John Michael Smitz Has HOF Potential

Pass2Run

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,870
Reaction score
12,221
Everyone talks about Mayer being such a solid pick, and I agree, he's a pretty solid pick. But I think the player with even less risk is John Michael Smitz. He would upgrade the position and you'd have a moster of a center and you start off your draft with a bang. Could easily be the best player on the board at 26, so why not just take BPA even though we have Biadz,.

Smitz definitely has position flex, and could totally play guard. And I think he's an OL that could play any position on the line really. He's one of the most technically sound players I've seen as far as offensive line goes. I think quite a bit ahead of Avila, for me at least.

You have the Eagles interior to deal with and San Fran, etcetera, a center who can also play guard makes sense.
 
Last edited:

AsthmaField

Outta bounds
Messages
26,489
Reaction score
44,544
You don’t have to sell me on Schmitz. He is my favorite interior OL in this draft. If that is the way Dallas wants to go at 26, I’d rather it be him than Avila or Torrence. He reminds me of Frederick with his size at center.

However, I don’t anticipate the team going in this direction. They may like Biadasz more than the fan base thinks, too. I’m not sure they even want to replace him. They could play Schmitz at G for a year and then let Biadasz walk in 2024, but like I said… they might not want that.

So yeah, I really like the player but I see that as a little bit of a longshot. IMO they’re looking more at TE, RB, Edge early because those are where the BPA will likely be.

Less than a week… I’m ready to find out.
 

fivetwos

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,122
Reaction score
29,271
You don’t have to sell me on Schmitz. He is my favorite interior OL in this draft. If that is the way Dallas wants to go at 26, I’d rather it be him than Avila or Torrence. He reminds me of Frederick with his size at center.

However, I don’t anticipate the team going in this direction. They may like Biadasz more than the fan base thinks, too. I’m not sure they even want to replace him. They could play Schmitz at G for a year and then let Biadasz walk in 2024, but like I said… they might not want that.

So yeah, I really like the player but I see that as a little bit of a longshot. IMO they’re looking more at TE, RB, Edge early because those are where the BPA will likely be.

Less than a week… I’m ready to find out.
Biadasz has been solid, not spectacular. A little up and down but mostly good enough.

He was following a very tough act, and that has be considered, but I’m not sure he is someone I’d want to give a big second contract to.

Using a first on a guy that could play LG this year then move to center sounds like a better idea than a TE. If one of the tackles falls, have to go that way, but if not there’s some safe picks there at 26 if moving backward isn’t an option.

Also Tyron and Martin are getting closer to retirement. Not a bad move to be ahead of that.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,216
Reaction score
64,730
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Everyone talks about Mayer being such a solid pick, and I agree, he's a pretty solid pick. But I think the player with even less risk is John Michael Smitz. He would upgrade the position and you'd have a moster of a center and you start off your draft with a bang. Could easily be the best player on the board at 26, so why not just take BPA even though we have Biadz,.

Smitz definitely has position flex, and could totally play guard. And I think he's an OL that could play any position on the line really. He's one of the most technically sound players I've seen as far as offensive line goes. I think quite a bit ahead of Avila, for me at least.

You have the Eagles interior to deal with and San Fran, etcetera, a center who can also play guard makes sense.
This is not April 1st...
 

locked&loaded

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,609
Reaction score
960
From mcginn article
CENTERS
1. JOHN MICHAEL SCHMITZ, Minnesota (6-3 ½, 303, 5.31, 2): Sixth-year senior. “I have him ahead of Tippmann,” one scout said. “He’s my best center. Has a wrestling background. Very tough. Big and physical. He reminded me some of that kid that came out of Wisconsin, Travis Frederick. Has some athletic limitations but I think he can fit in both a gap and a zone scheme. He’s a good enough athlete. He’s played a lot of football. He’s a plug-and-play, Day 1 starter.” After redshirting in 2017, seldom getting on the field in ’18 and starting four games in ’19, he started all 31 games at center from 2020-’22. “Plays on his feet, works to finish, solid in the run game and pass pro,” a second scout said. “It wouldn’t surprise me if he starts right away. He has guard flex potentially, which is a big thing.” Wonderlic of 22. “More fun to watch than he is talented,” a third scout said. “We have him later in the draft. Center only. He’s stiff and bends at the waist. Balance and body control are an issue. He’s on the ground too much. Now, he is a prick. He’ll try to kill you on every play. But plays out of control.” Arms were 32 5/8, hands were 9 ½. “Heart and hustle,” said a fourth scout. “Gets in the way but nothing overly athletic about him. Just a smart, tough, heady player. He’ll start.” From Flossmoor, Ill.
 

