Jones needs to use a 1 for a QB

Established1971

fiveandcounting
Messages
5,774
Reaction score
4,305
I wanted to analyze the Cowboys history of quarterbacks a little. This was not an exhausted search so I could be missing something or have a detail wrong. But here is what I wrangled up

Pre Jerry Jones we basically had 5 main starters
Eddie LeBaron rcvd in trade for 1st and 6th round picks
Don Meredith rcvd rights for a 3rd round pick
Craig Morton 5th overall pick in draft
Roger Staubach 10th round pick after winning Heisman due to 4 year commitment to the Navy
Danny White 3rd round pick who went to competing league first

We got lucky with Danny White, although he did prove to be in the Romo/Prescott mode of never getting to a SB despite big numbers over many seasons.

Since Jerry Jones there have basically been 4 eras Aikman, Romo, Prescott and 5 years where we tried many different qb's
Troy Aikman 1st pick in draft
Tony Romo undrafted free agent
Dak Prescott 4th round pick

QB's which started 2001-2005 - Carter, Bledsoe, Hutchinson, Testaverde, Henson (had 1)

Also Kitna, Cassell and Rush had to start numerous games due to injuries

And we also had brief QB controversy type starters from 84 to 91 - Pueller, Hogeboom, Walsh
Pueller and Hogeboom were pre Jones.

Ocassional spot starts for injury- Peete, Kosar, Longely, Garrett, others

The Cowboys seem to have a history of acquiring QB's who seem to have more upside than the method of acquisition would suggest. They got Meredith in a strange way (just have to wiki to read more on that). We all know Staubach we a gem and not a 10th round talent. White was an odd case because they wanted him to punt and back up Staubach but he went to the WFL.

Then we have the Jones era. Aikman just fell in Jones lap. He bought the team in 1989 and they went 1-15 and got the first pick. But picking Aikman was not enough. Jones had to also take Steve Walsh in that weird supplemental draft that only lasted a short time and start Aikman off with a qb controversy.

He got lucky with Romo and Prescott, though thats debatable since they both suck in the post season like White. Interestingly he kept the habit of trying to find gems on the cheap. Drew Henson was great talent who chose baseball then changed his mind and with a little luck could have been the QB had Romo not come out of nowhere. Chad Hutchinson was someone who before we saw him play had some upside if he was successful in the World League. He got his chance and sucked. Now we trade for Trey Lance for a 4th out of nowhere.

Jones has had an obsession with WR during his ownership drafted so many high and signing so many big names, but qb he seems to think getting on the cheap is enough. My opinion, 81 years old or not, Jones needs to stop looking for steals and just draft a damn qb. He has had the team 35 years now and, like I said, Aikman was a no brainer and Jones wasnt even content at the time. This draft has 6 first round talents at QB. Take one.
 

Ranching

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,664
Reaction score
110,895
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
1st round pick doesn't guarantee anything, I could name many busts from the first round. We need ILBs, OL, DTs...etc.
Imagine if Bill had taken a QB in the first and not pick up Brady in the 6th. It's all a crap shoot.
 

yentl911

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,469
Reaction score
1,401
We have so many holes to fill I doubt we go with a QB in the first round. I would really like to see Lance get a shot in here - if he's not the guy we think he is then punt on him.

We need LB's, OL, RB, etc.
 

G2

Taco Engineer
Messages
24,846
Reaction score
26,452
Anyone remotely confident we find a better QB?
 

starfan1

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,249
Reaction score
12,337
I didnt read all that but who would you pick? I think Pennix jr and Bo Nix will be there when we pick but I am not real enamoured with Nix. Id take pennix though. I believe our biggest need is LB a downhill playing beast. If you change the QB and dont fix the rest of the problem (and the defense has been the issue for years) then you are still going to be pissing and moaning about the results
 

G2

Taco Engineer
Messages
24,846
Reaction score
26,452
We have so many holes to fill I doubt we go with a QB in the first round. I would really like to see Lance get a shot in here - if he's not the guy we think he is then punt on him.

We need LB's, OL, RB, etc.
This could have been addressed in the off season, but nope.
 

mardwin

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,155
Reaction score
10,246
We have so many holes to fill I doubt we go with a QB in the first round. I would really like to see Lance get a shot in here - if he's not the guy we think he is then punt on him.

We need LB's, OL, RB, etc.
The next hole will be at QB.
 

MikeT22

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,350
Reaction score
4,311
1st round pick doesn't guarantee anything, I could name many busts from the first round. We need ILBs, OL, DTs...etc.
Imagine if Bill had taken a QB in the first and not pick up Brady in the 6th. It's all a crap shoot.
Forget the percentages and let’s hang onto the one or two outliers trying to find a QB on day 3. Brilliant man
 

fivetwos

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,562
Reaction score
28,354
Jones didn’t know who Steve Walsh was, let alone make the call on drafting him in the supplemental draft. He probably didn’t even know what the supplemental draft was at the time.

He still knows nothing and neither does the kid, which is why they won’t pay for other peoples players….they have no ability to scout them, and fall in love with their own draftees, who end up infected by the toxic culture before long.

It over. It’s broken. It’s not fixable.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,120
Reaction score
76,049
Forget the percentages and let’s hang onto the one or two outliers trying to find a QB on day 3. Brilliant man
You look at the last quarterbacks who have won the past 13 years? Eli, Mahomes, Nick Foles, Stafford, Flacco, Peyton…talking outliers lol…
 

Cmac

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,972
Reaction score
8,652
So now JJ McCarthy of Michigan is coming. He may be available around that time. Mel Kiper help our board.......please.
 
Top