Latest Head Coach Rankings. Mike McCarthy 19

[TwistedL0g1k]

Here's the recent ranking of head coaches by CBS:

CBS Head Coach Ranking

How do you view McCarthy's ranking?

 

[CowboyFrog]

MM 19th SeanP greatness....Make it make sense....

 

[TwistedL0g1k]

From article re: MM

"It takes more than just an elite QB to oversee 10 different double-digit winning seasons across two teams, so McCarthy deserves more credit than he gets. What keeps him from the upper echelon here is the recent crunch-time resume: an old-school play-caller with a conservative bent, he hasn't guided any of his elite rosters to an NFC title game appearance since 2016."

 

[PA Cowboy Fan]

He should be in the top 10 or close to it.

 

[jazzcat22]

Another useless biased list. So many coaches too high or too low.
However they need to write crap to earn their paycheck.

 

[75boyz]

Sounds about right.
Criminal that he could only coach up one SB out of the best generational pure passer of the modern football era. Criminal coaching underachievement.
That QB did his part.
He then lucked into a win now team in which the DC is responsible for the lion's share of recent success and fired the OC whom he will soon learn first hand that it wasn't the plays called but the person executing the plays was at fault.

It's put up or shut up time now as it's all his hand picked staff and playcalling.

Time to sink or swim McCheese.

 

[TwistedL0g1k]

Another useless biased list. So many coaches too high or too low.
However they need to write crap to earn their paycheck.

Well they certainly do need to write- that's what they do. Is it "biased"? Any attempt at this is subjective, but I wouldn't call it biased.

I thought it was a reasonable shot at it. Not perfect. They had some explanation to go along with it.

The top 10 on that list seemed about right, give or take.

I might have had MM about 14-15. He's not scaring anyone with his game planning. He does have a really solid team now.

 

[CowboyRoy]

MM 19th SeanP greatness....Make it make sense....

If you cant see how great of a coach SeanP is then thats on you.

 

[gtb1943]

I would probably put him top 10. Some of those this crappy list had above him frankly are a joke.

 

[CowboyFrog]

If you cant see how great of a coach SeanP is then thats on you.

I can see what has actually happened and they look like the same coach...

 

[CowboyRoy]

I can see what has actually happened and they look like the same coach...

To you maybe

 

[gtb1943]

I can see what has actually happened and they look like the same coach...

Both coaches only got one ring with a HOF QB in about the same number of years.

 

[rnr_honeybadger]

McCarthy might be one of the most hated coaches in the league today

 

[GMO415]

Anyone who puts NYG HC above MM is a moron and therefore their entire premise is flawed.

Subsequently, this list is dog @#$*

 

[ESisback]

This list is crap, invented to create debate and controversy. McCarthy has a ring and multiple winning seasons. Two reasons he’s rated so low—he’s the Cowboys’ HC, and he’s fat. Period. I have no time for any twisted belief system that says otherwise.

 

[CouchCoach]

If you cant see how great of a coach SeanP is then thats on you.

Watch the end of that playoff game before he was saved by the no call PI and tell me how great a coach he is. He would have owned the worst game management at the end of a playoff game in history.

He is the most overrated HC in the game and you will soon discover that in DEN.

 

[ESisback]

Watch the end of that playoff game before he was saved by the no call PI and tell me how great a coach he is. He would have owned the worst game management at the end of a playoff game in history.

He is the most overrated HC in the game and you will soon discover that in DEN.

Yeah, I’m baffled why Payton is such a genius, compared to the doofus ‘Big Mike’.

Dollars to donuts, had Payton come to Dallas, I wonder about his guru status….

 

[Jipper]

Back to back 12 win seasons as a hc and a playoff win...dumb ranking

 

[Robbieac]

Guys. MM has had back to back 12 win seasons to start his Dallas career……all while being handcuffed to a handicap at the QB position.

With those facts in mind, MM’s job performance thus far has been borderline spectacular.

 

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

Here's the recent ranking of head coaches by CBS:

CBS Head Coach Ranking

How do you view McCarthy's ranking?

I don't need to see those rankings.

I'll bet each coach is ranked according to his team's final 2022 record...plus or minus a couple spots.

Last year they had that knob Rams coach in top 2 or 3.

1 year later...I'll bet they have that same coach 15 to 20 spots lower...just because his team was less talented.

The people who make this Rankings just don't know football that well....or they're lazy.