Mailbag: What's The Missing Piece?

cowboyjoe

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,433
Reaction score
752
Mailbag: What's The Missing Piece?

I mentioned this in several posts about cowboys getting a few free agents or trades like the cowboys did in 92, when they traded for charles haley and thomas everett, read what the cowboys mailbag says, then give your own thoughts and viewpoints. Remember now, we can sign one top free agent, even Adam our cap guru said so.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

DallasCowboys.com Report
January 20, 2010 4:22 PM Change Font Size A A A A



• Vikings, Raucous Crowd Send Cowboys Home 1/17


(Editor's Note: Each day we will take the 2 best questions for our staff writers to answer from the Mailbag. "Click here" to email questions now.)

REESE COLE - SAN ANTONIO, TX: What's the missing piece? Which position do we need someone to step in to be this team's Charles Haley?

Rob: Great question. That's tough to answer because the Cowboys didn't seem to have many weaknesses before the Vikings game and there probably won't be many changes to the starting lineup. Other than offensive line depth, they need a kicker they trust. Shaun Suisham's two misses didn't cost them the game, but both were momentum killers. I'd like to see David Buehler get a shot to compete after an off-season of field goal work.

Nick: I don't think the Cowboys need a Charles Haley-type of addition to put this team over the top. Maybe I just see that because there aren't many players like that on the street. And you have to remember, Jerry took a chance on a shaky-character player like Haley. But it worked. So you can't fault him for trying to do that type of stuff again in guys like Pacman, T.O. and Tank. It has worked before. As for a missing piece, I really do think the Cowboys need a dynamic kick return specialist who can do both kicks and punts. Maybe he's a fourth WR or can play corner or safety as well. But give me a guy that knows how to return kicks and that can be his niche right away.

Josh: How about an awesome, ball-hawking safety? Gerald Sensabaugh gave the defense a new dimension because he could man up against tight ends and running backs split out wide, and Ken Hamlin is back there too, making sure nothing gets behind him. They were solid, and they didn't get beat very often, but how many plays did they really make? The defense still doesn't consistently create enough turnovers. I don't know how many Ed Reeds or Troy Polamalus there are out there, though.

STEVEN BOORAS - BATON ROUGE, LA: I have been supportive of Jason Garrett all year. Yes, I know it is easy to pile on the offensive coordinator after you get beat, but what do you think of his play-calling in Sunday's game? I was disappointed we didn't see any bubble screens or slants since Minnesota was putting so much pressure on Romo.

Rob: We've heard those suggestions, as well as having Romo roll out of the pocket. Tough to say that would work because the pressure was coming from everywhere. I was surprised Felix Jones wasn't in the game more in the second half - pass protection might've had something to do with that - but overall it's hard to call plays when your quarterback isn't being protected, as well as when you're constantly in third-and-longs because of negative plays.

Nick: Yes, I thought some of that could've been used. Overall, I think he called a decent game. But the Vikings just thrived on getting those negative plays that always seemed to occur around the 25-35-yard line. It just killed the drives and the Cowboys never could recover. But you can't really argue about the coordinator when the offense produces a franchise-record in yards for a season.

Josh: I thought Garrett was fine. When they lose that badly we tend to go back and say 'Where was this, where was that,' but I think the main reason they were so bad is the players weren't able to execute. Now, I have my suspicions that the pitch out to Marion Barber in the third quarter was something Romo audibled to, but that shouldn't even be an option. Not with Barber.
 

Rampage

Benched
Messages
24,117
Reaction score
2
it's not just 1 piece. on defense we need

2 new ILB's who can play coverage not just go forward.

1 playmaking safety(don't care if it's free or strong)

and guys in the secondary minus Mike Jenkins need to force more turnovers

on special teams we need a freaking reliable kicker

on offense we need

1 new/young LT who can also block speed rushers.

1 center that isn't dumb as a box of rocks

more youth for o-line depth.

find a #2 wr or Roy step his game up(doubtful)

Bennett to get his **** together

Barber to get less carries and Choice/Jones to get more

Garrett to run the ball more/call more playaction/get rid of that wildcat play/get better at making adjustments and go back to calling plays the way he did in december where we attacked the weaknesses of opposing defenses.

just to name a few things
 

dirt

Member
Messages
288
Reaction score
0
funny you should say a center that isnt as dumb as a box of rocks. I have thought for some time that Gurode is talented but there was a stretch of years previous that the OL just couldnt adjust to blitzes and that is mental. The center is supposed to be the cerebral member of the OL right? I have thought Gurode was lacking in that department for years!
 

