Mel Kiper Grades (NFCE Only)

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
22,114
Reaction score
23,483
Cowboys B-

Top needs: Linebacker, wide receiver, defensive tackle

The Cowboys had clear needs in this draft, and there were more than three. After Anthony Hitchens signed a big-money deal with the Chiefs in free agency, Dallas knew it needed to find a middle linebacker. After the Cowboys cut Dez Bryant earlier this month, they had to target a wide receiver, even with the signings of Allen Hurns and Deonte Thompson. They needed to figure out whether La'el Collins was going to stick at right tackle or move back to left guard. They needed a one-technique defensive tackle. And they needed a tight end, which looks even more pressing now with Jason Witten on the brink of retirement.

So I can see what Jerry Jones & Co. did on the first two days of the draft. I had Bama linebacker Rashaan Evans higher on my board, but I can't deny Leighton Vander Esch's high ceiling. The Cowboys see him as a Rolando McClain-type middle linebacker, who can be a playmaker against the pass and stick backs behind the line of scrimmage. Vander Esch surged up boards after the combine, but he only had one great year of tape at Boise State.

I see Connor Williams as more likely to move inside to guard, so that means Collins could stick at tackle. And that's a good value at No. 50 -- Williams looked like a top-15 pick in 2016, but dipped a bit on play and measurables -- his arms are a little short. I said on Friday night that Dallas grabbing wide receiver Michael Gallup was one of my favorite picks of the third round. He's an underrated player, but don't expect him to replace Bryant. Dorance Armstrong Jr. (116) had an injury-plagued 2017 season but had 10 sacks in 2016. You trust defensive coordinator Rod Marinelli to get the best out of him. Dalton Schultz (137) isn't going to replace Witten, but at least Schultz isn't allergic to blocking. I thought Mike White (171) could have gone late in the second round, so that's a good pick. If Bo Scarbrough can play special teams, that's a good pick late in the seventh round.

Where was the defensive tackle, though? That's still a weakness, and maybe Dallas can find a street free agent to play a role. And if Witten does retire, do they have a starting-caliber tight end on the roster?

Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/19 Leighton Vander Esch ILB BOISE STATE
2/50 Connor Williams G TEXAS
3/81 Michael Gallup WR COLORADO STATE
4/116 Dorance Armstrong Jr. DE KANSAS
4/137 Dalton Schultz TE STANFORD
5/171 Mike White QB WESTERN KENTUCKY
6/193 Chris Covington OLB INDIANA
6/208 Cedrick Wilson WR BOISE STATE
7/236 Bo Scarbrough RB ALABAMA
 
Last edited:
Eagles A-

Top needs:
Offensive tackle, linebacker, wide receiver

It's good to be the Eagles. Coming off a Super Bowl title, they have no major needs and get to develop starters -- not try to draft plug-and-play guys. They're looking for impact depth. That's why we saw GM Howie Roseman trade out of the last pick in the first round to move down 20 spots and add an extra 2019 second-round pick (plus pick 125 in this draft). That 2019 pick is an extremely valuable one to stash away.

Now, you have to laugh at the Eagles trading up three spots to take tight end Dallas Goedert ahead of Dallas (49) with the draft in the Dallas area. And my best comp for Goedert all along was Zach Ertz, so now the Eagles have both players. Goedert is the best pass-catching and most athletic tight end in this class. Remember: Trey Burton and Brent Celek are both gone from 2018, so Goedert is going to play. Philadelphia led the league with 110 receptions by tight ends last season. If Goedert had gone late in Round 1 -- maybe to Philly! -- it wouldn't have surprised me.

The Eagles didn't have a third-round pick due to the Jordan Matthews-Ronald Darby swap with Buffalo last year, so Philly had just one pick on the first two days. Fourth-rounders Avonte Maddox (125) and Josh Sweat (130) are talented and athletic. Maddox was a four-year starter who ran a 4.39 at the combine. Sweat had 29 tackles for loss in college and had a 39.5-inch vertical jump at the combine. I moved up Matt Pryor (206) over the last few weeks after people in the league told me he was going to move to guard. And how about the Australian former rugby league player Jordan Mailata going late in the seventh round? Philly is going to try to make him an offensive tackle.

