Kaiser Rolls out notes on Commander game

Kaiser

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,628
Reaction score
28,430
The team has publicly said Kris Richard is the Defensive Coordinator in all but the title, from the first two games it really seems like the defense has fully transitioned to Richard’s scheme. It’s not the all-out Marinelli rushmen attack, they are rushing 4 DL to get good but not great pressure. Then the CBs take away short routes and Jaylon & LVE cover miles of ground to make tackles.

As much as I love Richard as a person, is that the right strategy? With our offense scoring at will, it really seems like a contain strategy is better than a gambling style that makes plays but gives them up as well.

In all the “Dak Sucks” threads I said most of the problems were on the OL. You see now what this team does with a healthy OL. They are scoring at will and completely controlled both games, I put the improvement over last year 50% on the OL, 30% on Kellen Moore and 20% on improvements Dak has made (with Kitna). Your mileage may vary.

One of the biggest mistakes of last season (in terms of making me read bad threads) was holding all the starters out of preseason and then falling flat against the Panthers in the opener. They did it to avoid injuries but the Panthers game was a trainwreck, so we should have played the starters this offseason, right? Or Garrett’s an idiot, right?

Right?

Wrong, they knew they would pancake two of the first three opponents. These three opening games basically are our preseason so it was actually smart to hold the starters out of the actual preseason.

Jaylon Smith and LVE are playing well but haven’t had any dominant performances. But they are playing well enough that Sean Lee has 3 tackles in 2 games and fans (myself included) don’t give a rats hiney about it.

Xavier Woods is clearly improved but he hasn’t shown the level of play the coaches were saying – at least not yet. In Bob Sturm’s metric of Splash Plays Jeff Health is tied for 2nd (with LVE) with 4.5 (DLaw has 6.5). Both guys are playing good, not great. But we gave up a 5th round pick and low salaries for the two of them, it completely justifies the Dallas strategy if not overpaying in draft picks or FA dollars for a safety.

And finally, I’m sure someone posted this already but he’s a Fish Taco now.
 
Good read but I wouldn't say Jaylon is playing "well". He certainly doesn't seem like his usual, dominant self (and Sturm has agreed as much). Hopefully Miami is just what the doctor ordered for him.
 
Is our style of defense under Richard really a gambling style of defense?

We seem to be willing to give up a lot of short stuff such as easy throws over the middle and I to the flats in order to keep from getting beat deep. Our LBs are often immediately dropping into fairly deep zones to prevent plays behind them.
 
Good read but I wouldn't say Jaylon is playing "well". He certainly doesn't seem like his usual, dominant self (and Sturm has agreed as much). Hopefully Miami is just what the doctor ordered for him.

I agree. Smith is tied for most tackles so far with 17 but he's been merely average. I think the big plays are coming, though. Two games is a very small sample size.
 
Is our style of defense under Richard really a gambling style of defense?

We seem to be willing to give up a lot of short stuff such as easy throws over the middle and I to the flats in order to keep from getting beat deep. Our LBs are often immediately dropping into fairly deep zones to prevent plays behind them.
I do not see it as a gambling style, no.
 
We are going to face tough defenses and we will see if we can score at will then. Will let us know a lot.
 
we havent had to gamble, Quin was gone and our first 3 games were and extension of pS IMO..

So when the pressure is put on us playing in game when in the second half we are down 10 etc, im sure they wil release the dogs to create a play or Tos etc..
 
The team has publicly said Kris Richard is the Defensive Coordinator in all but the title, from the first two games it really seems like the defense has fully transitioned to Richard’s scheme. It’s not the all-out Marinelli rushmen attack, they are rushing 4 DL to get good but not great pressure. Then the CBs take away short routes and Jaylon & LVE cover miles of ground to make tackles.

As much as I love Richard as a person, is that the right strategy? With our offense scoring at will, it really seems like a contain strategy is better than a gambling style that makes plays but gives them up as well.

In all the “Dak Sucks” threads I said most of the problems were on the OL. You see now what this team does with a healthy OL. They are scoring at will and completely controlled both games, I put the improvement over last year 50% on the OL, 30% on Kellen Moore and 20% on improvements Dak has made (with Kitna). Your mileage may vary.

One of the biggest mistakes of last season (in terms of making me read bad threads) was holding all the starters out of preseason and then falling flat against the Panthers in the opener. They did it to avoid injuries but the Panthers game was a trainwreck, so we should have played the starters this offseason, right? Or Garrett’s an idiot, right?

Right?

