Would love to know what Brads srengths are. If you're going to tell me error free football don't waste your breath. A few INT's were in the making last week, he was very lucky most corners don't have WR hands in this league.
He has sound knowledge of the offense? Definitely useful as long as your arm can utilize the playbook at least up to 20 yards down the field.
Please do not tell me accuracy, please do not. Leadership and huddle managment/presence I'll give Brad as strengths because of his experience and past results but other than that he is not even a 1 dimensional QB who is as much as a liabilty if more than not.
Brooks should be bagging groceries as well but at least we can see a 20 yard pass that sometimes hits the WR in stride. At least there is some mobility. There is absolutely no huddle presence, barely game management past 1 game and definitely not much leadership but we need to give ourselves a chance at 21 points. I doubt Brooks can find us 21 himself but I think he poses a better chance than Brad at this point.
Will Brooks screw up field position and let the Giants score defensively? You have to coach the importance up this week. If you are looking to have Johnson available in the red zone so that we can get at least 3 points or set up a nice jump ballfor RW or T.O to go up and get then I can see this QB switch up worth while. Otherwise I want Brooks in, even though he stinks also. T.O and RW have to be considered in this game by the defense because MBIII is going to be their main focus and rightfully so.