jnday

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,292
Reaction score
11,422
Everyone talks about Mayer being such a solid pick, and I agree, he's a pretty solid pick. But I think the player with even less risk is John Michael Smitz. He would upgrade the position and you'd have a moster of a center and you start off your draft with a bang. Could easily be the best player on the board at 26, so why not just take BPA even though we have Biadz,.

Smitz definitely has position flex, and could totally play guard. And I think he's an OL that could play any position on the line really. He's one of the most technically sound players I've seen as far as offensive line goes. I think quite a bit ahead of Avila, for me at least.

You have the Eagles interior to deal with and San Fran, etcetera, a center who can also play guard makes sense.
The offensive line can immediately see a huge upgrade with a great center. Frederick was proof of that. When he took over, the offensive line was average at best. After a handful games, the offensive line was very good. If there is a center prospect that is similar to Frederick, you draft him if he is available.
 

CalPolyTechnique

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,716
Reaction score
44,662
You don’t have to sell me on Schmitz. He is my favorite interior OL in this draft. If that is the way Dallas wants to go at 26, I’d rather it be him than Avila or Torrence. He reminds me of Frederick with his size at center.

However, I don’t anticipate the team going in this direction. They may like Biadasz more than the fan base thinks, too. I’m not sure they even want to replace him. They could play Schmitz at G for a year and then let Biadasz walk in 2024, but like I said… they might not want that.

So yeah, I really like the player but I see that as a little bit of a longshot. IMO they’re looking more at TE, RB, Edge early because those are where the BPA will likely be.

Less than a week… I’m ready to find out.
100%

Dude is a technician. I wouldn’t blink twice replacing Biadasz whom I think is a mid-level talent.
 

Pass2Run

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,870
Reaction score
12,221

The offensive line can immediately see a huge upgrade with a great center. Frederick was proof of that. When he took over, the offensive line was average at best. After a handful games, the offensive line was very good. If there is a center prospect that is similar to Frederick, you draft him if he is available.
Smitz would really complete the line.

Not sure why some think it's funny or a joke, he's about as good as it gets for interior linemen.

I think he's in play.. Very safe pick and he's ready right now IMO.
 

Rockport

AmberBeer
Messages
46,580
Reaction score
46,004
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Everyone talks about Mayer being such a solid pick, and I agree, he's a pretty solid pick. But I think the player with even less risk is John Michael Smitz. He would upgrade the position and you'd have a moster of a center and you start off your draft with a bang. Could easily be the best player on the board at 26, so why not just take BPA even though we have Biadz,.

Smitz definitely has position flex, and could totally play guard. And I think he's an OL that could play any position on the line really. He's one of the most technically sound players I've seen as far as offensive line goes. I think quite a bit ahead of Avila, for me at least.

You have the Eagles interior to deal with and San Fran, etcetera, a center who can also play guard makes sense.
Build the trenches. I like it.
 

Pass2Run

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,870
Reaction score
12,221
You don’t have to sell me on Schmitz. He is my favorite interior OL in this draft. If that is the way Dallas wants to go at 26, I’d rather it be him than Avila or Torrence. He reminds me of Frederick with his size at center.

However, I don’t anticipate the team going in this direction. They may like Biadasz more than the fan base thinks, too. I’m not sure they even want to replace him. They could play Schmitz at G for a year and then let Biadasz walk in 2024, but like I said… they might not want that.

So yeah, I really like the player but I see that as a little bit of a longshot. IMO they’re looking more at TE, RB, Edge early because those are where the BPA will likely be.

