MMQB - How Ezekiel Elliott Could Cut Two Games Off Suspension, Sue Roger Goodell and NFL for Defamat

Plankton

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,256
Reaction score
18,644
https://www.si.com/nfl/2017/11/09/ezekiel-elliott-suspension-roger-goodell-defamation

Pursuant to the Second Circuit’s expedited review of Elliott’s appeal of Judge Failla’s ruling, a three-judge panel on the Second Circuit will hear oral arguments by attorneys for Elliott/NFLPA and the NFL on Dec. 1. The timing of how quickly the Second Circuit will rule following the Dec. 1 hearing is up to the three judges, but it’s possible that Elliott will hear before he serves the fifth or sixth game of his suspension.

Given that Elliott will miss at least four games, he will obviously not be able to “get those games back” if he later prevails in the appeal. This means that should Elliott ultimately prevail, the NFL would reimburse Elliott for missed games—a hollow victory, to be sure, but one that would still furnish Elliott some degree of vindication.

Yet Elliott’s chances for success on appeal of Judge Failla’s ruling fare also unfavorable. As has been explained throughout his legal saga, Elliott faces negative precedent in the Second Circuit because of the court’s 2016 ruling in the Tom Brady case. While the Elliott and Brady cases could hardly be more dissimilar in terms of underlying allegations, they are very closely aligned for purposes of the law. Indeed, Judge Failla repeatedly cited the Brady case in her ruling against Elliott.

In short, both the Brady and Elliott cases concern players arguing that their personal conduct suspensions were unlawful because these players were denied opportunities to review critical evidence and cross-examine key witnesses. In both cases, the NFL has insisted that the players demanded procedural rights that were not collectively bargained by their union, the NFLPA. The Brady precedent is a difficult one for Elliott to overcome.

Should his appeal fail, Elliott could request an en banc review from the Second Circuit. In such a review, all of the active judges on the court would hear his arguments. Unfortunately for Elliott, the Second Circuit hardly ever grants such reviews—in fact, they are granted less than one percent of the time. Similarly long odds would exist if Elliott later petitions the U.S. Supreme Court. It only takes about one percent of cases.

In reality, if Elliott loses at the Second Circuit, his case is over.
 

lukin2006

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,968
Reaction score
19,293
Elliot should have hired a publicist a year ago ...

The only way he stands a chance to clear his name is with a publicist and private investigator to investigate the case...
 

hornitosmonster

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,965
Reaction score
5,312
It's over, the best we can hope for is Jerry pushing Roger out of the NFL (ratings, protests, lying, Thursday night games, London Games, Mexico Games, etc). None of that is bringing new viewers in and the ratings continue to plummet. Advertisers would be wise to ask for cheaper prices. If the Cowboys are out of the Superbowl consider skipping the game. Dont' Watch, simple.
 
Messages
18,222
Reaction score
28,531
If you are innocent you fight to the end.
Zeke needs to sit the 6 games, but continue the legal fight however he wishes to clear his name.

If he wants to sue for defamation, go for it. I wish him the best of luck. I hope he wins.

But as for the 6 games, he needs to sit them out and be ready for December 24, when he returns.

This is now 2 separate issues:

1. The 6 game suspension
2. His name and reputation
 
Last edited:

ABQCOWBOY

Regular Joe....
Messages
58,929
Reaction score
27,716
He's not fighting for his innocence, he's trying to get the courts to allow him to play based on a denied procedural process..has nothing to do with his guilt or innocence, that's not before the court!!

Don't even try. This is a downward spiral that you will regret, almost immediately. You will end up frustrated your entire weekend. I'm telling you this for your own good. LOL........
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
He's not fighting for his innocence, he's trying to get the courts to allow him to play based on a denied procedural process..has nothing to do with his guilt or innocence, that's not before the court!!

But there is still the public perception of guilt or innocence if he does not fight.
 

The Quest for Six

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,612
Reaction score
20,825
Why don't you inform him of that because he said he was specifically fighting to clear his name!

You mean like how OJ Simpson if fighting to find the real killers of his ex wife and her friend???

I don't know what happened between Zeke and his Ex, but both seem to have issues.....I wasn't there and neither were you, but he's not fighting for whether he's innocent or not, that's the big mistake people on this forum seem to be making.....that's not before the court, he's only fighting to play on a denied procedural process....nothing more!
 
Messages
18,222
Reaction score
28,531
But there is still the public perception of guilt or innocence if he does not fight.
The public perception of guilt is a done deal, no matter what Zeke does.

Just go to fan boards of other teams and ask them what they think. The overwhelming majority will tell you he's guilty and many will say he's getting off easy.

That will never change.
 
Top