The reason this class isn't a straight "A"? Not a single running back (though they did announce the re-signing of Darren Sproles when the day ended). If that's the only bad thing I can say, the Eagles must have had a good day.

Round/Pick Name Pos College
2/49 Dallas Goedert TE SOUTH DAKOTA STATE
4/125 Avonte Maddox CB PITTSBURGH
4/130 Josh Sweat DE FLORIDA STATE
6/206 Matt Pryor OT TCU
7/233 Jordan Mailata OT South Sydney Rabbitohs
 
  • Like
Reactions: C42
Giants B

Top needs: Guard, quarterback, linebacker

You can love the player but question the pick. That's the issue with Saquon Barkley at No. 2. I always say to look for running backs after Round 1. That's where the value is. Look at last year. Dalvin Cook and Joe Mixon went in Round 2, and Kareem Hunt and Alvin Kamara went in Round 3. Those are fantastic three-down backs with much smaller contracts than Barkley. Barkley will probably be great -- and the Giants haven't had a 1,000-yard rusher since 2012 -- but he's taking hand-offs from a 37-year-old quarterback in Eli Manning, who has been objectively pretty bad in recent years for long stretches. So that's why I would have gone with Sam Darnold here. Get the quarterback who's going to take Eli's place because the Giants don't pick this early ever.

Again, though, I like the pick of Will Hernandez at the top of the second round (pick 34). He's going to help pave the way for Barkley, and he fills a need after losses in free agency. Lorenzo Carter (66) is a good outside linebacker who is a fit in New York's new 3-4 defense. I thought he could sneak into the top 40 picks after he ran a 4.50 40 at the combine. He's not a true pass-rusher, but he could play inside. B.J. Hill (69) is a powerful nose tackle who started 44 games at NC State.

Grabbing Kyle Lauletta at No. 108 is good value, but he doesn't have an NFL arm at this point. He's a touch passer, and he has to get stronger. He's going to compete with last year's third-round pick Davis Webb to back up Manning, and maybe the Giants will find their quarterback of the future there after a couple of years of development. RJ McIntosh (139) was one of my favorite underrated players, and he could be a steal. He's quick and athletic, and he has a motor. He'll likely play end.

Again, I'm not going to crush GM Dave Gettleman's first draft in charge of the Giants. I like the players he got, and we clearly have a different philosophy.

Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/2 Saquon Barkley RB PENN STATE
2/34 Will Hernandez G UTEP
3/66 Lorenzo Carter OLB GEORGIA
3/69 B.J. Hill DT NC STATE
4/108 Kyle Lauletta QB RICHMOND
5/139 RJ McIntosh DT MIAMI
 
Commanders B+

Top needs: Linebackers, defensive line, wide receiver

This is a good class, especially at the top. There was the biggest need filled with nose tackle Da'Ron Payne at No. 13. The Commanders had the worst rush defense in the league in 2017, surrendering 2,146 yards. And now Payne gets to partner up with a (hopefully) healthy Jonathan Allen, another Alabama defender who fell to Washington in Round 1 last year. Remember that Allen was looking like a Pro Bowl player before he got hurt. That D-line could be tough inside.

Then Washington upgraded its running game with Derrius Guice, my second-ranked back, who fell all the way to 59. Look, we don't know the exact reason why he dropped -- he has first-round talent -- but clearly teams were scared off by some questions. On the field, he's a really good player who can run over defenders with power and away from them with speed. When he replaced an injured Leonard Fournette in 2016, there was no drop-off, and he averaged 7.6 yards per carry. Also, fun note from my friends at ESPN Stats & Info: This is the eighth straight draft in which Washington has drafted a running back.

One of my favorite offensive tackles in this class is Geron Christian, who fell to Washington at 74 . He's raw, but he could be a starter at the next level. Safety Troy Apke (109) ran a blazing 4.34 40 at the combine, but he only started one season at Penn State. I graded him as a special-teamer and likely late Day 3 pick. Inside linebacker Shaun Dion Hamilton (197) has dealt with injuries, but he's a starting-caliber player if he can stay on the field. Defensive tackle Tim Settle (163) is a sleeper because the best version of him is a guy who goes much earlier. I had a fourth-round grade on Mr. Irrelevant, wide receiver Trey Quinn. That's a value pick at No. 256 for a slot receiver who caught 114 passes last season.