Scranton Tiger

New Member
Messages
377
Reaction score
0
The first player I thought of was Ed Reed. Even if he is a free agent though, I would be shocked if he isn't franchised.
 

LandryFan

Proud Native Texan, USMC-1972-79, USN-1983-2000
Messages
7,400
Reaction score
6,347
Rampage;3247059 said:
it's not just 1 piece. on defense we need

2 new ILB's who can play coverage not just go forward.

1 playmaking safety(don't care if it's free or strong)

and guys in the secondary minus Mike Jenkins need to force more turnovers

on special teams we need a freaking reliable kicker

on offense we need

1 new/young LT who can also block speed rushers.

1 center that isn't dumb as a box of rocks

more youth for o-line depth.

find a #2 wr or Roy step his game up(doubtful)

Bennett to get his **** together

Barber to get less carries and Choice/Jones to get more

Garrett to run the ball more/call more playaction/get rid of that wildcat play/get better at making adjustments and go back to calling plays the way he did in december where we attacked the weaknesses of opposing defenses.

just to name a few things
Won't argue with a single thing you said, except to say "easier said than done" on all of that.
 

Doomsday

Rising Star
Messages
20,224
Reaction score
16,866
Rampage;3247059 said:
it's not just 1 piece. on defense we need

2 new ILB's who can play coverage not just go forward.

1 playmaking safety(don't care if it's free or strong)

and guys in the secondary minus Mike Jenkins need to force more turnovers

on special teams we need a freaking reliable kicker

on offense we need

1 new/young LT who can also block speed rushers.

1 center that isn't dumb as a box of rocks

more youth for o-line depth.

find a #2 wr or Roy step his game up(doubtful)

Bennett to get his **** together

Barber to get less carries and Choice/Jones to get more

Garrett to run the ball more/call more playaction/get rid of that wildcat play/get better at making adjustments and go back to calling plays the way he did in december where we attacked the weaknesses of opposing defenses.

just to name a few things

Would some one mind faxing this list over to Jerry? :laugh2:
 

WV Cowboy

Waitin' on the 6th
Messages
11,604
Reaction score
1,744
Rampage;3247059 said:
it's not just 1 piece. on defense we need

2 new ILB's who can play coverage not just go forward.

1 playmaking safety(don't care if it's free or strong)

and guys in the secondary minus Mike Jenkins need to force more turnovers

on special teams we need a freaking reliable kicker

on offense we need

1 new/young LT who can also block speed rushers.

1 center that isn't dumb as a box of rocks

more youth for o-line depth.

find a #2 wr or Roy step his game up(doubtful)

Bennett to get his **** together

Barber to get less carries and Choice/Jones to get more

Garrett to run the ball more/call more playaction/get rid of that wildcat play/get better at making adjustments and go back to calling plays the way he did in december where we attacked the weaknesses of opposing defenses.

just to name a few things

You can't do all of that in one off-season.

You are going to have to narrow down your list.
 

clutch88

Benched
Messages
639
Reaction score
0
cowboyjoe;3247034 said:
Mailbag: What's The Missing Piece?

I mentioned this in several posts about cowboys getting a few free agents or trades like the cowboys did in 92, when they traded for charles haley and thomas everett, read what the cowboys mailbag says, then give your own thoughts and viewpoints. Remember now, we can sign one top free agent, even Adam our cap guru said so.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

DallasCowboys.com Report
January 20, 2010 4:22 PM Change Font Size A A A A



• Vikings, Raucous Crowd Send Cowboys Home 1/17


(Editor's Note: Each day we will take the 2 best questions for our staff writers to answer from the Mailbag. "Click here" to email questions now.)

REESE COLE - SAN ANTONIO, TX: What's the missing piece? Which position do we need someone to step in to be this team's Charles Haley?

Rob: Great question. That's tough to answer because the Cowboys didn't seem to have many weaknesses before the Vikings game and there probably won't be many changes to the starting lineup. Other than offensive line depth, they need a kicker they trust. Shaun Suisham's two misses didn't cost them the game, but both were momentum killers. I'd like to see David Buehler get a shot to compete after an off-season of field goal work.

Nick: I don't think the Cowboys need a Charles Haley-type of addition to put this team over the top. Maybe I just see that because there aren't many players like that on the street. And you have to remember, Jerry took a chance on a shaky-character player like Haley. But it worked. So you can't fault him for trying to do that type of stuff again in guys like Pacman, T.O. and Tank. It has worked before. As for a missing piece, I really do think the Cowboys need a dynamic kick return specialist who can do both kicks and punts. Maybe he's a fourth WR or can play corner or safety as well. But give me a guy that knows how to return kicks and that can be his niche right away.