Wrong, they knew they would pancake two of the first three opponents. These three opening games basically are our preseason so it was actually smart to hold the starters out of the actual preseason.

Jaylon Smith and LVE are playing well but haven’t had any dominant performances. But they are playing well enough that Sean Lee has 3 tackles in 2 games and fans (myself included) don’t give a rats hiney about it.

Xavier Woods is clearly improved but he hasn’t shown the level of play the coaches were saying – at least not yet. In Bob Sturm’s metric of Splash Plays Jeff Health is tied for 2nd (with LVE) with 4.5 (DLaw has 6.5). Both guys are playing good, not great. But we gave up a 5th round pick and low salaries for the two of them, it completely justifies the Dallas strategy if not overpaying in draft picks or FA dollars for a safety.

And finally, I’m sure someone posted this already but he’s a Fish Taco now.
Have to agree with you about 400% I'm holding people out of preseason last year then completely flopping in the Panthers game and kudos for the offensive line, that makes a big difference I think Frederick it's the big Difference Maker there health close second
 
I do not see it as a gambling style, no.

You can substitute the word "aggressive" for gambling. Marinelli has traditionally blitzed a lot more than we have seen in these two games. That produces more positive plays but more negative plays as well.

Richard seems to be applying some pressure but focusing on taking away the short game, so if the coverage is there the DL has time to get to the QB - or at least force them to throw the ball away. It seems like they are taking away most first options and getting to the QB before they get to their third read.
 
Also to watch in this game: we'll get our first look at Hil

And Donovan Wilson and Joe Jackson, both guys will probably play the entire second half. Plus a big heapin' helping of Dorance Armstrong.
 
You can substitute the word "aggressive" for gambling. Marinelli has traditionally blitzed a lot more than we have seen in these two games. That produces more positive plays but more negative plays as well.

Richard seems to be applying some pressure but focusing on taking away the short game, so if the coverage is there the DL has time to get to the QB - or at least force them to throw the ball away. It seems like they are taking away most first options and getting to the QB before they get to their third read.
Yeah and like blue blood 70 mentioned, there wasn’t really a need to have a gambling style in the first two weeks of the season. The team got up pretty big and they just let the Giants and Skins chew up the clock. In those situations, the last thing you want to do is give up the big play.

I imagine that will change with more challenging opponents.
 
Ill take the kind of defense weve shown the past two games IF we can haul in interceptions and recover fumbles

The defense isnt bad not as good as last seasons but

they gave up 10 against the giants and another 7 in garbage time

14 against the skins and another 7 when they game was already on ice
 
You can substitute the word "aggressive" for gambling. Marinelli has traditionally blitzed a lot more than we have seen in these two games. That produces more positive plays but more negative plays as well.

Richard seems to be applying some pressure but focusing on taking away the short game, so if the coverage is there the DL has time to get to the QB - or at least force them to throw the ball away. It seems like they are taking away most first options and getting to the QB before they get to their third read.

What constitutes “short game”?

Because we seemingly have given up a lot of easy passes in the flats and over the middle for 5-6-7 yard gains.

And it appears that happens because our backers and secondary seem to be playing deeper.

Marinelli’s blitz percentage was also almost always in the bottom third of the league, if I recall.
 
Our defense has been fairly vanilla, but we have been controlling games, so it leads to a more conservative game plan. We aren’t blitzing at all, but in contrast the Giants blitzed a bunch and got torched! I think the takeaways will come and our DL will find a rhythm. Giants and Washington also seemed to want to get the ball out fast.
 
Good read but I wouldn't say Jaylon is playing "well". He certainly doesn't seem like his usual, dominant self (and Sturm has agreed as much). Hopefully Miami is just what the doctor ordered for him.
To my untrained eye he seems to be freelancing a bit. That or he is making poor reads. I expect he will get back to last years play level soon.
 
You can substitute the word "aggressive" for gambling. Marinelli has traditionally blitzed a lot more than we have seen in these two games. That produces more positive plays but more negative plays as well.

Richard seems to be applying some pressure but focusing on taking away the short game, so if the coverage is there the DL has time to get to the QB - or at least force them to throw the ball away. It seems like they are taking away most first options and getting to the QB before they get to their third read.

That strategy won’t work on Rogers or Brady
 
Good read but I wouldn't say Jaylon is playing "well". He certainly doesn't seem like his usual, dominant self (and Sturm has agreed as much). Hopefully Miami is just what the doctor ordered for him.
His running after the ball carrier was abit off , either he is having injury issues or confidence issues , his sideline to sideline play from last year is not seen yet
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,658
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top