This isn't quite an "A," but it's close. I was surprised Washington waiting until the sixth round to grab a corner.

Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/13 Da'Ron Payne DT ALABAMA
2/59 Derrius Guice RB LSU
3/74 Geron Christian OT LOUISVILLE
4/109 Troy Apke S PENN STATE
5/163 Tim Settle DT VIRGINIA TECH
6/197 Shaun Dion Hamilton ILB ALABAMA
7/241 Greg Stroman CB VIRGINIA TECH
7/256 Trey Quinn WR SMU
 
Cowboys B-

Top needs: Linebacker, wide receiver, defensive tackle

The Cowboys had clear needs in this draft, and there were more than three. After Anthony Hitchens signed a big-money deal with the Chiefs in free agency, Dallas knew it needed to find a middle linebacker. After the Cowboys cut Dez Bryant earlier this month, they had to target a wide receiver, even with the signings of Allen Hurns and Deonte Thompson. They needed to figure out whether La'el Collins was going to stick at right tackle or move back to left guard. They needed a one-technique defensive tackle. And they needed a tight end, which looks even more pressing now with Jason Witten on the brink of retirement.

So I can see what Jerry Jones & Co. did on the first two days of the draft. I had Bama linebacker Rashaan Evans higher on my board, but I can't deny Leighton Vander Esch's high ceiling. The Cowboys see him as a Rolando McClain-type middle linebacker, who can be a playmaker against the pass and stick backs behind the line of scrimmage. Vander Esch surged up boards after the combine, but he only had one great year of tape at Boise State.

I see Connor Williams as more likely to move inside to guard, so that means Collins could stick at tackle. And that's a good value at No. 50 -- Williams looked like a top-15 pick in 2016, but dipped a bit on play and measurables -- his arms are a little short. I said on Friday night that Dallas grabbing wide receiver Michael Gallup was one of my favorite picks of the third round. He's an underrated player, but don't expect him to replace Bryant. Dorance Armstrong Jr. (116) had an injury-plagued 2017 season but had 10 sacks in 2016. You trust defensive coordinator Rod Marinelli to get the best out of him. Dalton Schultz (137) isn't going to replace Witten, but at least Schultz isn't allergic to blocking. I thought Mike White (171) could have gone late in the second round, so that's a good pick. If Bo Scarbrough can play special teams, that's a good pick late in the seventh round.

Where was the defensive tackle, though? That's still a weakness, and maybe Dallas can find a street free agent to play a role. And if Witten does retire, do they have a starting-caliber tight end on the roster?


Weird that he likes all of the picks and gives it a B-.

We weren’t picking top 5.. We did a pretty good job where we were.

We also bolstered our biggest strength with the Connor Williams pick.
 
Mel kiper is a strict needs guys,if he feels we havent addressed a position of need then he will give us bad grades.the thing is Dallas rarely addresses all its needs with the draft and they were never going to draft a Dt anyway.
 
Mel kiper is a strict needs guys,if he feels we havent addressed a position of need then he will give us bad grades.the thing is Dallas rarely addresses all its needs with the draft and they were never going to draft a Dt anyway.

The Eagles passed on their biggest position of need OT according to him for a backup TE yet they got an A-
 
Kiper makes me puke! Can't stand his face, I just want to punch that face.. I don't watch ESPN draft anymore, to boring.
 
I fail to see how the Eagles draft gets that grade. It was terrible IMO.

Not that I am complaining.
I agree with you. I did not think it was overly great and I am not trying to be a homer but I thought ours was better.
 
Weird that he likes all of the picks and gives it a B-.

We weren’t picking top 5.. We did a pretty good job where we were.

We also bolstered our biggest strength with the Connor Williams pick.

A little disappointed.
If Kiper had graded the Cowboys at a C or lower, then I’d have known it was a really good draft.
He is horrible!
 
I fail to see how the Eagles draft gets that grade. It was terrible IMO.

Not that I am complaining.
What was terrible about it?

One thing I wish is I wanted Bo in the 6th. You guys got him in the 7th. Could be a steal as a guy who could handle short yardage situations and give Zeke a breather every now and then.
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,658
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top