I'm not talking exclusively about Poe in reference to go get the best guys available, just that there are DL available that we shouldn't turn our noses up at because of some "rush men" philosophy that has been 4 years in the making and hasn't materialized. And believe me I'm not far off from that last sentence in your post.
I don't blame Marinelli because he is handcuffed by our free agent philosophy and our poor history of drafting good defensive lineman. We bargain shop when it comes to free agency so your chances of getting a great defensive lineman are close to zero. In the last 5 drafts we have taken 8 defensive lineman. Tyrone Crawford = OK, but severely overpaid. Getting starter money when he is probably a backup, Ken Bishop = trash, Ben Gardner = trash, Demarcus Lawrence = OK, if he could stay healthy and off the suspension list, Ryan Russell = trash, Charles Tapper = Incomplete due to injury rookie year, Randy Gregory = Trash, suspension machine, Maliek Collins = OK, trending toward good
8 DLine drafted with 4 = trash, 1 = incomplete, 2 = OK, and 1 = OK, trending toward good. Then we sign low costs development players in free agency hoping we know something more than the other teams and hoping we can coach them up. It is the same philosophy we once used with the OLine.
Remember, prior to the 2011 draft, when we drafted and acquired our OLine like we now do with our DLine? Here are our OLine draftees from 2005 - 2010:
Rob Petitti
Pat McQuistan
James Marten
Doug Free
Robert Brewster
Sam Young
Doug Free was actually the ringer out of that group. lol