a coach with multiple years of experience, was. Joe was the passing game coordinator and WR coach, and that for 1 year. He probably got the job based on affiliation to the Burrow-led team.

The guy replacing Brady was the OC and play-caller for Rhule at Baylor and is a Senior Offensive Assistant with the Panthers.

Well with Cam Newton & Sam Darnold at QB with your franchise running back out most of the season good luck thinking sacking Brady with 5 games left is the answer

 

[khiladi]

Well with Cam Newton & Sam Darnold at QB with your franchise running back out most of the season good luck thinking sacking Brady with 5 games left is the answer

They sacked Brady because they realized he was NOT the answer. If Jerry had done the same thing with Garrett, maybe we would have gotten our SB with Romo, instead of wasted a decade trying to find a place for him. The Giants took about a year and a half.

And a young QB like Sam Darnold also gets the excuse that his franchise RB was out, before Sam was put on injured reserve for his shoulder injury. And Sam has ONE year left on his contract, meaning they most likely are looking next year to see if he is the one, but they need a real offensive HC to determine it.

 

[RonWashington]

How many yrs and excuses does Darnold get ? Firing the OC is a bandaid on a roster issue . It’s called lack of talent on that side of the ball .

 

[joseephuss]

Why not? When you fire an OC that is this bad, you aren’t expecting to go to the play-offs. You are getting rid of dead weight.

Joe Brady is 32 years old and has ZERO NFL coaching experience outside, his two years as OC of the Panthers.

He was an offensive assistant(some low level position) with the Saints for 2 seasons, but I agree, he has very little NFL experience.

 

[RonWashington]

Look at the Giants . You can change OC every 10 mins but if you don’t have the manpower to get in the endzone your stuck . One TD in 2 games with Freddie Kitchens in Giants land ….

sure Kellen does a good job for the most part but he’s got one of the best set of receivers in the NFL , Dak plus an emerging Pollard . And I can assure you Barkley in the backfield is not blocking for Daniel Jones or whatever spare they trot out there the way # 21 protects Dak