Josh: How about an awesome, ball-hawking safety? Gerald Sensabaugh gave the defense a new dimension because he could man up against tight ends and running backs split out wide, and Ken Hamlin is back there too, making sure nothing gets behind him. They were solid, and they didn't get beat very often, but how many plays did they really make? The defense still doesn't consistently create enough turnovers. I don't know how many Ed Reeds or Troy Polamalus there are out there, though.

STEVEN BOORAS - BATON ROUGE, LA: I have been supportive of Jason Garrett all year. Yes, I know it is easy to pile on the offensive coordinator after you get beat, but what do you think of his play-calling in Sunday's game? I was disappointed we didn't see any bubble screens or slants since Minnesota was putting so much pressure on Romo.

Rob: We've heard those suggestions, as well as having Romo roll out of the pocket. Tough to say that would work because the pressure was coming from everywhere. I was surprised Felix Jones wasn't in the game more in the second half - pass protection might've had something to do with that - but overall it's hard to call plays when your quarterback isn't being protected, as well as when you're constantly in third-and-longs because of negative plays.

Nick: Yes, I thought some of that could've been used. Overall, I think he called a decent game. But the Vikings just thrived on getting those negative plays that always seemed to occur around the 25-35-yard line. It just killed the drives and the Cowboys never could recover. But you can't really argue about the coordinator when the offense produces a franchise-record in yards for a season.

Josh: I thought Garrett was fine. When they lose that badly we tend to go back and say 'Where was this, where was that,' but I think the main reason they were so bad is the players weren't able to execute. Now, I have my suspicions that the pitch out to Marion Barber in the third quarter was something Romo audibled to, but that shouldn't even be an option. Not with Barber.
Lets start with a real GM, a real COACH, and any OC not named Garrett...that pretty much sums it up thanks.
 

DatNguyen59

Member
Messages
250
Reaction score
2
Its sad that we have two guys making huge amounts of money and their backups are more reliable than they are. :bang2:
 

utrunner07

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,326
Reaction score
262
Like it or not, what is missing is a real coach. With a real coach we win Sunday. Im talking a real OC or a real HC, we have a real DC.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
I would rather make one of our strengths even stronger. Dallas' pass rush is already very good, one more player could make it elite.

Vikings do not have better LBs, or even better secondary players. But their pass rush altho only a little bit better, is elite. It makes the entire defense dominant.

Of course a new kicker, oline depth and some ballhawking youngbloods at S and ILB all go without saying too.
 

CF74

Vet Min Plus
Messages
26,167
Reaction score
14,623
dirt;3247075 said:
funny you should say a center that isnt as dumb as a box of rocks. I have thought for some time that Gurode is talented but there was a stretch of years previous that the OL just couldnt adjust to blitzes and that is mental. The center is supposed to be the cerebral member of the OL right? I have thought Gurode was lacking in that department for years!

I thought this was his worst year ever and then I found out about his knee. I guess he was playing hurt, either way we need to draft a center in the 1st three rounds...
 

CF74

Vet Min Plus
Messages
26,167
Reaction score
14,623
utrunner07;3247533 said:
Like it or not, what is missing is a real coach. With a real coach we win Sunday. Im talking a real OC or a real HC, we have a real DC.

We need somebody that can call the offense and adjust offensively in the heat of the battle. Neither Wade nor Garrett can do this, no surprise the offense always loses the big games for us..
 

Fletch

To The Moon
Messages
18,395
Reaction score
14,042
Rampage;3247059 said:
it's not just 1 piece. on defense we need

2 new ILB's who can play coverage not just go forward.

1 playmaking safety(don't care if it's free or strong)

and guys in the secondary minus Mike Jenkins need to force more turnovers

on special teams we need a freaking reliable kicker

on offense we need

1 new/young LT who can also block speed rushers.

1 center that isn't dumb as a box of rocks

more youth for o-line depth.

find a #2 wr or Roy step his game up(doubtful)

Bennett to get his **** together

Barber to get less carries and Choice/Jones to get more

Garrett to run the ball more/call more playaction/get rid of that wildcat play/get better at making adjustments and go back to calling plays the way he did in december where we attacked the weaknesses of opposing defenses.

just to name a few things

Well put. I hope Martellus gets it going next season. That alone would be a huge step toward a championship.
 

pgreptom

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,798
Reaction score
551
Scranton Tiger;3247100 said:
The first player I thought of was Ed Reed. Even if he is a free agent though, I would be shocked if he isn't franchised.

He's mulling retirement last I read.
 
Top