Less than a week… I’m ready to find out.
Also, the more I think about it, the more this guy gives you position flex, who can play either guard position. He also plays center.

That way, we can always draft another tackle or guard down the road. Or just pick whomever the best linemen are. Because guys like Tyler and Smitz can play several positions.

In my mind, after Smitz, the talent drops off quite a bit. If you want a player who can start, right now, or at the very least be your swing guard, back up center next year. This guy makes life easy as far as O-line.

Also, we'll see what McCarthy thinks of this player, ind iIf the team is doing what he wants, that is, to protect Dak. Or if the team is still Jerry's toy..

I feel like a guy like Mayer would be good. But he doesn't really give you a whole lot that you can't teach Fergushot to do. I particularly like Hendershot, but I also like what Ferguson brings. If he settles in, I can see him being very consistent.

To me, Smitz is the guy like Tyler Smith was last year. The things you don't like far outweigh the aspects he brings, and he'll fit in day one as one of the better players on the line, much like a Zack Martin pick.. HOF player.. that underwhelmed people. But he's consistent just like Martin.

Sleep on Smitz all you want. Laugh and insinuate April Fool's jokes if you want, because you think you have the safe pick, or knee-jerk react because the talking heads are telling you what to think, so I see a lot of players like Smitz, Jaren Hall, maybe Kancey.. those guys are going to be better players than the pundits think, imo.

Just remember, this class of players is coming in to take the jobs of previous classes, so these guys are the future, and I'd say more than 50 percent chance that Smitz ends up a Pro Bowl player, no matter who drafts him, but particularly if he goes to a zone blocking team.

We'll see what McCarthy and Shotty have in mind. The pick should be up to them, since this year is on them to put their money where their mouth is. Let McCarthy, Shotty, and McClay decide that pick.
 
Last edited:

cowboys5xsbs

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,282
Reaction score
20,799
I wouldn't be opposed to drafting him and playing him at guard and moving him to center when Biadisz is gone
 

Pass2Run

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,870
Reaction score
12,221
The middle of our line is soft.

You fix that first, if you aren't going to bring your receiver room up-to-speed.
 

Pass2Run

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,870
Reaction score
12,221
To put it into perspective, last year, it was Jelani Woods, who everyone wanted, because he was so athletic, had 25 receptions for 312 yards and 3 TDS.
Jake Ferguson had 17 receptions for 174 yards and 2 TDS, and he was our 2nd/3rdish TE. Hendershot had 11 receptions for 103 yards and 2 TDs, sharing reps with Schultz and Ferguson.

Say what you want about stats, Ferguson has a catch percentage of 86.4 to Woods 62.5. So, I see Ferguson, who was always a consistent player, somewhat on par with what Mayer can do in the passing game, although I agree he's not as good of a blocker. Mayer was more of the focus of his team in college, but you could have done that with Ferguson as well, imo. And Hendershot was a focal point for a really crappy QB where he played, same for his teammate, that WR from last year who went home with a hammy pull during camp. But Hendershot was a baller on that team.

Anyway, of all the TEs from last year, Ferguson did more with fewer reps in the passing game. He's deceptive after the catch.
 

Pass2Run

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,870
Reaction score
12,221
You don't have to play Biadasz at Center, if you like him so much. I've always thought he was also more of a guard converted to center.

Smitz would also make a great guard, imo. And while he may not be overly athletic from an RAS standpoint, that does not worry me. As CalPoly said, the guy is a technician, and has a brain for the game. He's been doing this a long while, and it reflects in his game, which I think bodes for a high percentage success rate, if he puts in the work. He can do it what he has now, but will only get better year 2, 3, 4 and so on.

Look at why Dallas has been successful at drafting. It's because they go safe picks at offensive line. You have to at least consider Smitz in the first, no matter what position, guard or center. It's nice to have a guy who can play both and not miss a beat as a team. Gives you flex to bring extra players...since he can do two things.

Think about why they've done well: it's because they take their offensive line seriously. You have to with a QB like Dak. I'm not trying to start a Dak thread, just saying, it starts at the line. Take it seriously in this draft, too; it has served you well in recent years.
 
Last edited:
Top