That's not polarizing though
For starters, fans have no impact on this. It's a panel of judges, the commissioner, former winners and current players...so honestly a lot of peers
I'm not sure who does the votes for this "award" but it's not a real group, it's fans and trolls, so I'd say the in the first group he is held in very high esteem and there's nothing polarizing about that
Now, among fans...specifically Dallas fans...yes, very polarizing. I 100% agree
But does the average Bills fan really care about Dak Prescott and his contract? No
I wouldn't even say Eagles fans hate him and his contract, they're probably like good, less money for better players