McShay's top 5 picks.

Messages
2,023
Reaction score
1
"The NFL's regular season is over and the playoff field is set, which means the top 20 of the NFL draft order is also locked in.

Our next full mock first round is still a couple weeks away, but here's a quick look at how I see the top five playing out right now.

All five of the players below are underclassmen who have until mid-January to decide whether they will enter the draft, so this is obviously subject to change. But as things stand today there is little question who the top pick would be.

1. Carolina Panthers -- Stanford QB Andrew Luck
Luck is the highest-graded quarterback since Matt Ryan in 2008 and will be the face of the franchise that drafts him for years to come.

2. Denver Broncos -- Auburn DT Nick Fairley
A versatile lineman with the ability to disrupt plays in the backfield, Fairley would help shore up a defense that has been a mess for some time now.

3. Buffalo Bills -- LSU CB Patrick Peterson
Peterson's combination of size, instincts and athleticism would be an instant upgrade for the Bills both on defense and in the return game.

4. Cincinnati Bengals -- Clemson DE Da'Quan Bowers
The Bengals managed only 27 sacks in 2010 and could use Bowers' quickness and athleticism off the edge, and he can also play the run, too.

5. Arizona Cardinals -- Missouri QB Blaine Gabbert
Gabbert has risen up the board late in the season thanks to the size, arm strength and pocket mobility to develop into an effective starter in the NFL."

Gabbert at 5? huh? Hope that happens.
 
I would love for Gabbert to become a darkhorse and find his way into the Top 8.

Push those prospects down!
 
Gabbert is going to need a good combine to show that he can transition from a shotgun offense to a pro style, under the center offense.
 
The changes have started. It should be interesting to see how the upper half of the 1st round shakes out in a few months.
Recall when Taylor Mays was a surefire top 10 (or even 5) pick? We often don't know what we think we know....uh, I think.
 
realtick;3780425 said:
I would love for Gabbert to become a darkhorse and find his way into the Top 8.

Push those prospects down!

Yep. Plus if Mallet and Newton get picked in the top 10? Beautiful.
 
CanuckCowboysFan;3780452 said:
Yep. Plus if Mallet and Newton get picked in the top 10? Beautiful.
The dream scenario!
If you look at who's picking, almost all (at the very least 5) of those teams will be considering QB at some point in the draft.
 

Cowboys Pick'em

DAL @ GB
Oct 18, 2026 at 7:20 PM
Make your pick
65 member(s) have picked so far. Picks are revealed at kickoff.
+ 12 more games to pick this week
Season leaders
The leaderboard starts filling in once the first games are graded. Get your picks in!

Survivor Pool

55 of 55 still standing
Week 6 · last kickoff Oct 19, 2026 at 7:15 PM
Join the pool

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
476,585
Messages
14,701,691
Members
24,234
Latest member
Justdatruth
Back
Top