Manning or Bledsoe.

[Cowboy Junkie]

The excuse of Manning not having the protection is ridiculous !!!
Anyone watching this years playoffs can clearly see that there is lots of pressure on all the QB's..
The defense's have picked things up a notch and if Manning is not capable of picking it up also , he will continue his ineffectivness , when the game gets to that playoff level.....

Throw his game stats around as much as you want ...The game told the story...
He made poor throws and even when not pressured he acted as if there was pressure...
Pitt started playing consevative a little too early...

Cowboy fans might remember in the 90's I wanted to face Farve anf not Young....

Farve always had the stats , but he always gave us the game before the stats came...

 

[joseephuss]

Manning is the better quarterback, but how would he be without his recievers, running back, and offensive line? No one will ever know. Come play off time though Bledsoe is better.

Manning
regular season 93.5 QB rating
playoffs 89.1 QB rating
-4.4 differential

Bledsoe
regular season 77.3 QB rating
playoffs 54.9 QB rating
-22.4 differential


Look at Brady and Aikman for a biased base line:

Brady
regular season 88.5 QB rating
playoffs 89.4 QB rating
+0.9 differential

Aikman
regular season 81.6 QB rating
playoffs 89.0 QB rating
+7.4 differential

 

[Dave_in-NC]

Zimmer

 

[Cowchips]

Im a big basher of Manning after yet another choke, but is this really up for debate. If we did have Manning, we would be set at QB for years. As much as I like Dungy as a coach, he had the same problem in Tampa, he couldnt get over the hump. With a coach like BP, Manning would be considerably better.


I will give Bledsoe a bit of a positive mark here though, he did win an AFC CHampionship game

He actually won 2

 

[DallasDomination]

Blesdsoe did good behind this line. Not so sure about Manning behind this line. He might get injured or soemthing.


Bledsoe in my eyes still has the better accuracy and long ball.

 

[Nors]

I think it comes down to this. Bledsoe has better leadership attributes. He's a stand up guy, never complains and has taken a team to the Bowl and won a 2nd AFC championship game on the road.

I think Bledsoe has gotten lessor teams far further than Manning ever has. Manning has some spoiled brat in him and he tends to act like a baby when spanked or toys taken away when he's playing in the big crib.

Bledsoe

 

[noshame]

Manning or Bledsoe?


I'll take Elway.

 

[Nors]

Manning on ESPN - they are talking about him whining and backstabbing Oline in public after game.

No leadership skills.

 

[yesfan]

I think it comes down to this. Bledsoe has better leadership attributes. He's a stand up guy, never complains and has taken a team to the Bowl and won a 2nd AFC championship game on the road.

I think Bledsoe has gotten lessor teams far further than Manning ever has. Manning has some spoiled brat in him and he tends to act like a baby when spanked or toys taken away when he's playing in the big crib.

Bledsoe

Manning might turn into Dan Marino without those receivers.Bledsoe somehow
gets nada for his abilities,Manning, they make it like he walks on water.

 

[shnagy]

I think Manning is possibly the worst clutch player in the NFL. However, i still take him over Bledsoe.