Many various opinions, and I see points in all of them.
It is a loss, because he did protect the ball, however, even though he may have been a league leader, he wasn't breaking any long ones either. A few 50 yarders, but that's it. I remember him just getting about 20 yards then runs into a pile. Rarely hits (or gets) a hole to go through. And rarely, just seems lately, he cuts it to the outside. But then, too many times he cuts it back in...right into a pile.
Now, it's easy for us to say that, sitting on a bar stool or a couch. But I don't think we will see a huge difference in average starting field position. Just hang on to the ball.....
I don't think it was him as much as other plaayers not doing their part enough.
All said and done, I would raather him be back there. I have been feeling lately he was due to break one, he was getting closer.